Finally, my clan is able to battle!!! Thanks for fixing it!
Printable View
Finally, my clan is able to battle!!! Thanks for fixing it!
I have seen many system lockups tonight.
I was not able to do replays or visit bases.
I could still collect my loot.
This must be a server issue with your system.
it locked up and booted me out of the game. Then I was raided. Thanks a lot.
Please fix.
+1 to the following:
- Saved base layouts for fast switching.
- Ability to "lock in" your war base manually at any point during the prep day.
- Ability to see who donated to War Base CC's.
- Ability to dump War Base CC during prep day.
- Require approval of War Base CC troops before accepted into CC?
- If a member leaves after a war has started (prep day), the next member "on the bench" should take his/her place in the war. We had two hoppers leave today after matched in our first war and two long time members are stuck spectating even though we currently have 46 members. So we'll be fighting with 43 attackers but we have 3 people sitting out!!
- Ability for Leaders/Co-Leaders to "assign" or "suggest" or "mark" opponents to clan members, some sort of flag system or something. Organizing who will attack whom is proving to be near impossible.
- Clan War shared chat so warring clans can have friendly chatter/trash talk during war.
Can't wait to get our first war day under way tomorrow!
Wouldn't everyone just attack the weakest member from the opposing clan and get the three star?
why not make a button for clan members to confirm if they are willing to take part in the clan war or not b4 the system matching work?
I'm excited about the update but im having a problem. We have our match i assume it would be called 50/50. Enemy has 50 we have 48 so i would assume they would have two to sit out but we have 9 players that r grayed out with no shield/ sword badge and we can not donate them troops. War starts in 16 hrs. How do i resolve?
I really don't think it's fair that many people are already able to go to war while there are countless clans stuck in spectator mode. Supercell really should have gone into maintenance as soon as it became clear that there were issues.
Has anybody been able to get out of spectator mode yet???
So as to shorten the 24hour prep day, SC, pls place a ready button on each warring member. We can press this button to let the system know we are ready for battle and not to have us wait for the longest 24hours of our lives. When this Ready Button is pressed by each participating member on both sides then that would signal that everyone is ready for battle day and we could all proceed to battle, not waiting anymore for the 24hours to finish.
When everyone is all pumped out for clan wars, believe me sc, the preparation hastens and is just really quick because well yeah everyone is excited! Even when they are of different timezones. Trust us on this one, sc.
basically what i want to b able to do is , make my war base donate wall my troops then submit my war base and then be able to carry on until war day as if it was a regular day i don't want to have to wait until the timer runs out for it to take a snapshot of my base or to wait for the right time to get a long enough shield where i can change my base and wait for prep day to end
The only bad part about clan wars is the fact that if someone leaves, their spot isn't taken by the next spectator on deck. I understand that the clans were matched up based on the base layouts of the top members during the sesrch, and that putting in a different person as a substitute would create a mismatch, but it sucks to see people left out, especially when there is room for them to participate and you are forced to fight with 1 less man.
Hi, we have problems, we appear like lookers, and I dont want a war (I'm leader) ...please Help us!!!!! Pd: Excuse me, I dont speak english! GRETTINGS FROM COSTA RICA
- We want better way to communication between classmates for strategy. The leader message is TOO short. And Clan Chat is INEFFECTIVE. Maybe a page to POST Clan's Rule/Strategy for everyone to read.
- We want an option to accept/decline Troops donate to us in clan castle in clan war
- We want Save As Clan War Map option in Village Edit Mode ASAP so we can Save one map as Clan War Map and we don't have to switch back and forth. This is VERY IMPORTANT
Thumb up and copy this message around so SuperCell sees it, please!!!
I've seen lots of complaining about wanting to be able to dump bad/unwanted troops from your war base, but I have a different idea.
A nice feature to have would be the ability to see who donated which troops. That way leaders, co-leaders, and elders can kick out trolls. Or help misguided members understand what they did wrong.
Great job Supercell. Our clan has always been a very active clan that really enjoys the game. But, this? This update? Like ...seriously.... Amazing! You really proved that you listen to the fans and care anout what we ask for. Much appreciated!
The best way would be to allow members to be able to put a block on troops they do not want. In fact that is how donations should have been the day they introduced the custom message.
