Clan Wars FEEDBACK here

Only the ones with the sword symbol can get troops, they rest of us are empty... STILL

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by pawars

Hey, check ur clan roster or members list.
do any of the members except the top 9 have a sword symbol before their name in the clan roster?

---

SUPERCELL!!! Please please please let us save base layouts or at least have a separate war base design we can change so that us farmers can still continue to farm and not worry about always changing our bases every other day once a war has started!

3 things would be great:

- save function for villages
- to be able to dump cc troops in warbase
- better ingame communication (1 msg / 12 hours does not help)

I really like the update so far. I have noticed that the server is a TON slower since the update though, so if you guys could work on that, that would be the best. I would also like to suggest that when clans get matched up that they also get matched up by whether the players in the clan are active or not. Thanks, love the game.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by tommie317

Stuck on search for 2 hours now
Clan: Go Bears!

Fyi: 45 vs 45

---

We cancelled ours after 3+ hrs last night. Retry found us a match in about 2min after that. I know they say not to cancel it, but they also said it should only take up to an hour. So I would say go ahead and cancel it and retry.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SSofJetlife

I'm finding in Clan Wars that Hero level isn't weighted nearly as high as it should be. the sheer power of high level heroes can be the sole determining factor in a War. In fact, Hero level shouldn't even be weighted linearly. The power of level 40 heroes rather than 30 is leaps and bounds ahead.

Just like in Champion's League, Clan Wars will be determined more by the attacks than the defenses. You're gonna lose your defenses hard so you have to attack harder(not defend harder) than the other Clan and Heroes make all the difference in attacks.

Level 15 heroes don't do much in determining the end of a battle unless the player is right on the edge of winning. Level 40 heroes on the other hand can take you from the edge to "Oh good I got the one star, oh wait there goes the two star....wow they're still going!...let's see if I can get the 3 star with my last rage spell!"

A clan where everyone has level 10 heroes can be matched against a clan with equal bases but all level 5 heroes EXCEPT for the top 10 who have level 35-40 heroes. That right there gives the clan with the level 5 heroes 20 attacks that are already guaranteed a 2 star and possibly a 3 star without much effort.

I have a near maxed base and I'm not ashamed to admit that a guy using nothing except healers and 2 level 40 heroes did 80% damage to me, even with my maxed or near max defenses and level 11 walls and full Clan Castle. He didn't even have to think about where to deploy them.

Heroes carry more weight than you give them in Clan Wars.

---

Thanks for for the heads up. Was not sure about the power of heroes, I am just beginning to upgrade them.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by cobraron84

• The ability to *flag* bases that you want/intend to attack during the war so that you don't have to communicate outside of the game for that. This way when your clanmates look at bases they see who will be attacking who and can plan accordingly.
• The ability to lock in and allow only specific donations and/or ability to dump war clan castle troops.
• Better balancing of matchups/re-working the algorithm.

---

I really like your first suggestion. That's a great idea that would minimize the amount of chat required.

I am thrilled that Supercell took into account that we have world-wide clans and not everyone can be on at great lengths to participate in the Clan War. I'm happy with the format and design of the Clan Wars - great job!

A few initial observations & feedback:

• War Base Save Layout - this is by far the number one request in my clan. Please give us the option to quickly switch between our normal village and the war base village.
• War Base Clan Castle - either give us a way to see who donated the troops, so we can talk with them about appropriate donations, or give us the option to dump specific troops or all troops from the war base clan castle.
• Option in settings to be a spectator - a clan member could go into settings and select, spectator mode such that when the next Clan War is declared, they would sit out that Clan War. This would allow members to farm or go on vacation and not feel pressured to participate in every Clan War. With this, there could be an indicator that appears next to their league shield on the clan's listing of being in spectator mode.
• Chat history - with all the chatting going on, the number of chat messages being kept is insufficient. Our clan has had to start using an alternative chat app to keep more history of strategies and planning for Clan Wars.

Just a thought... what if a snapshot of your normal base was taken and set as the war base at the start of preparation day. At that point, your war base is entirely separate from your normal base, and can be rearranged however you want during the 24hr prep day without changing your normal base at all. At the end of preparation day, the war base is then locked in. At the end of the war, the war based used simply vanishes, and the next war that starts begins from a new snapshot of your normal base at that point in time. This solves 2 problems:

1) since normal base doesn't change, there is no need to change and then change back, and no worrying about trying to time changes around the prep day countdown.

2) since the snapshot is taken at the start of prep day, players can't gem a bunch of upgrades after the match is found for an unfair advantage in the war. Any upgrades that finish during the war would only count for the normal base but not the war base. The upgrades would then count for the next war and be included in the matchmaking calculations.

Just thought this would be a fair alternative to saying multiple layouts. I could imagine some technical issues with what happens to your saved layout if you buy a new building is it just placed randomly somewhere in your other saved layouts or are the saved layouts corrupted or are you asked to place the building in every saved layout everytime you buy a new building? The idea in this post, you still need to arrange a new war base every war, but since it doesn't effect your normal base and you have 24 hrs before it locks in, you don't have to do it all at one time, you can sign off without worrying about getting raided with an in-progress base. You also don't have to switch from farming to war base, wait for the timer, and then switch normal back to farming.

Oh yeah, my first post. Great game, only been playing for a few weeks and just got to TH5. Pretty hooked on the game plan to keep playing for a while. Thought I might as well join the community here.

I had all clan spectator issue.

It was resolved today


thanks

:)