Printable View
I agree that it seems to value defense. It really depends on how the MM handles a clan full of premmie TH players. Will they get matched with folks with similar TH levels or more with folks with similar defense (weapons / walls).Quote:
Originally Posted by BlackDragonX
As someone who has chosen the path of a fully built out base before each upgrade, I'm hoping for more weight to be given to TH. I'm looking forward to taking my "heavy" low level TH and pounding premmie TH players.
I predict clan wars could really change clan dynamics
First off, its not about sharing replays. If you royalty screw up, it will be available for all to see. If you have a player that can get those 3 star wins off stronger opponents, he is suddenly going to be very highly valued. Similarly, if a player can only get stars off a considerably weaker opponent (the bread and butter of farmers) - they have a high potential of having a limited value.
I could see players having to prove they are clan wars material. Since it appears you can select participation, I could see this being a major clan dynamic piece. Also the level of cooperation is much higher than normal.
If you place a wallbreaker in a clan war castle, I foresee that being a good enough reason for the boot. Also, I see people being much much picker for that sort of castle. I.E. Wizards and witches only! Or even your highest level people being the only ones allowed to donate.
Anyway, thanks for the guide :)
Definitely won't be able to not share that totally flubbed attack. That can be good though since your clan mates will likely "help" you learn how not to do that again! I'm not going to bite on the "farmers only attack weak opponents" bait. ;)Quote:
Originally Posted by NioTheDreamer
A good tactical player who gets stars above his level will be highly valued. Also valued will be low level but solid players who can get lots of stars at the bottom of the map. If your bottom three players can three star their bottom six bases, you are on the way to a big win!
I don't see where there is any leader / co-leader ability to select who participates. That is a common statement but it is not supported by the FAQ. ( http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...-Clan-Wars-FAQ )Quote:
Originally Posted by NioTheDreamer
Now a player who is in the clan but chooses to not participate in a clan war may find himself looking for a new clan! I can also see new recruits being looked at much more closely. I would not accept a premmie in at this point. Nor would I accept in someone who is unwilling to take guidance on who they will be attacking in a war.
Yeah, an unrequested troop of any kind in a war castle could be grounds for a boot. That is actually hurting the whole clan, not just peeing in the boot of the guy who sassed you last night.Quote:
Originally Posted by NioTheDreamer
There definitely will be a lot more thought about what gets put in each war castle. The top leveled players should plan on having lots of lvl 5 Archers handy to fill in the gaps around the more specialized (and high level) troops.
Thanks. I'm really curious to see if the "Bottom Up" strategy works and catches on.Quote:
Originally Posted by NioTheDreamer
Nice post.. Seems like you know all the details :D
Until they actually release the update!Quote:
Originally Posted by Palalay
At that point, all the planning will go out the window. Kind of like the real thing.
No plan of action survives contact with the enemy but not having a plan before contact is planning to fail.
Some excellent ideas in this post/thread, thanks! I'm wondering about a few things...
* How useful will the "recommended target" suggestion be? Will it suggest a base whose defensive strength is similar to your offensive strength (not just compare your base to theirs on defense or total points)
* If opponents top bases are maxxed out, should a medium attacker just one-star them and let the top attackers 3-star some other bases in the top section?
* How will this strategy work in practice, where the assumptions don't all hold - not 100% clan participation, imperfect bases wide open to a specific attack type (hogs/balloons/etc), and having some players who will ignore all this and do whatever they feel like doing? :p
Excited to see Clan Wars coming out soon - please keep sharing thoughts on war day strategy as you get to try these ideas.
Basically what is a little bit of loot to higher lvl players is a lot to the noobs. Remember when you were happy to get 30k loot in a raid ? lol . Plus if you don't pound those noobs more than likely you will lose. And no Win equals no bonus at all.... soooo, its definitely worth it.Quote:
Originally Posted by Tohibii
Also this is a great guide in general. If only it was that easy to get everyone on the same page for some clans.