So if you want only Archers, Wizards or Dragons. They would be the ONLY troops anyone could possibly donate to you, the remainder will have a red cross on them and be impossible to donate.
+1 to these for the next update :)
Also I would like to report a bug, in our 45 vs 45 match we have 16 villages on both sides that cant receive any troops, have wrong th icon (all have the same low level th icon on war map despite in reality having th9,8,7...) and are on the bottom despite some of them being some of our best players.
Also matchmaking is kinda broken, our enemy has definitely way better defense than we have, 5+ have xbows, one has infernos and nobody from our clan has any of those (we only have 2 premature th9 with barely th8 defense and troops, i have the best offense and defense in my clan despite being far from a maxxed th8), also all of them are th7+ except one but we have several th6... Our only hope is most of them will be inactive or they have poor offense :P
Clan war SVK versus MadeInSoverato.
We've got a clan of about 20 people or so who transitioned from another game about a year ago. We're a tight knit group of friends though over time, we've added about 10-15 other people to our clan.
Clan Wars hits and some s*** head is donating goblins and we can't tell for certain who it is. The update is great overall, don't get me wrong. I would just really like to see this adjusted. :)
5 of our best members aren't in the war, including our leader! hmmmmm
i have a question if someone can give me an answer. It is been told that, Heroes and defense that are being upgraded will be effective in clan wars. So they will all be there for defense. How about in attack? Is a upgrading hero will be available in an clan wars attack?
Thanks
Showing who donated will isolate those idiots not following requests.
Hi Marika,
one question. I'm on the 7th place in my clan, but i'm not an active part in our first clan war. Can you explain to me, what's the reason, that i can't fight in our first clan war?
TYVM
Yours sincerely
IGN: Baileys_2010
Clan: Grandfathers
TH 9
Just wanted to thank supercell for bringing out such an amazing update! Looking forward to fighting against Italian Army 0 in our first clan war! :D
Still seeing the "war spectator" screen. My clan is getting restless. They want WAR!
1. Give us the ability to change the troops donated to clan members on the War Map and also let us see who donated to us (this should be added to normal clan castle as well). Many people have been complaining about members donating awful troops to their war bases and I don't see any reason why we can't get rid of them and have new troops donated.
2. Add something I like to call War Planning. So we have the ability to scout and all, but I think it would be cool if we were able to mark or target the person on the war map we intend to attack. It would make clans a lot more organized by giving us the ability to see who wants to attack who.
3. So I see that Supercell has these "Clan Flags" on the new loading screen and I think it would be cool if they were put to use. If you attack someone in Clan Wars and 3-star their base, one of your troops will pull out your Clan Flag at the end of the battle and stab it into the ground with fierce momentum. As if they're saying, "You've been conquered!"
4. Add Clan Levels and perks for being in that clan. For Example: Your clan is level 10 and your current perks are +5% gold and elixir production (so it would kind of be like the statues in Boom Beach:cool:). Clan Levels are determined by wars won and toughness of member's bases. Clan Level would also determine the matchmaking for what clan your matched up against in Clan Wars. So even if their is a high level clan but they just aren't good at winning wars, they won't always get matched up to a similar clan in toughness that has won 20 wars in a row. (Does that make sense? lol)
5. Clan Wars leaderboards. Have leaderboards (with gem rewards) for Clan Wars depending on how many wars are won with your clan during the two week period. This would also give some of the lower level people a chance to win gems through the leaderboards.
6. On the clan's profile in that empty space next to the "EDIT" button, it should say who the clan is currently at war against (of course unless they're not at war) and then also show who won. It would be cool to see Quantam's Web matched up against Mega and see who won the war.
7. Ok this one kind of ties into Clan Wars but not really. The ability to save base layouts. Yeah this has been mentioned a million times but it would make preparing for Clan Wars a lot easier if you could just select the base you wanted for defense.
8. We should have a War Chat so we can talk to the other clan we're against during war. It would be really fun to see their perspective of everything.
I didn't add "make preparation day shorter" because the majority of the Clashing Community isn't on 24/7 and most people need the full day to prepare.
How are my ideas? Bad, good, ugly? Any ideas I should add? Are there any mistakes you've found to discredit my ideas? If so, please comment so I can make changes. ;)
Love it! All of it! Great ideas ^^^
we have been matched with a more powerful clan..this is not a good matching..
