Clan Wars FEEDBACK here

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by supersale

lol..

well it's your opinion as against to the idea. Smack talk between clans? how could that possible, you cant even choose a opponent clan for war, you cant even choose which global to join. Within the clan, yes, we talk, we discussand as co, I manage the war for our clan, from prep day to end of battle day.

The link or my post is not a spam per se, it is still "quite-very much" related (to the thread).

edit:
btw, I added an image to that thread (link)..

---

I wish you luck with your idea, my point was not to upset anyone, you used the word "spam" I was just trying to help you not get in trouble. Here is an idea for your clan in the mean time. Make sure you have 1 less than the groupings of five so 4 players can sit out. just have them drop their trophies so the lowest 4 players do not war. It is not perfect but it could help you until they add your suggestion.

I truely wish you good luck in your attempt to add a feature to the game.

Tired of watching TH7 attacking TH9. The only problem in my clan. There are always a few lower level players attacking higher level opponents who me and fellow high level members could easily three star them. Right now there is literally no strategy and tactics planning for the clan war. People are just attacking whoever they want whenever they want. :mad::mad:

I'm assuming this is going to get buried, but I'd like to give it a shot anyway. Sorry if this has been suggested and commented on already. Also, apologies if this isn't the place for new CW ideas.

So my idea is simple, war bases are used to make war troops, completely separate from your village. This would allow upgrading heroes and upgrading spell factories to be functional during war. Not only that, if these war troops were magically free of cost, the elixir injection would be equivalent to the gold injection. It puts more emphasis on winning the war, not the loot bonus. It would not impede regular farming during war (an issue for my clan). And it would promote more wars because of the aforementioned advantages.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by GinGian

3) Wars are expensive!, loot has to be improved, even if it's not directly, you should implement some other mechanics so clans don't have to spend so much (dark) elixir. Here's a few ideas:
3a) Make war castle defensive troops persistent: this way you only need to fill castles once and the troops will be there for every war, unless the person decides to ditch them for new ones, or upgrades the castle and has some extra room for more troops.

---

I have to agree with this point, especially if your base doesnt get attacked. The cost has to be the reason so many are leaving there CC empty.

Why do we only see "wars won"? If a clan has "wars won 7" that could mean they have only gone to war 7 times and won them all, or it could mean they went to war 27 times and lost 20.

If Supercell adds a "wars lost" next to "wars won" then the stats actually mean something.

Agree/disagree?

Lobster Rescue (Darwin Salad - Wars won 8. Lost 1)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by LobsterRescue

Why do we only see "wars won"? If a clan has "wars won 7" that could mean they have only gone to war 7 times and won them all, or it could mean they went to war 27 times and lost 20.

If Supercell adds a "wars lost" next to "wars won" then the stats actually mean something.

Agree/disagree?

Lobster Rescue (Darwin Salad - Wars won 8. Lost 1)

---

I would like to see this along with supercells own ranking chart like they have for individual. The individual leagues give you bonus loot when you win bht this could be used to receive loot win or loss. all depends on what happens to their teams ranking.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by LobsterRescue

Why do we only see "wars won"? If a clan has "wars won 7" that could mean they have only gone to war 7 times and won them all, or it could mean they went to war 27 times and lost 20.

If Supercell adds a "wars lost" next to "wars won" then the stats actually mean something.

Agree/disagree?

Lobster Rescue (Darwin Salad - Wars won 8. Lost 1)

---

i don't think that was the intent of supercell, especially in light of only being able to see the past 10 matches in "war log."

i think tracking by wins only makes it easy enough and convenient enough for them while also maintaining a way to install a leadersboard at a later time.

once win/loss ratios enter the equation, your win percentage needs to be calculated and all of a sudden, you will have a 1-0 clan having a higher percentage than a clan with a 20-1 record.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Silvex

i don't think that was the intent of supercell, especially in light of only being able to see the past 10 matches in "war log."

i think tracking by wins only makes it easy enough and convenient enough for them while also maintaining a way to install a leadersboard at a later time.

once win/loss ratios enter the equation, your win percentage needs to be calculated and all of a sudden, you will have a 1-0 clan having a higher percentage than a clan with a 20-1 record.

---

That is very true that is why there should be leagues, 1-10, 11-20, 21-30 and so on. after say 40 wins you get entered on the master list..

just MHO.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MarcusFishie

That is very true that is why there should be leagues, 1-10, 11-20, 21-30 and so on. after say 40 wins you get entered on the master list..

just MHO.

---

that still wouldn't fix the ratio issue... a team that is 40-1 is gonna be higher than 119-3.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Silvex

that still wouldn't fix the ratio issue... a team that is 40-1 is gonna be higher than 119-3.

---

You make a sound point, not sure how to solve this other than a factor that takes into account your total wars. I like the idea it just needs more though.