Printable View
I think it would be helpful if we could choose who went to war with you in your clan. One reason being that some people don't want to do clan wars. And I'm not just going to kick someone because they don't like the new update. Also some of my lower level guys want to fight as well. So I was thinking when you choose to start a clan war it should give you the option of deciding who goes to war with you. Then the system would configure what clan you battle based on the members you chose.
That is a good idea but u dont know how May people on the other team
What do you mean?Quote:
Originally Posted by Tipmonster
He's trying to say that once you find a clan, they match you up with another clan with roughly the same amount of people.Quote:
Originally Posted by alpha9390
Or, before war the person starting it can make a head count. Have options. Minimum head count at least 10. 50 max.
This could lead to bad leaders not letting people fight in wars, even if they wanted to.Quote:
Originally Posted by KROM
This isn't fair for users, And matchmaking for people is random, everyone can participate even if the leader doesn't want them to, or not that specific person.
If it were that you just so happened to have a bad leader who wouldn't let you fight, then you could just leave the clan. I just want all my guys to be able to participate at one time or another. Plus it would encourage everyone to try harder. They could even possibly make it to where it will randomize who you bring to war with you.
This is the reason i came to the fourms..to share this idea. They need to do this. My members should have the option to set out of a war if they want to without droping a bunch of their trophies. Just give us a button beside our names on the clan list that lets the player "set out" or "fight" in clan wars. I know this will be done..but I hope you do this as soon as you can, SuperCell.
I think it would be a good idea for each person to be able to opt out of war rather than leaving the clan then rejoining once war is found
Bad leaders are going to neglect clan members that don't do anything wrong.Although this would sound like a good punishment when you disrespect co-leaders and leader and also elder this would be good to stop inactive players from playing in wars but there's alot of bad leaders and they like to treat there members and elders even co-leaders like ♥♥♥♥.So this cant happen
If your leader is like that then you NEED a new clan. Don't take ♥♥♥♥ like that on a video game.I'm a leader and my clan members and I vote about stuff..find a new clan,bro.. we already have ways to choose who fights or not so why can't it be easier for us? It's logical. But I'm sayin that the player should be able to choose if they want to set out of a war. Don't let the leader choose who fights. Let the player choose if they want to fight or not. That solves your big worry right there. You get what I'm sayin now right?
This has been posted already.
http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...or-War-Rosters
This is so very very important, at this time of year and over Christmas lots of people are on holiday and the last thing we want to do is break down a sucessful clan weve put a long time into developing! We need an opt in opt out solution for war! Its very very important!
I completely agree. If I go on vacation or am extremely busy with work, I should be able to have the common courtesy to toggle an "opt out" button regarding clan wars. Why this would be ruled out id never know. Secondly, I think the leader should be able to opt people out. Why not? If some hasn't been active, opt them out until they step it up. If someone makes a bad or selfish move? Opt them out. Really simple. This "what if my leader is mean" garbage is irrelevant. Find a new clanQuote:
Originally Posted by LeeAlexander
Absolutely its a ridiculous argument bad leaders = bad clan. As an adult clan we've been quite thorough so we have looked into the possibility of having a clan which wars and one which doesn't but thats effectively splitting the clan which is silly also we only go to war over the weekend so everyone knows the routine however people will still need to opt out here and there! Results in a lot more work for the leaders when the game should be fun not a chore! The simplest and most effective solution is out of our control and in the hands of supercell! Let's hope they come up with the goods!
Why was this old thread bumped...
Maybe a button so you can choose for yourself. If it's on, you want to battle in the next clan war. If it's off, you don't want to battle anymore(in a clan war). So you can't battle in any clan war until you set the button on "on"
Good lord, an intelligent reply on this. I have never understood the argument that "leaders will take advantage of this". Find a new clan if your leader is not leading correctly. In our two clans we would never opt someone out because of something like a bad attack. We train and work with our members. And I know many many clans like ours.Quote:
Originally Posted by TrenchFoot
But not having this option to take people out of the war is plain silly. We have to boot people on vacation or whatever the reason. And track it.
What I really don't understand is why supercell hasn't responded to this. In their initial outlay of features they where looking at implementing, this was one of them. All but two of those initial features have been added but not a word on this. Its not in the ruled out section or in the considered section. What gives with that?
This is the 100th time someone posted this i like the idea but you have to chose be4 you search...
How about every Co-leader, Leader and Elder have to agree to a "leave out"?Quote:
Originally Posted by LukeClashOfClans
Such as a notification in-chat gets sent for all elders/co-leaders/leader to accept.
The only problem is:
Friendly clans could create fake wars everyday and add some "Wars Won".
But it would be fun to do clan wars with friends :D
Yup, not only is this an older thread being added too but frankly, until Supercell actually replies to this and puts it on the "actively looking at" list or "ruled out" list, I would not mind seeing 100 more threads. I will continue to reply on each one.Quote:
Originally Posted by Oggi
there are of course counter arguments. While you might think its good for your clan (Which it obviously is) it may not be so good for the game *imo
http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...t-out-for-wars
Well thats what happens, the members affected can just leave and join a more better clanQuote:
Originally Posted by TurtleBandits
I wouldn't want to be in a clan with a leader like that, i would leave immediately, and thats what the members should do also.Quote:
Originally Posted by LukeClashOfClans
I agree with u completely, leaders cannot abuse this, it just makes warring more better, its better advantage for both clans when u know all of ur attacks r going to be used, in my clan i was send a message when the next war is usually giving 2 days time, but ppl still r unable to attack in the war did to vacations or anything else, and also there r ppl that r inactive but i dont want to kick them cuz their great members, so an opt out option would be nice, yes just cuz of a bad battle a guy shouldn't be taken out of the war, we dont do that in my clan but help all members, but sometimes we need to give those guys a break and regroup, this option will help everyone, and if a leader actually does abuse this by not letting ppl fight, then the member can just leave like many posted alreadyQuote:
Originally Posted by BigDarrick
How would u start a fake war? And win one?Quote:
Originally Posted by JustElisha