TH9 vs. TH10

Printable View

Show 100 post(s) from this thread on one page

March 31st, 2014
ColonelForbin

Quote:

Originally Posted by GameloverHD

http://clashofclans.wikia.com/wiki/Archer_Queen
http://clashofclans.wikia.com/wiki/Barbarian_King
Add it up:rolleyes: I already told you I've been playing from WAY before the profile update. I had my heroes to about 7 each I think (Sorry but my memory doesn't go back months for a video game. They could have been 8 or something). I also didn't upgrade any dark troops during this period so most of my 591K HH went towards DE troops instead of my Heroes. I can count it all out for you:rolleyes:

Dude, I'm 99% sure that the August 2013 achievement update would NOT have affected your Heroic Heist because you hadn't maxed it. It only paused the progress on people who had already farmed their 1,000,000 by then, which you hadn't. Therefore I'm close to certain that you have farmed under 600K DE lifetime. If I'm wrong I'd love to have it explained to me how I am.

So as far as adding it up, a Level 11 AQ has a cumulative DE cost of 402,500 and a BK level 10 has a cumulative cost of 227,500.

That right there is more DE than you have farmed lifetime, which means you must have gemmed it.

I'm also willing to wager that your minions are level 5, thats another 100k DE. How about your hogs? golems? valks? witches?

It seems conclusive to me that you've gemmed a fair amount of DE.

Therefore I also don't buy that you farmed 430,000,000 gold prior to July 2013, then quit for some period of time and have now come back with your GG reset at 100,000,000 and have only farmed 69,000,000 gold.

If you'd farmed 430,000,000 gold in July 2013 you'd be a pretty famous farmer.

I can't be certain of the details of your GG, but when you lie about 1, 2 or 3 things, how can you expect to have any credibility on your 4th?

And I know this seems like an ad hominem attack...but I'm really just trying to get the facts straight since you dispense so much *wisdom* about things that I'm beginning to suspect you don't really know anything about.
March 31st, 2014
Michael1515

Why do people write " maxed out " when they aren't even close :rolleyes:
March 31st, 2014
madmonk3y

Definitely TH10. Past Crystal League walls are irrelevant and Inferno Towers help protect your resources much better. Unless you're one of these cowards who hide in Silver League, then you may stay at TH9 forever if you find that fun.
March 31st, 2014
ab6c

Quote:

Originally Posted by ColonelForbin

Dude, I'm 99% sure that the August 2013 achievement update would NOT have affected your Heroic Heist because you hadn't maxed it. It only paused the progress on people who had already farmed their 1,000,000 by then, which you hadn't. Therefore I'm close to certain that you have farmed under 600K DE lifetime. If I'm wrong I'd love to have it explained to me how I am.

So as far as adding it up, a Level 11 AQ has a cumulative DE cost of 402,500 and a BK level 10 has a cumulative cost of 227,500.

That right there is more DE than you have farmed lifetime, which means you must have gemmed it.

I'm also willing to wager that your minions are level 5, thats another 100k DE. How about your hogs? golems? valks? witches?

It seems conclusive to me that you've gemmed a fair amount of DE.

Therefore I also don't buy that you farmed 430,000,000 gold prior to July 2013, then quit for some period of time and have now come back with your GG reset at 100,000,000 and have only farmed 69,000,000 gold.

If you'd farmed 430,000,000 gold in July 2013 you'd be a pretty famous farmer.

I can't be certain of the details of your GG, but when you lie about 1, 2 or 3 things, how can you expect to have any credibility on your 4th?

And I know this seems like an ad hominem attack...but I'm really just trying to get the facts straight since you dispense so much *wisdom* about things that I'm beginning to suspect you don't really know anything about.

What does this have to do with th9 vs th10?
March 31st, 2014
ColonelForbin

Quote:

Originally Posted by ab6c

What does this have to do with th9 vs th10?

Because the data indicates, to me, that he gems rather than farms his resources. For the record, I'm by no means anti-gemming. I've bought gems and will possibly do so again in the future.

But if you gem a large share of your resources the loot penalty for farming is less of a factor in deciding whether or not to upgrade.

