How to stop farmers from getting free shields

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Foghorn

LOL, you wont respond because you cant make a good argument against something Supercell themselves stopped.. I would really like to hear what you have to say about the wall spikes and why Supercell is punishing those who will keep using them (because they are useless now).
Also..... This thread is NOT mine, nor is this in any way my idea.... i am completely against this idea, it would never work.
I have made a few threads featuring different ideas on here recently...
1. Make the TH shield time 1 hour instead of 12. This would leave you open to more attacks if you leave it out, it also gives trophy chasers more free trophies. But i changed that idea to this one..
2. Award any player over 1500 trophies a small amount of gems for successfully defending their base. the more trophies you have the more gems you can get from a successful defense. This doesnt hurt farmers who put their TH outside, but it awards those who try to protect it. the gems at a 1500 level would be about 1-3 for a victory in a defense. around 2500 trophies maybe you could earn 20 gems from a good defense.
this wouldnt help the farmers below 1500, they cant earn any gems. So no one has a reason to drop to 200 trophies to win 10 attacks a night and get 10 free gems.
also i would suggest this idea replace the obstacle clearing one, seeing that there is already one way to get a tiny amount of free gems, supercell wouldnt have 2 ways. The one with the TH is more reasonable and its earned.

---

Completely against the idea? Lol your the only one defending it

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by xShadowLordx

Forget it, he little nub won't ever grow a pair nor will he grow a brain and finally understand that every game is never fair, players will always find a way to beat it, they aren't trying to make a dang game that isn't impossible to play! Ya know? They don't even need to have their TH outside, people can still put all their ♥♥♥♥ out side, get 40% and still gain a freaken shield without having their resource taken, you gunna complain about that too??? Seriously, the shield is there for everyone, if they take the shield from farmers then they take it from everyone, those who must get constantly attacked wont have time to fight back either.

There are so many ways to get a shield and stuff, stop whining. If you feel like they really need to get rid of the shield in the game then make a thread about shield removal comeon go ahead, because that's the only way, but oh wait, they won't because they won't get money if they take that away since they also gain money from having people buy shields.

you can still try, no one made a WallBreakers ai thread about how to make them easier, but I had friends who are tired of them so I made a thread, 12 or so hours later they announced that there would be an update for it. Who knows maybe they will listen to ya.

But seriously I never use WallBreakers, but because people complained about it, I just submitted it as an idea, I wasn't whining like you are now when it doesn't even concern you and how you do things.
farming doesn't concern me because I don't have to farm to make a profit, but nothing is wrong with how people do it either, does it change how I fight? Does it change how I play? No I doesnt.
does the shield benefit people? Yes it does it helps everyone.

farm helps players keep their resources, it also helps trophy hunters get 1star from town hall, and 1star from 50% it helps both sides. Use your head and stop whining

---

Sorry to disappoint you but people have been complaining about wall breaker AI for a while now, it likely wasnt stemmed from your thread.
I have made threads with my ideas, some agree and others disagree. Just because all of you enjoy the easy way out doesnt mean its right. Lots of people liked not being creative by making a wall spiked base, now supercell is making them play the game correctly and forcing them to be creative. Im not sure why they havent fixed the TH issue yet, but there are several issues to the game they still havent fixed, like mortars and wizard towers stalling and not firing. They will get around to it eventually. They cannot fix everything with one update.
But a game as great as this one should not have win-win scenarios. No great competitive game has a win-win scenario.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Mufasa

Completely against the idea? Lol your the only one defending it

---

im defending the idea that the TH shield is OP... not the original posters idea that there should be an extra wall around the TH to defend it more.
And will you not defend yourself about the wall spikes and explain why SuperCell nerfed it? I'm still waiting on your explanation as to why they fixed it.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by xShadowLordx

They would never accept this idea, supercell doesn't give anymore free gems then they already have, 1) gems to top 10 of the first 3 clans 2)gems to clearing obstacles
they aren't going to do something like that

---

please read the entire message before responding and sounding like an idiot.... i already said they would never give out a THIRD way to get free gems... thats why i said they sould get rid of the obstacle clearing one and substitute this one instead. how often do you win a defense? for me its once every couple days. thats less gems than i would get with the obstacle clearing one.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Foghorn

im defending the idea that the TH shield is OP... not the original posters idea that there should be an extra wall around the TH to defend it more.
And will you not defend yourself about the wall spikes and explain why SuperCell nerfed it? I'm still waiting on your explanation as to why they fixed it.

---

They nerfed it because it made wall breakers obsolete. Keeping your townhall outside doesn't make any area of the game obsolete.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Mufasa

They nerfed it because it made wall breakers obsolete. Keeping your townhall outside doesn't make any area of the game obsolete.

---

yes it does, it takes away MANY bases from being attacked properly, it also gets you out of being revenge attacked most of the time. That hurts farmers right there.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Foghorn

yes it does, it takes away MANY bases from being attacked properly, it also gets you out of being revenge attacked most of the time. That hurts farmers right there.

---

I never knew there was a proper way to attack.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Mufasa

Im almost tempted to respond but your just the type that keeps arguing for no reason. Make a better plan to stop people from leaving their th out or stop defending your idea.

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Mufasa

I never knew there was a proper way to attack.

---

You know what I'm talking about. An attack that's meant to beat your defenses.

Oops. Added an extra quote

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Clanmember14

Farmers are really annoying because they get a ton of money and then they put their town hall outside the walls. I thing that there should be some walls that are part of the town hall. Archers can not shoot over these walls, they must be broken to attack the town hall. These walls are very high so a dragon or balloon must destroy the walls first. It will not make the town hall take up more space there should just be walls that are right next to the town hall as you upgrade the town hall the walls are upgrade as well (just the ones around the th)

---

why do you care its just a sheild sometimes i break my free sheilds

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Stan2040

TH outside is a good tactic one was is for people to stop attacking it?

I do it my self same as I hide my elixir when I'm off line, that's the game of clans,

what I would say is make TH hold more stuff

say TH 9 holds 40,000 of each? Then they may think twice,
TH8 say 30,000

---

bad idea do just give up the fact that people put there th out

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Foghorn

Having wall spikes was also a good tactic.. But it ruins the idea of the game. You have a LOT of money, you should get attacked. Not be given a free shield.
I'm hoping they change the way the town hall works.

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Blackshadoo

I'm not saying this is a bad idea but overall to summarize what your saying is that you want to add another layer of protection to the town hall at no extra cost and, that make's it even more difficult for already difficult bases to be destroyed. I think that the new walls around the town hall would just give the defense buildings already in place more time to attack the enemy. If your attacking with dragons it just gives more time for the air defense (assuming it is placed smartly) to kill the dragons. Just need to consider the affect this would have on the overall gameplay, not just farming.

Thanks,

Shady

---