Printable View
The idea is if you loose in a battle then your clan leader or co-leaders can avenge you once every 24 or 48 hours. During this time if the avenger wins then they get half the trophies and the person that's getting avenged gets the other half of the trophies. If they loose then the avenger looses trophies.
Also ment to mention the the same would go for the coins and elixir. Another idea is having a clan map. Everyone can donate to the map and only leaders and co-leaders can edit map. Which opens the option for clan castle battles. I would let the limitations of traps, fighters, and buildings for the makers. In this map you would only need storage for coins and elixir. Each member would have there own barracks to help defend the castle.
If you like this or have an addition please reply.
-rakino-
Thats ruled out, on your first thread comment - bit of a rubbish idea. The fact you could have some awful players in big clans just giving a lot of trophies away to high level playersQuote:
Originally Posted by Rakino7863
Hi and welcome to the forums!
Supercell ruled out this idea(s) because players could get wrecked by super high lvl players.Please read all the ruled out ideas before posting next time (here: http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...rum-guidelines)
~UltraDragonMaster
Sorry, please read the sticky.
I read stickys but damn there's so much to try and remember what's ruled out. I understand that top players could wipe out a lower ranking person but he're an idea, the person getting attacked don't loose trophies it's just a way for the avenger and avenged to get some trophies back. Also it wouldn't get to crazy because the clan leaders could only do it once every 48 hours and that's a pretty good limit. It don't have to be co-leaders but if it is then they would need to limit the amount of co-leaders. I'm just saying it's possible. There would be a lot of little details to work out but really it's a good possibility to work right.
-rakino-
Actually kind of OP. If your leader was in champion and your were th6 your leader could completely destroy the person and they could easily get trophies
Only once every 48 hours. And if that's such a big deal then they can make it to where leaders or co-leaders have to be in the same division in order to avenge. I'm open to ideas gents and lady's.Quote:
Originally Posted by KaiTheBeast0
Please feed from this thread. I believe great minds come together and create something fair and awesome. It don't just take one but many to bring something new to the table.
-rakino-
From
-Unruly 50-
1: Watch your language, it's bad for the kiddies:cool:Quote:
Originally Posted by Rakino7863
2: It's still ruled out, even if it's only once every few days
Ok so I read the whole sticky and the only thing I found that was close to what I said that was in the ruled out section was "*Ability to transfer a revenge to a clan member or public hitlist"
So have said that you won't be able to transfer the revenge. The avenge button would only be accessible to the clan leader and the only way they can avenge is if the replay was posted on the clan message board. Once again you don't transfer the revenge and you don't place them on a hit list. I still fill this is different and would like the moderators to take a look into this and possibly make this change.
So the person that gets attacked has to risk when revenging, only the avenger would lose trophies and if there is a gain they would split? thats not goodQuote:
Originally Posted by Rakino7863
now let me tell you why this would not work at all.
Firstly, you have not mentioned how resources would be distributed at all. anyways, there is no way you could split it to make it fair. Secondly, I could avenge for my friend all the time, as i am over double their level and could basically smash any one that attacks them. but that is unfair and would not work in the game. also, if a champ avenges for a bronze league guy and the possible # of trophies is 20, and they each get half, would the champion league guy get 10 trophies? because that is a ton for attacking a bronze league village in champions league. lastly, in trophy hunting clans, it essentially means that anyone can revenge and all the targets are free to pick from. bad idea overall
It is still transferring a revenge. Only difference is that it is only transferred/hitlist to co-leaders and leaders and changes the word from revenge to avenge.Quote:
Originally Posted by Rakino7863
again, due to the many ways it could be exploited and change the game mechanics, it would not work. no it will not happen
"The avenge button would only be accessible to the clan leader and the only way they can avenge is if the replay was posted on the clan message board. Once again you don't transfer the revenge and you don't place them on a hit list. "
seriously... it is available to co-leader/leader means anyone can be promoted and avenge/revenge. any replay can be posted. and you are transfering the revenge by allowing someone other than the one being attacked to revenge/avenge. hitlist? its a replay in clan chat and any co-leader could click avenge, pretty much a hitlist.
So you are suggesting allowing trophies to be created out of thin air? since one side gains it and one side doesnt loose it... bad idea again and esp bad in high trophy levelsQuote:
Originally Posted by Rakino7863
I could easily drop to gold to avenge... why cant you just fight your own battles.Quote:
Originally Posted by Rakino7863
and it is clearly ruled out, no matter how you try to twist the words of revenge and avenge or say its not public just co-leader and leader (which anyone can be promoted to, so its essentially public). the fundamental idea that revenges cant be transferred and thats clearly ruled out...
Ruled out folks. Nothing to see here...
Wow you guys are mean. Who really cares it's just an idea and I'm sorry you guys care sooo much to knit pick every single thing. Here's an idea you guys come up with an idea. Help me geez. I'm not asking anyone to tell me it won't work nor am I asking for people to pic apart my idea. I am asking for ideas to make this work or better. And I don't care if you guys say it's ruled out or not, you are not a moderator or supercell employee. Let them do there job. Report me if it's that big of a problem. And lastly I already said that whom ever decides to do this if they do that they can work out all the small details. I guess you didn't understand when I said that you could only be able to avenge someone that is in your same division.
-leader or co-leader can avenge
-only in the same division
-only every 48 hours (two days)
-(new idea) if you promote/demote a person they can't avenge for a past battle nor avenge for 48 hours after promotion or demotion.
-(changed idea) trophy and items you can gain half back if you win and that half is split between the avenged and the avenger.
I do not see how this could not work.
-rakino-
Check it out
Please click 'forum rules' in my sig and read #4.........Quote:
Originally Posted by Rakino7863
Please refrain from breaking the rules as Ultra said, For your post above, A Moderator ruled it out. Or SC Employee, and the community is telling you, I'm sorry to say this, but there is no purpose for this thread as this won't be added for a very long time.Quote:
Originally Posted by Rakino7863
Interesting because if you claim to be a supercell employee then you could just close this thread and would give me a good reason. Anyway nice try and yes I got that rule thank you. Once this thread closes then I'll stop posting this and I will also be grateful for the supercell employee getting in contact with me or at least to have read this full thread.Quote:
Originally Posted by UltraDragonMaster
Interesting because i don't care what you have to say nor any other super wanna be cell workers. Anyway nice try and yes I got that rules thank you. Once this thread closes then I'll stop posting this and I will also be grateful for the supercell employee getting in contact with me or at least to have read this full thread. In the mean time you all that have nothing better to do than shut people down can F off. This section is not for you guys it's for people with ideas or requests. Not for a community that don't want to help create ideas. Not for people to shut other peoples ideas down. You guys are not the moderator or supercell employee. Have fun not getting anywhere with what your doing.Quote:
Originally Posted by matthewe
I know these guys. They don't try to represent Supercell. They are just rebroadcasting what there employees are saying. All of us are trying to make this sub section better by helping this sub section be cleaner. All of us have ideas and aren't just here to "F people off". Supercell is based mostly in Helsinki, they can't cover this sub forum 24/7. We use our own expertise of the forums and rules to guide new forumers around and to the sticky!Quote:
Originally Posted by Rakino7863