Well, I hope we don't go to war with your clan because at least half my clan can't receive troops.
I have the same issue in our first war. A bunch of people from various trophy levels got randomly placed on the bottom of the war map with town hall 5 icon and 0/0 donations, including myself - I was ranked 4 out of 48 in our clan and I am a co-leader. From other threads it seems leader/co-leader got excluded more than regular members.
Was this just a bug because of how active things were at the time? Was this as designed?
I was raiding during the time that the match was found, does this matter?
Wellllll my clan has full cc's however they are all full with what we had in them when the update happened.... It wont let us empty to donate or anything and i gemmed my cc and it wont show as 35 spaces only my previous 30. It also skipped a lot of my higher level town hall peeps and replaced em with lower levels so now the higher levels are spectating..... I also went to war yesterday at about 1630est and i got a message to my phone at around 2130est that we were at war with the same people from 5 hours previous so theres an obvious lag in the notification of it...... All the above is for my main clan and feeder clan but other than that seems to be working smooth so far
Preparation Day goes well, except for the order on the War Map. I'm below quite a few players with less strength and defences. Somehow this isn't calculated correctly yet. For the rest...supercool new feature these wars. Cheers to Supercell!
Our bases are in reasonable order based on strength. We did have higher ranked person randomly be put into spectator mode. Not being able to see who donated or dump the donated troops is definitely a problem. Not being able to send multiple or long clan mail is a problem.
People, especially right now, don't know how the wars work. Communicating is very difficult. Someone logs on and immediately donates giants to fill up the requests. Not malicious but they think the troops are for attacks and are trying to help out. As we can only send clan mail every 12 hours and it has to be short, there is no way to prevent this from happening except to suffer through many wars. Every time someone new comes in four pages of instructions need to be repeated.
I like the idea of the clan wars, but these are overly complicated. There is not enough structure in place to enforce proper preparation (request first, then donate, then change base layout, then change base layout back after prep timer expires, then attack a base nobody else is attacking that is as high as you can go and 3*, then wait for everyone else to attack, then get the next highest base that has not been 3*'d. There is also not enough information...who donated what troops, are the troops used for attack or defense (it's defense), when can you change your base design, what happens to the cc troops, what happens to traps, etc. I know a lot of this information is available but we do not have the tools to communicate it to our clans.