Clan Wars FEEDBACK here

have lurked on most of the thread, but haven't read all of it. lots of suggestions about opt in/out, so here is my suggestion.

as a leader I’m not sure that i would want to wait on everyone’s "green up" (socom reference), but would rather see the leader of the clan be able to select members participation.

in conjunction with this, i also think a leader(s) {include co leaders} should have a clan inbox. Several things could happen here, but specifically members of the clan could send opt out msg, and the leader(s) would then be able to select/de-select the member before a war initiation.

There has also been talk about "dibbs" on matchups: successful war is about orchestrating attacks. I would also like leaders to be able to suggest targets for members. I think giving the leaders the ability to suggest targets rahter than SC would be more beneficial. Some builds take upwards of 3 hours, thats a long time for planning, then another member hits it, and you’re stuck with an attack that isn't perfect for another base.

I'm sure this will be lost in the text, I'm also sure the suggest has probably been made but due to the size of the thread however, here goes.

Regarding Opt In / Opt Out of Clan Wars, how about this:

The clan itself is marked as allowing opt in / opt out or not, much like required trophy count and invite only, etc.

If the clan does not allow opt in / opt out then clans wars remain exactly as is.

If the clan does allow it then each player can choose if to be included in any wars.


In order to avoid some of the "balance" type issues that have been raised by people opposed to the opt in / opt out. The following may work:

1) During a war, only allow those in war to receive attacking clan castle troops from others in the war.
2) Use the fact that a clan does / doesn't allow opt in / opt out as a factor in match making. If you choose to not allow opt in / opt out then you will only be matched against clans that also choose not to.

Ghosting still no fixed , and dear supercell ,wat is the point of watching live? After adding "watching live" in clan war, it make hard to determine Ghosting problem!! And i can tell to everyone how to do ghosting, the keyword is "disconnect and reconnect" find out guys! That's all i can tell

How about letting us use heroes in war when upgrading. Everything else works while upgrading, but not the heroes. Kinda unbalances things seeing as hero level is part of the clan wars matchmaking system.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by badman11811

The matchmaking has been very hit and miss. Today we had to war a clan that was in the top 150 with 30 town hall 10s. We only have 18 town hall 10s. Please tell me you see the problem there. It is very annoying and difficult to find an even war.

There are many matchmaking problems you guys need to fix. It is terrible.

---

I'm looking for more info on how the matchmaking system works. I get the basics but...

If there are rushed bases in the clan, would we get matched up with more difficult opposing clans? If we have younger bases does that help or not help in getting matched with a clan that we can all attack?

We have had difficulties with the matchmaking system for the last 4 CWs. We can't attack their top few bases and our lower players don't have bases that they can attack.

CWs are taking their toll on my clan and on me. (I lead my clan.) It'd be great if SuperCell could adjust the matching system, but I'd appreciate any help the rest of you can give me while we are waiting. thx!

Nice work as always, Supercell.

Claiming targets during preparation day would be nice, but maybe limit it to each person can only claim one of their two targets. I know that in my clan some people get annoyed because they "reserved" a target, but the rest of the clan didn't know they did.

I'm sure there will be improvements, but Clan Wars has re-motivated tons of people who were beginning to get bored of the game to play full time again

Id be curious to see the statistics of the number of clan wars decided by single digit star margins as an indication of the game successfully selecting close match ups. Almost none of our wars ever end in single digit wins or losses indicating a fail selection system.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by jonpluc

Id be curious to see the statistics of the number of clan wars decided by single digit star margins as an indication of the game successfully selecting close match ups. Almost none of our wars ever end in single digit wins or losses indicating a fail selection system.

---

Most all of our clan war losses have come by way of single digit losses (a recent one was by one star). However some of our wins were pretty lop sided. We did USED to have this problem, but now we demand people max out before going up a TH and they must have a predetermined attack (ex. TH6 -Healer,Giant,Wizard...TH7/TH8 Dragons...TH8/TH9 Gowiwi/Gowipe). We also do not take all members to war used a kick/invite method of choosing a favored war squad. These things are understood by those who don't make the cut, cuz they know one day soon they will. I hear people complain about this a lot, but I would advise that you learn the match making system, then use that system to your advantage. The matchup system takes your defenses, troops, and hero and assigns them a number score...your team's score then gives it a matchup range. Taking people with strong bases for thier TH level, who are capable of a strong attack, is your best chance at winning. Leave the women and children at home and take the real warriors with you....that would be my suggestion....don't blame junk bases and poor participation on the matchup system.

What's everyone think about an additional army camp just for donation use only?? I love donating to my clan but I don't use a lot of what's requested. I have responsibly so I dump troops to train for my clan. Dragons and pekkas take a while, then I wait more for my troops. Please consider this idea.