Clan Wars FEEDBACK here

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by minigott

I don't like it that inactive members are taken into a clan war. And there are always members who doesn't want to participate. There should be a function for every member to join the clan wars team.

Furthermore, I'm not happy with the system how war bases are being saved. I always have to switch my base from Farming to Clan War and back. There should be a function to save a clan wars base.

---

Easy fix....get rid of the inactives and have the bum go find a clan that suits them better

.... In normal raiding , loot has been horrible since the CW update . many clanmates also feel the same , and many people in my local COC forum also feel the same . SC pls fix this , your turn , thanks .

Opt in / opt out is definitely needed. I think the easiest way to solve it is to do the actual match making at the end of the preparation day.

Day 1. Preparation day
- people opt in, get their bases prepared (members should confirm it for each war)
- at the end of the first day based on actual participants matchmaking is done
- right after matchmaking is done the Battle day starts

Day 2. Battle day
- same as it is now


PS. Also, since you don't know your enemy until u get ur base ready, there is no need to hide the army in opponents army camps.

I apologize if this has already been reported or addressed

Congrats SC, Clan Wars is awesome....our entire clan was engaged and were extremely excited about the experience.

We were fortunate enough to have won the War against our opponent and our members were looking forward reaping the rewards of their War win loot bonus.
However, several have now reported, that they did receive their gold and elixir, but not the DE bonus was never delivered.

Is this a glitch or are there prevailing circumstances where certain members would not have received their DE bonus.

Specific example:

War Clans: Canadian Tundra v. Ghostz
Date : Battle day - 13-April
Member : MEH
War page stated he earned 450 DE, but when we reviewed his clan castle only the Gold and Elixir were there. No DE.
He did not hit the collect button, so you could clearly see this.

If its a glitch is there a remedy ?, or if there are prevailing reasons for this happening, please let me know.

Thanks in advance, for any help.

Thanks very much for the awesome update !!

An idea that is shared within my clan is that it would be awesome to have the opportunity for clan members to sign up for a war before the clan matching process and the prep day so that everybody in the clan could have the possibility to participate even low level people and players who are away for any reason don't participate to the ongoing war.

Thanks,

Arno

Reduced preparation and war time. Maybe 12 hours each?

Chiming in that opt in/out absolutely needs to happen, and fast.

I already have clan members who want to start warring non stop while others don't want to do it at all, and I'm worried that this is going to screw up what had been a really active clan up until this point. Heck, I knew this would be a problem as soon as the clan wars details came out.

And don't tell me "tough", or "it's only two attacks", or "there were already pushing/farming clans, now there will be war clans". Clan wars takes effort do do right, and not everyone has the time sometimes. As far as farming/pushing clans goes, individual members in farming clans could always push on their own if they wanted to, but in clan wars everyone is forced to whether they want to or not.

Opt in/out would have been easy to implement and would have let clans keep their current structures. Alienating people who play your game by making them do something they don't want to do (e.g. having to leave their clan, being forced to participate, or not being allowed to participate as much as they want to) is never a good idea. Supercell really dropped the ball on this one.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Sabotage777

Easy fix....get rid of the inactives and have the bum go find a clan that suits them better

---

I am not going to destroy my clan because of the clan wars.

The fact that you can't use your Heroes for attacking while upgrading is a joke.

Most people, including me, have at least one Hero upgrading 24/7.

Sort it out.

The clan wars is amazing and works fine now. I thought that you would make an easier way to see how many stars did your clan mates get by showing them on the war map. Maybe you could remove the line between clan description and the buttons "send mail" and "edit". You should make a clan cooldown, when you leave a clan. Or something against hoppers, that would be so cool and so helpful. Make level 4 clan castle flat so those containers wouldn't be on top of a ladder and a hole. And it would've been so awesome if the gembox would appear in the water and moving a littlebit, like on stranded islands. Thanks for reading if someone read it. :)