We tried to start war over 8 hrs ago- still nothing and entire clan are just spectators?!? We are ready to wage war baby!!... As soon as this is fixed, of course.
We are in our preparation stage and it's looking good found 3 targets with townhalls put side so hopefully it stays that way.
How about CC defence troops being requested rather than there for everyhwere to fill up - to go along with the other suggestions of selecting only the troops and levels you want donated etc
- OPT out. I have zero interest in being in every war that leaders & Co will be signing us up for. It's not exactly fair that we should be forced into battling if we don't want. And no, I don't want to drop to bronze just so that I can be counted out of CW. And no I don't want to leave the clan every time either. We have donation battles so leaving constantly isn't a solution. Leaders & Co shouldn't get to decide how the rest of the members in a clan play the game.
- Dump troops - enough said.
- Who donated to me?
- Remove the ability for clan members to be able to spam others with troops. Bring the old fashioned request for troops into CW.
Please remove the preparation phase. Donations could be done during the battle phase. Preparation phase lasts forever and this is quite frustrating.
Another thing is that we can only do two raids in 24h. This is too little, given that one raid only lasts 3minutes. We should be allowed to do as many raids as we like, or at least more than two.
I thought you said the layout of the bases will be TOP - STRONGEST / BOTTOM - WEAKEST?
We have a couple Max def th9 with Lava walls but they are 4th/5th in clan and a much weaker th9 is top?
Sure i read that its base from strongest to weakest to you can find your enemys base which is similiar to your strenght???
Hai marika just with when you get donated troops for the war can we like dispose them so we can get different ones it would be very helpful :)
Hello Supercell Staff,
first of all thank you for the Clanwars. It seems to be an interesting thing for our clanmembers and I think it will strengthen the clan as people work together and have a common goal instead of just farming their own base.
Now for some feedback from M-Power clan :
right after the server manintenance, we started the search for an opponent.
We had 39 members in the clan at that time, so the system was looking for a 35 vs 35 match. Sounds alright to me.
After about 45 minutes, an opponent was found for a 35 vs 35 match.
Strength of our opponent seems reasonable.
While we have some stronger members than their strongest, we also have some weaker members than their weakest.
The explanations on how clanwars work (when pressing the blue 'i' Symbol) seem comprehensable to me. There is a mistake in the German translation (again....). I will post a screenshot in ther thread I once made about the mistakes in the German translation of the loading screen messages.
oddities/bugs :
- Not all participants in the war have a sword symobol in the member list of the clan.
- two of our TH9 players are depicted as TH5 players in the war map and way down in the south of the map
- I could not find a 'recommended target' to attack. I heard in a video that something like that should be there.
- Some people received donations. Now they suddenly can request again. But to others it just shows 0/0 donations possible.
Oh and we had a person join our clan right before the search for an opponent started. He left this morning. Now he will be missing in our clanwars.
Suggestion: People should only be eligible to partake in a clanwar after being a clanmember for one week.
I will post more feedback once we have fought the clanwar !
What happens if someone leaves during the clan war prep day? I assume they get taken off the war map but then does the war carry on as 50 vs 50 with us having one member short?
Really appreciate the update Supercell!:D I really want to emphasise how important it is to implement a button to remove unwanted troops or set up some sort of donation logs so we can keep track of who donated what. Because having goblins and giants in our war castles is NOT a good idea!
im having the same problem. The members who dont have a sword symbol next to their name are further down in the war map and cannot receive any troops(im one of them).
I think they're not allowed to attack in the war?
i am a th10 but depicted as a th5.
What is the spectator mode everyone is talking about. Am i a spectator in this war? Im confused pls help
And,
THANK YOU SUPERCELL FOR CLAN WARS!!!!!
Gj. wp. nicely done. great effort. WOOP!! WOOP!!
My clan started a battle and I noticed a guy that in the preparation day he started 2x Inferno Tower level 1 and 3rd X-Bow to level 1. If I look on the war base I see his IT and X-Bow up and ready for battle and that's unfair. I get it to make the heroes or a defense at the last level to be active in the battle but this is a HUGE advantage on his side and unfair towards others.
