Clan Wars: The Tie Breaker!!!!

Okay so if you haven't been keeping up with the clan war YouTube videos then long story short there can be ties in a clan war. Well I thought of using someone elses idea into my idea of a tie breaker. Another poster, I forgot who, said it would be cool to see troop versus troop instead of troop versus base. So how about this. In the event of a tie in clan wars you and your clan must donate troops to a clan army camp that can hold say 25-150 troops depending on your clans size. Now if you tie your clan can donate to this army camp obviously there will be say a ten troop limit. Well after a time period the troops get placed on either side of a coliseum looking area and fight troop versus troop. The winner wins the clan war.

And everyone wouls be able to see the replay or watch it happen "live"

I like your idea. I think that would be cool but that would need to be another day so it gives people time to get on and donate there troops for the tie breaker. So if it's a clan war 10 vs 10 then after the battles over and it's tie breaker time then each person can donate 10 troops each and the total is 100 camp troops (depending on who all donates). They get dropped in a arena after that day to see which side wins. If the clan has 15 members in war and each person can only donate up to 10 then it should be a camp that can hold up to 150 troops. (Correct? So on and so forth till 50 members)
I like the idea.

How about the war just takes all the troops already donated to everyone's war bases, places those in an arena and they all attack each other.

They should just give the tie breaker to the clan with the highest average damage percentage. Then the secondary tie breaker would be the clan with the least amount of attacks used.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by slickrick

They should just give the tie breaker to the clan with the highest average damage percentage. Then the secondary tie breaker would be the clan with the least amount of attacks used.

---

I think this is the easiest and quickest, yet still fair solution.

What's wrong with a tie?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Pieman91499

I think this is the easiest and quickest, yet still fair solution.

---

I like the idea of a draw, makes people strive to win that much more if its tied up in the final moments. I sure wish they kept track publicly of losses and draws though...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Gounja

How about the war just takes all the troops already donated to everyone's war bases, places those in an arena and they all attack each other.

---

It would be a problem because how would it know where to place troops

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jeromie

I like the idea of a draw, makes people strive to win that much more if its tied up in the final moments. I sure wish they kept track publicly of losses and draws though...

---

Exactly. It adds more stress and desire to win.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by PhilISuppose

What's wrong with a tie?

---

What's wrong with a tie is that it is treated as a loss for both teams, I think ties would be ok if the tied teams could split the rewards, rather than just getting losing rewards for a tie as they have it now.

it would suck if it were Barbarians verses Dragons. this is a hilarious idea. that is about it though.:facepalm:

I agree that there should be a determining factor to decide a clear winner but this one probably wont work. Troop v Troop wouldnt be controllable by players, essentially taking the war out of the clans hands.

Maybe like someone else said, whoever had the stars with the least amount of attacks, or who had the best dmg percentage. Both good ways to determine a winner.

i think drawing is fair, however i do think the rewards should be better.

How do you function each troop?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Gounja

How about the war just takes all the troops already donated to everyone's war bases, places those in an arena and they all attack each other.

---

Even if it wasn't a tiebreaker it could be a fun bonus game at the end of each war.

The Clan Leader could arrange the Defensive Clan Castle troops in whatever order he/she decided was best in an attack queue.

The final battle would dump the troops out say 50 housing spaces at a time. As units died the housing spaces would free up and the next unit(s) would be deployed once there was enough space available.

A lot of thought could be put into the order that units are deployed.

DaveJ

Good solution