Clan Wars FEEDBACK here

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by AngryAngels

Lol, a player do 3 stars on a village and get 300k, an other player do 1 star on the same village and get 300k ... and for you it's fair ... :confused:.

1 - I do not see what it as to do with helping weaker players ... well, just give 1000k to every player that is under the median level of the clan.... you will reply "not a good idea" and i will reply "What's bad about helping weaker clan member" ... will it help the discussion ...? I don't think it will.

2 - Your argument of the "star that secures the win" is unacceptable ... cause the player that does 3 stars has certainly more chances to secure the win than the one that does 1 star.

The solution i explained seems to solve this unfair behavior of the loot distribution, weak players will get less loot... leading them to develop a better strategy, troops.. etc.
Or you can see it an other way... double the loot for 2 stars and triple it for three stars ... you see... the weak player always got the same loot... :p

Ps : i've given more than 400 worth space of troops to help weaker players of my clan... (we're only 25).. :)

---

I cannot say you are wrong.. if the loot is tripled for 3 stars, there is another problem. A high level player will 3 star low level enemy to triple the loot. Well...although you can get 6 stars, but which enemy your low level player can attack? You may say if the guy doesnt follow the rule, you'll kick him.. By that time, it causes jealousy already; or even worst, your clan may lose the war.

To me, the current system is good enough :)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by AngryAngels

Lol, a player do 3 stars on a village and get 300k, an other player do 1 star on the same village and get 300k ... and for you it's fair ... :confused:.

1 - I do not see what it as to do with helping weaker players ... well, just give 1000k to every player that is under the median level of the clan.... you will reply "not a good idea" and i will reply "What's bad about helping weaker clan member" ... will it help the discussion ...? I don't think it will.

2 - Your argument of the "star that secures the win" is unacceptable ... cause the player that does 3 stars has certainly more chances to secure the win than the one that does 1 star.

The solution i explained seems to solve this unfair behavior of the loot distribution, weak players will get less loot... leading them to develop a better strategy, troops.. etc.
Or you can see it an other way... double the loot for 2 stars and triple it for three stars ... you see... the weak player always got the same loot... :p

Ps : i've given more than 400 worth space of troops to help weaker players of my clan... (we're only 25).. :)

---

A win bonus is a win bonus, you win with one star, you get the win bonus. Not different to the 'normal' game...never hear anyone complaining there.
ad1) I've got this thing with envy...I don't see how you're recieving less only because someone else is getting the same or even more, they're not taking it from you, are they?
ad2) If a higher ranked player 'takes away' the chance for a lower ranked player to make two stars by three starring 'their' base...it can tip the scales and ruin your whole clans win, that is what I meant. On the other hand, weaker members will help towards an easier match-up and so have already contributed before even the first clash commences. In a clan win, they deserve to get the same, they'll have played their part (btw inactive members get zero).
PS: we're 40, I'm the strongest, I'm virtually financing our war.
I am in for then fun, and having tons of it, I think you are too.
Have Fun!
TS

I have been in two clan wars now in two clans. One, my base was attacked 3 times. The other.....we attacked a base a whopping 7 times. Is this a bug? Or are we mistaken/presumptuous about the 2 attack law?

I just want to say Clan Ward is simply AMAZING Well done supercell!!! The bugs get a little annoying but other then that AMAZING

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Franchise

I have been in two clan wars now in two clans. One, my base was attacked 3 times. The other.....we attacked a base a whopping 7 times. Is this a bug? Or are we mistaken/presumptuous about the 2 attack law?

---

What 2 attack law?

Each player gets 2 attacks, and they can not attack the same player twice.

But every player on your side could conceivably attack one player on the enemy side. There is no limit to how many times a base can be attacked, other than once per player.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Franchise

I have been in two clan wars now in two clans. One, my base was attacked 3 times. The other.....we attacked a base a whopping 7 times. Is this a bug? Or are we mistaken/presumptuous about the 2 attack law?

---

Each clan member can make only two attacks, and cannot attack the same base twice, however, you can attack an opponent that has already been attacked by another member of your clan. This is how quite a number of attacks can be launched against the same war base... they will have to come from different players though.
Take note, that once a base has been three-starred it cannot be attacked again, or this would at least be useless.
Also note, that two-starring a base that has been attacked earlier with also two stars will not add to your overal score, only additional stars will.
Hope this helps.
TS

a moderator is on, yay!
so I can go to sleep now!
gn8 you all

How about awarding a star for a successful defense? Maybe even weight it. If a strong player attacks a weaker player and gets shut out for 0 stars the defender should get stars or at least loot. Just a thought.

Winning war loot not attractive..

All of my suggestions were captured in daddy's video - plus 1 on his recommendations