Thank you so much for the great feedback and report!!! Many of the bugs are unfortunately happening due to yesterday's server mayhem, but those'll be fixed with today's maintenance break :) And you'll see your recommended target as soon as the War Day starts :) :)
+1 here and some are donating w.breakers damn..
Stuck at the spectator screen since release.. . Clan is not happy!!
It would be great if you could allow us some way to empty the "war cc" during the prep phase, in case we receive troops that we don't want to use for defense during the attack phase of the war.
I can't change my war layout and I have the farming layout of my village :(
how can I change it??
I'd like to see this too. Also, so far as I can tell, you can't see when the troops have been donated without actually checking the CC. It would be nice to know when so you can say thanks.
Totally agree.
I'm actually glad we can't dump the CC as it separates disciplined clans from the rabble but we need to be able to check who's mucking things up.
- We want better way to communication between classmates for strategy. The leader message is TOO short. And Clan Chat is INEFFECTIVE. Maybe a page to POST Clan's Rule/Strategy for everyone to read.
- We want an option to accept/decline Troops donate to us in clan castle in clan war
- We want Save As Clan War Map option in Village Edit Mode ASAP so we can Save one map as Clan War Map and we don't have to switch back and forth. This is VERY IMPORTANT
Thumb up and copy this message around so SuperCell sees it, please!!!
First run through of this. Day 1. Can you please have someway to edit the war base or at least give an option to "refresh" or "update" it to your current normal base layout? Beyond the scope of farming/defense/hybrid bases; some people change their layouts depending on what is currently upgrading. For instance, i put whatever current defensive structure that is upgrading outside my main walls so that it distracts attackers. In my war base, the structure is not upgrading and is completely exposed.
Also, possibly allowing other clan members to setup war bases for their clan-mates? This seems like an over-step, but it would be helpful (however can lead to arguments).
Outside of these few things, everything looks great!
Thanks people!
+1 about 10 people got hogriders
We are about to start the clan wars. Loyal and active players join Bad Boy Club if you have lvl 5 troops minimum. Cheers and happy warring!
Its stated thatThe bases are ordered from highest to lowest strength. The highest strength war bases are at the top of the war map. Trophies have no influence on the order of bases.
Is it really true as i cant see that happening in my clan's war map.
Some of us have TH lvl8 and placed at the bottom of the tree and some lvl 6-7 guys are ahead of us.
Is it a bug or something.
Again whats the logic behind not showing the clanwar symbol for some participating members of the clan in the clan description.
Let me first say I am thrilled with this new aspect of gameplay. It is a breath of fresh air....Thank you!
Now, let me say it is awful that you can't save your war base. Who can be bothered to rearrange from war base to farm base every couple days??? I know many of my fellow clanmates will not take the time to tediously rearrange their bases.
How is it possible that this could have not been foreseen by supercell? It was obvious to hundreds of forumers within minutes...
Please SC do not wait a month or more to add this feature, I think many clans will not partake nor enjoy clan wars like it should be without this feature.
As a clan leader, the war which is all about coordination is very hard to coordinate! The ability to send 1 clan message of limited length every 12 hours is too restricting as with 50 people in clan chat all in different timezones, there is now way to universally communicate in game to coordinate a war effectively. An addition of a war FAQ written by the leader at the start would be helpful.
2nd, the ability to not save bases is annoying
3rd the ability to not empty your war cc if people made mistakes is frustrating too.
4th rest looks brilliant.
Having awful messaging system inside the clan makes it really hard for the Leader and Co-Leaders to discuss strategy amongts clanmates. There's practically no way to inform people in depth without using the clan chat which only a minority reads at a certain time.
Misguided people are doing the wrong things in Clan Wars and there's no way to educate people, nor is there a way to see who's the one donating barbarians to war bases.
The new clan war mode basically requires real clan info and real clan messages. Make the messages and clan info pop out when tapped so that it's possible to include actual amount of text. As it is right now the text limit + message limit destroys my ability to make important clan messages to tell what our overall goal and plan is in the war.
Need to know who gave troops to your clan castle so you can shout at them! Should also be able to remove any or all troops that were given in mistake because a few of our members filled every castle in the clan with crappy troops. :mad:
There should be a text window in the clan wars section where you can give instructions. Plenty of space please!
