Clan Wars FEEDBACK here

About 75% of the time when i click on the clan wars map my app crashes. Even after this recent maintenance break it still crashes. I'm not sure if its my Iphone that is the problem or COC. hope i can get this problem resolved

I thought the maint was supposed to fix people who show they can't participate but they should be able to?

They also can't request troops. Will they be able to participate in the end? Please SC please shed light upon us with a fix.

It is a major bug and needs fixing before 8PM UK time when the first battle days will be starting.

If they can't participate then I seriously think this needs fixing. We are going to war with 11 members down! Furthermore, those 11 could be classed as our best!

I've never complained but this has truly disappointed me.


Shiv

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by grafik

That might work for the most hardcore (biggest lo*ers) clans but for most other casual clans that can't spend 8 straight hours of real life on a tablet its just not practical. We had multiple messages sent out as well but some bodies little brother steals an iPad for 5 min and boom wbs galore. Maybe not a filter or cc dump but at the least a report for who donated what is sorely needed (which has been requested for months in our regular village too its nice to know who gave you the drag or pekka while u weren't loking)

---

I do think a report would be a good idea in order to help control the people. That way if there are repeat offenders they can be dealt with.

This is a team effort. Clans need to control their people that's why I will always disagree with the ability to dump a cc if somebody has a foolish member. You make them understand the rules or get rid of them. It's that simple.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SageAbkatsor

We did the same, sending out messages, but not everyone listens. And we have a great clan with almost 100% great players but it only takes one bad apple, and its not always apparent who that is.

While I'm not suggesting that we implement #1, I dont see why youre against it. I dont find your reason very valid as there isnt a good way for leaders to 'control' their clan at present. Sure you can say dont donate, but that doesnt prevent that bad apple from doing so. My main issue with the current system is that i have no idea who donated goblins to someone, and thus have no way of enforcing our rules. Those goblins go out, i say stop, and nothing comes of it. That player might like trolling us, i have no idea. We have random players in our clan that some of us dont know in person, and I would have to guess that 90% of clans are not static, meaning new players are coming and going as we try to find our way to a static 50 solid players. In our case, all of our top players got amazing troops right away, but as we built more for the lower players, a few people screwed up some of the lower bases donations.

So good for you, you have a 100% solid clan, but i feel like i can speak for most of the non-forum users, and many of the forums users alike, when i say that anything that will simplify clan coordination and individual player satisfaction should get a thumbs up. This would accomplish both of those as previously uncoordinated clans would have a system in place to 'force' coordination, and nobody gets troops they dont want. Most of us don't have our clans nailed down all the way as you seem to. It's a long and arduous process in some case...

---

Ok, with all of that said, i do have an intermediate solution to this issue that even you might like as it doesn't ruin the advantage you seem to want to hold on to because you are coordinated. Namely, when i look at an ally war base and see goblins in it, add a button that lets me view who gave which troops. At least this way the leaders can easily discern those bad apples and reprimand or kick them. Or, as many others have suggested, let us dump our war base troops.

---

Well said. I agree 100 percent, and your idea of a fix is great too.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SageAbkatsor

Ok, with all of that said, i do have an intermediate solution to this issue that even you might like as it doesn't ruin the advantage you seem to want to hold on to because you are coordinated. Namely, when i look at an ally war base and see goblins in it, add a button that lets me view who gave which troops. At least this way the leaders can easily discern those bad apples and reprimand or kick them. Or, as many others have suggested, let us dump our war base troops.

---

I totally agree with a report being needed to help deal with the repeat offenders.

I actually do the like the idea of allowing only the leader to dump a cc. However, there should be a limit on how many can be dumped per war based on the size of the war. For example if you actually get a 50v50 match maybe you get to dump 5 cc's.

In my clan's case we're in a 25x25. So maybe we get to dump two. That way you can clean up some of the mess but not all of the mess if you have a dipstick throwing gobbies around.

My clan is having a problem, we are in a 40v40, we have more than 40 people in our clan. So only 40 of us made it in, but around 30 people have the swords around there names, and we have 40 people on the war map, but some including me are experiencing the th 5 problem where we can't be donated too, I believe I'm in the war, but I will not have any troops donated to me.

This is probably not gonna happen but hey its a worth a shot:) Just wanted to ask if SC will ever add something for us to remove the troops in our cc for CW. Some idiot in our clan donated Giants and Hogs to mostly everyone in our clan for CW. Or we could have it that we can only request for troops in CW by ourselves. Hopefully SC sees is:)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Skullone

I totally disagree with number 1. It's up to the leaders to control their clan members. If you can't control your members then you should take the penalty of possibly having a weak CC defensive army.

---

There is no way to tell who donates what so how can you control them. I can't kick a bad donator. If someone is being a great member in any and every way but being a jackars about CW donates I would have no idea who to accuse.

I also warned the whole clan probably over 10 times not to donate anything and clan mails and still there were bad donations and I can't boot or do anything about it without proper tools. In a 50 person clan someone is going to miss the message or not catch on as fast. The game should work for the majority not just the adult only clans who all speak the same language and are on at the same times.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ZombieProcess

11 of our members appear as town hall 4 on the map: with a clan castle capacity of 0--so we essentially cannot donate anything to them at all. huge advantage to the other team.

---

We have the same problem, 3 of our players (me also) are showed on a war map with TH lvl 1 without possibility of donation. ( I have normally TH lvl 9). How should we solve this problem?

Thanks guys
Looking forward to war day:P

DONATION LOGS!!!!
As a Co Leader I have 0 ability to monitor or control clan members, we're 50 and there are bad donation all over the place!
I can't tell who was this!
Add one of the following, either donation log, or an option to empty the clan castle while still in preparation day!
How come you didn't think of it by yourself? ARGH!