Clan Wars FEEDBACK here

Printable View

Show 100 post(s) from this thread on one page

April 10th, 2014
Aronos

I think each player should have the ability to mark or assign their two prospective attacks to the enemy clan. This way, people could decide who they wanted to attack and it would be easily visible for clanmates to see who's attacking who.
April 10th, 2014
sepulse

Quote:

Originally Posted by beige

First off, thank you supercell for an awesome update! I have been reading a lot of complaints about the inability to dump war base CC troops (on the forums and within my own clan chat) and think I have a reasonable solution. I think rather than dump troops, it would be nice if you could allow certain troops to be donated to you war base CC and disallow others. For instance, if you grey out giants, wallbreakers, goblins, golems, and balloons... then no one could drop them in your CC. It would be an easy way to guide your clan mates into donating the proper troops with little fuss.

This! Exactly what im thinking
April 10th, 2014
gibbylovesyou

Quote:

Originally Posted by beige

First off, thank you supercell for an awesome update! I have been reading a lot of complaints about the inability to dump war base CC troops (on the forums and within my own clan chat) and think I have a reasonable solution. I think rather than dump troops, it would be nice if you could allow certain troops to be donated to you war base CC and disallow others. For instance, if you grey out giants, wallbreakers, goblins, golems, and balloons... then no one could drop them in your CC. It would be an easy way to guide your clan mates into donating the proper troops with little fuss.

I actually really like this idea!

But so far, for me, the update has been great!
April 10th, 2014
ZombieProcess

Quote:

Originally Posted by Aronos

I think each player should have the ability to mark or assign their two prospective attacks to the enemy clan. This way, people could decide who they wanted to attack and it would be easily visible for clanmates to see who's attacking who.

Oh! +1

Our clan tried several ways of sharing a doc, even google drive. Not very easy to coordinate with 50 anonymous people. ended up resorting to a glassboard status post--which is ill suited for that at best. :) This is a simple and elegant solution to that issue!
April 10th, 2014
Franchise

This is interesting

Quote:

Originally Posted by cezarica

My clan started a battle and I noticed a guy that in the preparation day he started 2x Inferno Tower level 1 and 3rd X-Bow to level 1. If I look on the war base I see his IT and X-Bow up and ready for battle and that's unfair. I get it to make the heroes or a defense at the last level to be active in the battle but this is a HUGE advantage on his side and unfair towards others.

Curious as to what, if anything they will do about this. That is a pretty big advantage if the bases were originally matched up pretty evenly. This will also be an issue when going up against gemmers who will start war then gem up their defences after matchmaking. Should be interesting.
April 10th, 2014
lurkist

Quote:

Originally Posted by lulug

Great update, and I'm sure its just because its new and we don't really know what we are doing...but the whole thing is seeming to take a lot of time to manage!

I have the following suggestions:

1. Please allow people within a clan to "opt in/out" of a war so that only the people who want to participate in a war do so... not everyone is available all of the time due to RL commitments...

2. Please allow us to be able to dismiss and replace troops from the clan castle, or at least see who donated what so that we can address trolling or misguided issues..:rolleyes:

3. Please show the recommended targets during preparation day so that people can see who they are meant to be matched with.. yes i realise they are likely to be the same number in the opposing clan's war map but it would be good to make sure..

4. Please give us a way to "lock in" the war base at some point during the preparation day without having to wait for the clock to go to zero (even better, in addition to this would be to have saved bases in edit mode so that they are simple to switch over!). This helps with time zone issues for an international clan as its almost impossible to hit the search war button when everyone is awake...

5. Please give us additional communication tools other than clan chat. with an international clan, instructions, and comments in chat are too easily missed due to time zones and people who chat A LOT! Leader messages are too short, and the cool down period is way too long. we are having to rely on outside ways to communicate, such as glassboard etc and it can be difficult to get all clan members to register...

Other than that I think that this feature will add a great new dimension to a fabulous game ... keep up the great work :)

THIS

...is one of the best recommendations I've heard so far. Agree with everything. May I add -

4.a - Show clearly on the enemy map which bases have been locked, so we don't waste our time scouting bases / recommending bases for clannies which are still due to change...

6. - Implement a system like a communal donation camp, infinite or very large in capacity (opportunity for shiny new graphic, preferably positioned front & centre on the friendly war map) into which we can donate, and the recipient can pick what they want from inside. Remaining troops would expire when the countdown reaches 0. Ideally this would be the way to go in the single player game as well (unused troops would expire after X days).
April 10th, 2014
SupermanCannotFly

100% support

Quote:

Originally Posted by rplanters4

It would be nice if we could have some sort of "saved" war base so farmers would not have to change their bases around every time a clan war was started. Other than that however so far clan wars is awesome! Great job supercell!

Very convenient idea,,,save lots of time.
April 10th, 2014
xtalx

I tried to search for this and couldn't find a similar topic, but apologies if it has been brought up before.

During the preparation phase for a clan war, donates made don't count towards the 'friend in need' achievement, or the donate tally that shows up in the clan and league screens. Is this meant to happen? Or should there be a seperate achievement for this in clan wars in the future?
April 10th, 2014
RiDdLe

Quote:

Originally Posted by beige

First off, thank you supercell for an awesome update! I have been reading a lot of complaints about the inability to dump war base CC troops (on the forums and within my own clan chat) and think I have a reasonable solution. I think rather than dump troops, it would be nice if you could allow certain troops to be donated to you war base CC and disallow others. For instance, if you grey out giants, wallbreakers, goblins, golems, and balloons... then no one could drop them in your CC. It would be an easy way to guide your clan mates into donating the proper troops with little fuss.

I like this idea!
April 10th, 2014
ZombieProcess

Quote:

Originally Posted by Franchise

Curious as to what, if anything they will do about this. That is a pretty big advantage if the bases were originally matched up pretty evenly. This will also be an issue when going up against gemmers who will start war then gem up their defences after matchmaking. Should be interesting.

Sorry, this is the *best* possible way to deal with that "issue". Look at a tower that's being initially built. it's referred to as "lvl 1 ____". So in the game logic, the level before level 1 is ... level 1.

Would you rather have a hole in your war base when you build your first one?

Show 100 post(s) from this thread on one page