Clan Wars: Can Leaders and/or Co-Leaders Choose the Participants Please!?

Hi guys,

Hope everybody is enjoying the Clan Wars!

It seems there are so many questions and requests regarding the CW and I am about to add one more on that pile. I am wondering your thoughts on allowing Leaders/Co-Leaders to choose who to join the CW! Even members can be allowed to decide whether they want to take part in the next CW or not! I am sure some clans had few leavers after they signed up to CW or their members didn't want to take part in CW and delivered no attacks/ produced no star(a) in CW or left their TH outside for an easy star for the opponent clan! Or etc.


What do you think guys?

Cheers
Adam

Yes to both. I think leaders/co should be able to decide. Saves people who haven't been on in a day who won't get to attack during the war but clearly will be attacked, especially if matched to an extremely active clan.

And yes... everyone in the clan should get the option to decide if they wish to partake or not.

But leaving your TH outside on purpose? That ain't cool!!!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Lola00

Yes to both. I think leaders/co should be able to decide. Saves people who haven't been on in a day who won't get to attack during the war but clearly will be attacked, especially if matched to an extremely active clan.

And yes... everyone in the clan should get the option to decide if they wish to partake or not.

But leaving your TH outside on purpose? That ain't cool!!!

---

Hi Lola,

Its really nice to hear from you :)

Im not sure if you were in the clan when we had these CW issues, but it seems there's a need for this option for both clan members and the management part of their teams.

The system should be simple that first members press the join/skip CW button and then the leader/co-leaders pick who they wish to join the CW from the group of members who want to join CW. I don't know if it's possible to put such system in place, as I'm sure SC must have anticipated these sort of problems whilst working on the CW. Perhaps it's not possible or too complicated for SC to implement this?


Cheers
Adam

Lol,soon everyone will go clanless..

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by donoh7100

Lol,soon everyone will go clanless..

---

I wouldn't be surprised especially after hearing about the "clash" in clans over joining/not joining CW!!

members should be able to opt out them selves - and i think leader and leader only should be able to decide too.

some members are unable to participate in every war. this option is needed.

I agree with both great suggestions. First the member can choose to opt out, and the clan leader can bar anyone from cw. This will avoid having to kick people who are away temporary as well as allow people a chance to take a personal breather without being a liability.

Agreed. Leaders and Co-Leaders should be able to choose who can participate, AND out of those the leader/co-leaders have chosen, the members themselves decide about their own participation. That way no one takes misplaced blame for unrealized attacks or whatnot, because it's the members who ultimately decide if they participate, i.e. take responsibility.

My idea its all about time. Just like match making does now, inactive players are removed from eligibility. If any player on the roster has not been active in X amount of time, they are not given a spot in the war, just as they do not get matched normally.

Then for those that pass the first test, award spots on the roster based on activity. Make the least active players the ones to sit out. So if player Bob plays once a week but player Sue plays daily, Sue gets a spot over Bob. This way we ensure the most likely people to participate get into the war.

In my clan I have some inactive players that are good friends. They pop in once a week or every other week but don't really play. Prior to clan wars we never thought about asking them to leave but now it is vital to have every player in the war active.

I think my idea would remove the ability to have leaders stack the deck and make things the most fair.