Printable View
Note: base design was done because my girlfriend INSISTED on it. LoL.
Looking for constructive criticism to improve base.
Design was done during Clan War Preparation Day. Which is why TH is centered, I normally run a farm design.
I'll post both Clan War & Farming design.
Over 120+ views and no replies yet. I would have to assume thats a bad thing. >_<Quote:
Originally Posted by xTooX1337x
I would appreciate any feedback, positive or negative!
Please & thank you!!
I might use it once i get all my defences built but currently my lab and 2 xbows are building as i just got to townhall 9!
Thanks for the response!Quote:
Originally Posted by R3taliate
Give it a shot and tell me how it works for you!
So far, it's been doing well for me! Ten attacks, only one attack managed to star this base.
i know it's not the best but I think its good. :)
Your wizard towers are very exposed, if I were you I'd swap them around with the gold storages. Also the far left and far right air d's are pretty exposed but you'd probably have to do some reshaping to get them in closer. But other than that the base looks pretty good :)
OK, I'll respond. I don't know what you're trying to do with this base. Pretty design? OK, functional? I don't think so.
Defense-led troops (hogs, giants, balloons) are going to go right into your core and over the base. I'm not trying to be a downer I just don't know what you are trying to defend with this base.
I did not allow my wife or girlfriend to influence my base design. Neither of them know anything about CoC, troop AI, hit points, or DPS. Both think my skull walls are creepy.
i don't really have a girlfriend, just a wife, but the rest is true.
Thanks for the reply everyone! You all bring up great points!
Hettoman2 - good point about the wizard towers! They definitely work better when placed a bit deeper so they are not targeted so easily and you're right, the left & right are VERY exposed. The only two attacks to have completely 3 starred me attacked from those points.
SuperGramps - not a downer at all. I greatly appreciate all feedback! this base did start off simply for pretty design, like i said my girl insisted on it. After making it, I kinda liked it and simply wanted input on ways to improve it. It wasn't aimed to defended against any particular type of attack but that is probably its main downfall. maybe I can try to implement the 'fluff' defense tactic by moving units around?
RichardF - if you truly loved her.. She should influence your base design!
...I'm kidding of course. :p lol. I did it for the late night brownie points ;p
Quote:
Originally Posted by xTooX1337x
not worth....
Did you read the date of this thread? This is best left in the grave :PQuote:
Originally Posted by yatakitumbi
Hahaaaa :oQuote:
Originally Posted by RichardF