Printable View
clan wars is fun don't get me wrong but the strategy is just to beat up on the little guys. there should be a scaled reward system where if you can 3 star the best guy/girl in the other clan you get more than just 3 stars. while 3 starring the lowest member should have diminishing returns.
anyone else agree?
Our top guys don't hit the little guys because then there would be nothing left for our little guys!
Our top 25 hit theirs and our bottom 25 take care of the rest. Results in 100 stars and above per war.
How many stars are you getting out of interest?
There is also already the incentive of a bigger loot reward for attacking higher players.
i'm not talking about loot rewards, i'm talking about stars.Quote:
Originally Posted by 8raveStarr
ok good point. but say a big guy attacks a big guy and gets 1 star. then a little guy attacks a little guy and gets 1 star. it would be more efficient if the big guy just attacked the little guy to get 3 stars and just not have the little guy attack at all. see what i'm saying?Quote:
Originally Posted by Robmac
my clan is only about 10 people so the max is 30ish. is that what you're talking about?
It's fine as it is. Risk vs reward. If everyone hits the little bases, the Clan will lose, so there is balance & strategy.
Yet you implied there was no incentive at all for attacking higher players -- hence your title "No Incentive To Attack Higher Players in Clan Wars."
The higher loot is the incentive. If your guys are just attacking low players, they are missing out.
if you're going to nitpick my title and wording why reply? you're missing the point.Quote:
Originally Posted by 8raveStarr
there is no risk whatsoever to 3 starring a little base over 1 starring a big base i'm not seeing the balanceQuote:
Originally Posted by Akali
I totally disagree. I'm TH8 hitting TH9 and TH10 getting huge bonus because they farm and forgot to move their town hall in side their walls. I'm one starring two attacks on the top, and I'm getting 700k loot bonus (which is all my Clan Castle can hold until I upgrade). My clan strategizes though. Bottom players attack both times in first 4 hours. Middle of the clan attacks both times in next 8 hours. Then, the heavy hitters bat clean up using their first attacks on top level players and second attacks on improving one star wins or TH only attacks if possible. We have 35 members and have dominated both times. We have a Leader and two Co-Leaders and we require approval from one of them before attacking because the recommended target may not be the best target for the member. Our next Clan War ends tomorrow at eight if you're interested in joining a place where you could be used effectively.Quote:
Originally Posted by tdoshea90
The risk is your clan loses the war :cool:Quote:
Originally Posted by tdoshea90
Perhaps what is needed instead is to scale a (3x bigger) bonus in line with number of stars won.
So 1 star = 1 third of it, etc