Everything's perfect as per our clan's experience of clan wars. We didn't rush into getting to war and we avoided the lag. I think we got our opponent ~15mins after searching. We are now in preparation day and are discussing our strategies. I've never seen my clanmates this active and engaged. Though some are still MIA. :(
Regrading matchmaking, I think we are evenly matched against our opponent and that's a job well done. It may sound premature but first impression lasts. Hopefully.
The only thing missing to make this even more enjoyable is the ability to save bases. We don't want to wait for another month or two for that update to come. In my humble opinion, that should've been anticipated by the developers.
I LOVE the way Clan Wars feels already!
The Battlefield with Home and Enemy side just looks great!
I'm not going to rant about people donating what is not requested in Clan Castles because, come on.. This is the first Clan Wars day and people are allowed rookie mistakes. :) Smail sum moar!
I'm sure people won't be late in cursing on those who donate what is not wanted ;-)
We still have 13 hours left of Prepping, and we're pretty set.
Within minutes people had an idea of who to attack and with what strategy, so unless the opposing Clan changes their bases significantly, we were ready to go to war after 1 hour ^^
Now for some improvements of Clan Wars.
I think it would be awesome, like others have wished for, to have a much higher limit to a Clan Message's length!
No leader can direct 49 people in a Clan message at the length it is today!
So that's that.. Find a way to make the Clan Message longer or add the ability for Leader/Co-Leader to send mail down to specific members or elders, but not the other way around.
2nd;
The ability to save up to 3 base designs would greatly improve the enjoyment of Clan Wars, I am sure.
I see now hundreds of posts about the tedious work with redesigning your base 20 minutes prior to Prep Day Image, for then to rearrange your entire base back.. it's just not a good feeling!
Besides the improvements, I'm loving Clash of Clans, I love my clan!
Shifty50 has been matched with The Lost and we're looking forward to Clashing!
Finally found the culprit and promptly kicked him.
Had to figure out who DIDN'T have the gobs, then count how many gobs had been donated, see who had at least donated that many troops, determine who COULDN'T make them, then finally verified my suspicions by the amount of gold in the guy's collectors. Had been about 10 hours since the gobs appeared, and he had precisely 25000 gold in his collectors at 2.5k per hours (after boost) so it was a give away.
A rather ridiculous method of finding these people but it's worth it I suppose.
+1 vote from my side .
somebody is do yang lv 4 giants when we all want wiz so like 10 of us are tryin to find out who it is
Yay 2 th 7s and a th 5 in the clan we are vsing.
My clan already successfully declare war with other clan.problem is now only some of my clan mate can receive the troop donation in war map....how about other clan mate....we cannot send troop for them...our war going to start in12 hours time........pls do advice...
our clan started a war and it is amazing. The whole clan is engaged and discussing strategies .
the only thing time add would be
1) the ability to know who donated what in war base cc
2)a online button so we can know who is not donating
3) and maybe (I'm not to fussed about it) a way to save at least 3 bases .
other than clan wars rocks!!
I love the war music and the game start background! Good job to the workers on main performance, graphics and audio!P.S. Did an old artist quit or something? The new stuff look so different than before.
Any idea when the maintenance will be Marika? The morning is now over in Finland.
Ok... 2 minutes left.
This is the longest thread in forum history without anyone complaining about loot!
We all want that, and Marika said they are working on it. Yes!I don't think this will be considered. It's not very fair.Right. There should be a list or at least pop up like when you get troops in your normal CC.NO. USE those troops, they were a piece of work and no one wants to see you throw them away.See comment to last idea.THIS SHOULD BE A STICKY! This is a VERY good way of keeping it fair. Make a thread and say this!No. Members should have the right to choose whatever base they want.A pretty good idea but I just worry that there will be swearing...
So as every other clan in our network is now in preperation day,,,, my clan (300!) is still sitting there as spectators!? Please can you get this issue resolved, i have asked my clan to log off, we log back on, oh, and we are still in spectator mode... If clan wars works, then its gonna be great, but at the moment, we are extremely frustrated!
300! Ready for war!!! Come on Supercell!!! Pleeeeaaassseee!!!