While OP might not like my response, it's certainly relevant to his question.
March 31st, 2014
daclanman

The thing is it will be easier to farm it at town hall 9... but at the same time you want those infernos sooooo badly. Your choice. Can you farm it against town hall 9's mostly, or do you still need to attack those town hall 8's
March 31st, 2014
daclanman

Quote:

Originally Posted by ColonelForbin

Care to explain how you got a BK 10 and AQ 11 with a 591k Heroic Heist?

Stop lying about your prowess and I'll stop calling you out on the lies.

Don't forget the drills:rolleyes:
March 31st, 2014
Theriddler93

Listen to me and only me: do lvl 9 walls, the th9 loot is way better then th10 so it will take less time. Are you in such hurry for the bad th10? It took me 3-4 months to finish them but you feel good after getting them done.
March 31st, 2014
ab6c

Quote:

Originally Posted by ColonelForbin

Because the data indicates, to me, that he gems rather than farms his resources. For the record, I'm by no means anti-gemming. I've bought gems and will possibly do so again in the future.

But if you gem a large share of your resources the loot penalty for farming is less of a factor in deciding whether or not to upgrade.

While OP might not like my response, it's certainly relevant to his question.

It seems to me that ur trying to "expose how much of a dirty gemmer he is" rather than just answer his question.

I think its very annoying when people demand an explanation or proof of something completely unrelated to them. I admire the OP's patience to explain why his stats r they way they are, my response could have been a bit different.
March 31st, 2014
GameloverHD

Wow....I was offline for about an hour and missed this huge flame war about me and my gems.... Time to respond:cool:

Quote:

Originally Posted by ColonelForbin

Dude, I'm 99% sure that the August 2013 achievement update would NOT have affected your Heroic Heist because you hadn't maxed it. It only paused the progress on people who had already farmed their 1,000,000 by then, which you hadn't. Therefore I'm close to certain that you have farmed under 600K DE lifetime. If I'm wrong I'd love to have it explained to me how I am.

So as far as adding it up, a Level 11 AQ has a cumulative DE cost of 402,500 and a BK level 10 has a cumulative cost of 227,500.

That right there is more DE than you have farmed lifetime, which means you must have gemmed it.

I'm also willing to wager that your minions are level 5, thats another 100k DE. How about your hogs? golems? valks? witches?

It seems conclusive to me that you've gemmed a fair amount of DE.

Therefore I also don't buy that you farmed 430,000,000 gold prior to July 2013, then quit for some period of time and have now come back with your GG reset at 100,000,000 and have only farmed 69,000,000 gold.

If you'd farmed 430,000,000 gold in July 2013 you'd be a pretty famous farmer.

I can't be certain of the details of your GG, but when you lie about 1, 2 or 3 things, how can you expect to have any credibility on your 4th?

And I know this seems like an ad hominem attack...but I'm really just trying to get the facts straight since you dispense so much *wisdom* about things that I'm beginning to suspect you don't really know anything about.

First, this has little to do with the thread but I'll dumb it down for you. I don't lie:rolleyes:. I'm not a famous farmer with 430mil...at all. Also, You seem to be forgetting that my mines go for a major portion of my loot gain. I have nothing against people who gem as it keeps the game free and the updates flowing. Does it matter if I gem or if I don't? Anyways, what are you even trying to prove? My question was "Should I upgrade to TH10?" not "Can you please prove to me exactly how many gems I have used". The amount of time you spend trying to make me look like a liar you might as well just start a thread called "Reasons GameloverHD is the worst forumer". Try doing that instead of starting arguments with me on almost every thread:rolleyes:

Quote:

Originally Posted by Michael1515

Why do people write " maxed out " when they aren't even close :rolleyes:

First, it makes you feel better. Second, I am maxed besides walls and heroes which few people even consider into the word "max".

Quote:

Originally Posted by daclanman

Don't forget the drills:rolleyes:

Exactly! I've been sitting on two Level 6 Drills for a while. Those things must have produced hundreds of thousands of DE during this time!

Quote:

Originally Posted by ab6c

It seems to me that ur trying to "expose how much of a dirty gemmer he is" rather than just answer his question.

I think its very annoying when people demand an explanation or proof of something completely unrelated to them. I admire the OP's patience to explain why his stats r they way they are, my response could have been a bit different.

Thanks ab6c:o:cool:

Show 100 post(s) from this thread on one page