Why is it that 2 out of my 4 co-leaders haven't been selected for our1st clan war? They are both very active and we are disadvantaged not having them. Can I change this??? Mod please answer!!!
Printable View
Why is it that 2 out of my 4 co-leaders haven't been selected for our1st clan war? They are both very active and we are disadvantaged not having them. Can I change this??? Mod please answer!!!
In my clan, it randomly skipped a couple people so they can't be in clan wars. They have been in the clan the whole time and are not last 5 people in the clan..
We have a similar problem... 14 of us are sitting out of a 45v45 clan war. It makes no sense that so many of us are spectating, it'd be great if someone could shed some light on this.
There is not way to change this. Sorry.Quote:
Originally Posted by Cotupacs
Depends on your war size. What is the size? Check out the FAQs stickied above, you may find your answer there.
There are about 44 active in the war including people that joined our clan two days ago, yet two guys that have been with us over a year aren't in it!!!Quote:
Originally Posted by SuperSteve[Supercell]
Quote:
Originally Posted by Noodle
exactly the same here. 14 of our bases are shown as a th4 and people cannot donate to us. we are able to donate to them.
why did it randomly exclude us?? ♥♥♥ is wrong ?
Are they the lowest in cups in your clan? Sounds like the matchmaking hasn't really been thought out very well as who gets to play...Quote:
Originally Posted by Cotupacs
we are in the same situation. we have 31 members and in a 30v30. 30 bases on each war screen. but bottom 5 are at a th2 looking th when they are th 7-10 and our lowest member isnt on the war screen (which was expected). they are not on the bottom of our clan list either and their clan request is 0/0. does this mean they are inactive? or a bug thats getting fixed? pretty much what does that mean when they show up as a lower th with 0/0 troop request. thanks!
none of the people whose bases are shown as th4 have lowest cups.Quote:
Originally Posted by Beagle21
Ouch maybe I am better off with the whole clan stuck in spectator mood, I would be bumming if I had to sit out my clans ever first war:mad:Quote:
Originally Posted by goodburner
a very annoying glitch that many almost all the clans have. ANY ANSWERS SC?????
Quote:
Originally Posted by Beagle21
one of my friends told it was because my base wasn't worth enough, i donated 5 wall breakers to his war base. Damn, I feel like i'm 12 years old.
SC why did you randomly skip my base? Please answer
our highest player is a th10 with 2800 cups, he's not included! we're 50vs50 so no way should anyone be excluded :(Quote:
Originally Posted by goodburner
Ok, instead of complaining, let's try to find answers ourselves. The most obvious one: maybe it excludes people who haven't gotten the new update. If anyone can prove this wrong, that's great, there are plenty of other options: for example, perhaps it excludes people not randomly, but specifically to make the clans as evenly matched as possible. Supercell might not even know what's going on, it would be great if we could work together and find it out ourselves.
Lol, I see a lot of gobs and wb in your CC going forward!Quote:
Originally Posted by goodburner
If you read the 3rd reply from the mod you could of saved yourself from writing out this lame responseQuote:
Originally Posted by MrScribbler
I read the reply. I think he was wrong, and there's some glitch that is making things work differently than the FAQs say. If you're satisfied with Steve's response, great, if not, there are constructive things we can do.Quote:
Originally Posted by Cotupacs
:confused: He is a paid employee of SupercellQuote:
Originally Posted by MrScribbler
Exact same problem... I'm quite angry that I won't be participating in our first clan war, and it doesn't make much sense either. It's literally the exact same problem as you. In our clan 14 are sitting out, and in the other clan 19 are. This even makes the number of people on the sides uneven, 30 on the other team and 35 for us. 30v35 war in a 45v45 clan war is just infuriating! I know that this may be hard to fix, but hopefully it will be focused on.Quote:
Originally Posted by Noodle
Another note: Scribbler, I don't think it's people who haven't gotten the update. Over half of the people not included have gotten the update.
Picked this up: I believe it is heavily, heavily glitched. Although there are 14 not participating, leaving our number at 35, in the war maps there are 45 bases. Now, our clan is 49 people strong, and our enemy is 48 strong. On both war maps, it shows 45 people in, but only 35 have shields and are able to participate. So let's team up and figure this out, guys!
So first of all, there are only a certain number of people who can receive troops in war bases, (the ones without shields CAN NOT), however, it seems that the numbers don't add up. In the war map section, there are 45v45, but in the clans (people with the sword clashing shields) it is a 29v35. I don't think that there will be an uneven amount of people warring, so the people without shields might just not be able to receive any troops during prep. day? I have no idea. If anyone determines anything else, please put it here.
Yet another post, sorry if this is spam.
---Shields refer to shields in front of players and under/background of their placing in terms of trophies in their clan, also known as "x-sword shields"---
Another add-on: Lowest few (in terms of trophies) don't have shields, and are not on the war maps at all. The number of players in this area can be determined by a simple formula,
(# Clan Members)-(Number of people in war, i.e 45v45)=Number sitting out, these will be from the lowest trophies.
Random number (don't know how it's determined) not eligible for donations for the time being AND don't have shields. New players of course don't have shields.
Smart;)Quote:
Originally Posted by MrScribbler
To the OP: I am currently in Centum Juvenis and we are involved in a war. We do not see anyone not being able to participate.............
What are you 12 years old? The supercell employee didn't say anything relevant to what this person said! He just said there is no fix. I think this is entirely reasonable, and would place my money on the fact that it is the people thst just haven't updated yet. Since everyone in my clan is updated and those who haven't arent included.Quote:
Originally Posted by Cotupacs
on the other hand, people are reporting just being spectators, in which case they have updated. Therefore, this is not necessarily true!
No i did not just contradict myself :P
however, it was a smart theory, so kudos to you!
Check the bottom of the war map (friendly) there should be a certain number of town hall 4 bases, and in the clan itself there should be a few people without the x-sword shields.Quote:
Originally Posted by GameloverHD
Way to think for yourself and not just complain!Quote:
Originally Posted by MrScribbler
Smart theory, wish I had thought of it :D although I proved it wrong... Sorry
I hate responses like this.... you had the opportunity to answer the question however you chose to cite a 700 page thread and expect us to find the answer?Quote:
Originally Posted by SuperSteve[Supercell]
You work for supercell, why not provide information or if you don't want to type it out over and over again, at least quote a specific post...
Here's another theory,
I started looking at those in my clan with the shields and they had defense troops donated to them and the ones without shields have an empty clan castle (in the clan wars board), maybe i need someone to donate to me so I can validate this...
anyone else can do the same and post here with the results.
can you guys verify this???Quote:
Originally Posted by sisterlimonpot
@sister, verified.
Seems to be the way these days with many businesses.Quote:
Originally Posted by sisterlimonpot
Since you are not in the clan war people can't donate to you and that is why everyone without the shield has 0/0 troops.Quote:
Originally Posted by sisterlimonpot