1-Saved base layouts for fast switching. 2- Ability to "lock in" your war base manually at any point during the prep day. 3-If a member leaves in the prep day, a spectator should take his/her place in the war. 4-Ability for the leader/co-leader to choose who participate in clan war. (so if he choose 30 people the matchmaking have to occur for those 30 people) 5-In clan wars mode, have the ability to have a double chat (like normally its Clan chat and Global) but in clan wars it will be Clan Chat and one combined between the 2 clans! that will make the battle more intense ;) 6-A clan profile so everyone can see how much a clan has won and loose a clan war !!!! There is some bugs in clan wars hope to be fixed in today maintenance break :) anyway.. Thanks Supercell for everything and keep the good work as always :D You rock guys !!
Hi guys come to my clan : "Desparados":o
Hey someone in our clan donated weak goblins, but there is no way to change them. We need a way to fix this up.
1. Yes. That is the best way to do it, but the person who takes the place will have less time.
2. No, that wouldn't be fair.
3. Would be great but there might be a chat fight and the two clans will start swearing.
4. We already have a War Log in the "My Clan" page.
+1 for all these features, hope Supercell will work on these to bring these ASAP.
Also there is one small bug in this new update but it is not causing any problem, on touching Spell Factory it is showing wrong info it shows like 20/2, 25/4, 25/5 instead of showing 2/2, 4/4, 5/5 (only happens while scouting on war map, not on home village).
Thanks Supercell for finally bringing Clan Wars, earleir it was a bit buggy like slow clan but now everything is OK and our clan finally got into a clan war, we got an evenly fair clan for war. Can't wait for battle day !!! ;)
I've read through about 45 pages and don't feel like reading more. I have yet to see my question answered which many have asked. I am the leader of my clan, I initiated the war, and I am the strongest player of the group...why am I relegated to a bottom position in the war with a town hall 4? It doesn't even say that I am a spectator. All I know is that I can donate to others, but I can't receive any donations. Am I involved in the war? And if not, why the **** not?
Same probleme here. A member left in prep day, but he is still displayed in the fighting base. We have 2 spectators now, who can´t participate in the war. Sucks a little bit. So best solution therefore is, that clanleader and/or co-leader have the option to choose the members, who participate in the war.
Fix it plz.
Greetings!
We need feature so we know who in clan going for what base.. As not everyone talks and different timezones
This needs to be addressed. Low level members have donated wallbreakers, goblins, etc. We need to be able to flush out our clan castle. These clan castle troops really matter, you can't fight again to re-gain your loses like normal gameplay, and you can't use the troops on the goblins to empty your castle of trash troops.
An even more preferable option would be to only accept certain troops. Ex. I request 2 wizards, 1 minion, and ten archers then only people with those troops would be able to donate to my clan castle. If I got my two wizards and 3 archers then only people can only donate 1 minion and 7 archers, not any other troop.
not sure if this is the right place but is anyone having any problems with coc loading. my internet is ok as I am typing this on the same network. have the servers shut down. what going on
I feel the same way.
Actually, somebody donated PEKKAS to all members and another donated Giants to the rest.
We discussed it and one member thought the troops where for offense, the other believes giants to be good for defense.
Well, we need to communicate better on how to handle donations in the second war. This also needs a team effort and I can consider it to be part of the war.
I will be very curious on how that PEKKA is helping me defend .g.
Ah well, if everybody is able to attack (even the ones that are on the war map but without a sword symbol in the member list), we will have a good time in our first war and crush that Spanish clan we have been matched with *evilgrin*.
It's gonna be fun to fight this first war and learn from the experience :)
SC.. When taking my time to write a small essay here, trying to help you improve your product, it really would be nice with just a confirmation that you have actually seen it and haven't allready left the feedback tread like you did last time ? :-/
Annyways.. Add to the above the suguestions mentioned by others about CC troops.. That system should definetly be changed so you have more control about what ends up in your cc..
Hope you guys are reading ?
clanwars donations...why doesn't it app up to clan receive/doantes??
Or have i reed FAQ wrong?
Real long thread...but to add my comment which may have already been mentioned (Im sure it has)...We need a way to dump the war cc on prep day. If people get trigger happy, or misclick, being stuck with a mish mash cc is going to be a real issue for a lot of people...