Best Out Of 3 AntiHog Bases?

While searching on the forums ive narrowed it down to 3 bases that seemed like the best choices to use for a Antihog base and also fair well against giants and other army compositions. I usually sit around 1500-1700 trophies and farm but with clan wars now, ill be putting my townhall in the middle for my war base. Hogs i presume, will be a highly used troop in wars, reason why im going for a antihog base.
The 3 bases ive came to are

Ringus:
http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...eansing-Design

The Black Whole (v2):
http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...-Hog-variation

Tsunami:
http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...d-to-Master-II

My goal is to still have an effective farming base to PROTECT GOLD & DARK ELIXIR, (I dont care if i loose normal elixir), have an effective defense base for clan wars, but be easily transferable between the two.
Any help would be greatly appreciated!!
If anyone needs my clan name to view my base its
Knights Table.
Im L{E}GIT

Anyone? I would really appreciate the help.

I use ringus right now and i crystal 2 only lost one defens ( mas drags). So I am sure the ringus(farm) should do u justice while u farm!

I would try the tsunami

Thanks for replies. I'll prolly test all 3 and go with the best. I'm liking the black hole so far. Not sure how it'll fair against tier 1 troop compositions with giants.

I have tried ringus and it didn't work for me, I think 82% if I remember correctly.
I have tried Black Hole and lost 75%.
i am trying Tsunami now and haven't been attacked with mass hogs yet
just 2 defenses: lost good amounts of loot, but no more then 55% base and only 1 star both times. (11 hogs, along with other ground troops)
BTW , I'm lvl 111 with maxed defenses And traps except walls which are all skulls and 2nd layer all Legos

Ghengis Khan - World Of Pain - Purple Lightning shield
4/11- 70% damage from 24 lvl 6 loons 65 lvl5 min lvl20 BK lvl25 Q

I use ringus. Switched to trophy ringus just before clan wars and I have not been attacked yet. Nothing, zero, zilch.
I might just leave that TH in there.
BTW I"m level 90 and each base I would imagine are better depending on your levels of defense. I've studied all three and ringus is the most complete to me and the best for early TH9. Good luck.

I've used them all ... tsunami was for me very badly after another 2 x 100% every time I had 5 wizz and five archers in my ck .. ringus was for me the best ..... good luck

I prefer to use Ringus as it is very clean-looking.

Won a few defenses around 2600, got destroyed above 2650.

Those hoggers in master 2 have no problems dismantling any of the above "anti hog" designs.

ive used ringus with pretty good results in clan wars 2 defense the base funnels all the giant and or hog to the the double giant bomb and instantly take out the hog, or really injures the giants so your splash damage will take them out. only real worry with it probably a mass dragon or gowiwi but it would be very difficult to 3 star