IS it even safe to recruit new members anymore?

Our clan were discussing last night about removing innactive players to make sure our clan is balanced for our future wars we take part in but then the issue of replacing those players came up and how every clan member was worried a new recruit could simply troll donate rubbish troops to our war castles then leave the clan to spoil our clan war.

Im surprised SCdidnt really think about this, of all the flaws so far with the new update this is by far the most game breaking.

What are people's thoughts on this and how are you going to deal with it?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Fragga

Our clan were discussing last night about removing innactive players to make sure our clan is balanced for our future wars we take part in but then the issue of replacing those players came up and how every clan member was worried a new recruit could simply troll donate rubbish troops to our war castles then leave the clan to spoil our clan war.

Im surprised SCdidnt really think about this, of all the flaws so far with the new update this is by far the most game breaking.

What are people's thoughts on this and how are you going to deal with it?

---

Don't recruit new people? My clan has 42 members and we are more than content with who we have. We had enough time to explain how we want to play in our clan and they act accordingly, which is very nice actually. No need for new members.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by trash1000

Don't recruit new people? My clan has 42 members and we are more than content with who we have. We had enough time to explain how we want to play in our clan and they act accordingly, which is very nice actually. No need for new members.

---

Sorry I don't see this being a long term solution to the problem, simply not recruiting new members to a clan over time will probably see the ultimate demise of it eventually.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Fragga

Im surprised SCdidnt really think about this, of all the flaws so far with the new update this is by far the most game breaking.

---

+2!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Fragga

What are people's thoughts on this and how are you going to deal with it?

---

There is no way to deal with it. You have to make sure everyone follows the Clan Rules, which you can't. :(
Even worse: You can't recruit new players, as you cannot see their Army Camp troops (e.g. if they have Archers Lv 5..)
It's up to SC to add an option to remove troops from your War Base.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by kaze

It's up to SC to add an option to remove troops from your War Base.

---

Or at least tell you who donated what so you can kick them

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Fragga

Sorry I don't see this being a long term solution to the problem, simply not recruiting new members to a clan over time will probably see the ultimate demise of it eventually.

---

Why should it? As long as your mates are actively playing and chatting, you will have a nice atmosphere in your clan and you will gain stronger. Won't lead to demise.
And if you want to recruit new members, no one forces you to go into war. Recruit new members, explain what you expect from them in your clan and then wait a few days before going to war again, so they can accomodate to your clan.
Of course you need to close your clan for this.