New Donation system

I like this idea and i think it would be good. but just a slight modification-
THis ability should be allowed in a clan only by the leader or co-leader. as in, when someone new joins a clan, they shouldn't be allowed to set limits to their troops already. there should be an option that enables the leader/co-leader to allow a new member to set this system. or else new members will be joining in requesting their very specific troops.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Tormented

I like this idea and i think it would be good. but just a slight modification-
THis ability should be allowed in a clan only by the leader or co-leader. as in, when someone new joins a clan, they shouldn't be allowed to set limits to their troops already. there should be an option that enables the leader/co-leader to allow a new member to set this system. or else new members will be joining in requesting their very specific troops.

---

How about when that new status oes away (about 5 dys), then you can do this. Before that, you can only set preferred troops and everything else is allowable.

I like this a lot !

Great Idea!

Supercell should definitely consider this!

check out "Donation log" feature - http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...on-log-feature

Perhaps that is solving you problem plus few others at once.

Great system Supercell should definitely release in the new update just a little changes should be put in place :)

Not a bad idea but as always has pros and cons

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by sirhybrid

I have been thinking about this for a while and I am finally posting this. This will completely change the donation system.

The first part of this is the donation filter and preferred troops. (P.S. The donation filter is so people don't get a lot pf donation points off wall breakers and other troops people do not want. I am not saying that I do not get the troops I want so please don't post something like, "If you don't want bad troops, change your clan.") When you hit request you will get a screen like the donation panel. On the top it will say " first choice." You pick a troop and set the minimum level on the bottom. Then, you hit he confirm button. The same will happen for second and third choice. Then, you will pick "allowable" troops. These are troops that you can have, but don't exactly want. You will choose a troop and set the reqired level. You will not hit the confirm button until you choose all the allowable troops. When you click on the troop you set a level and the level slider bar will go back to zero when you pick another troop. All other troops are not able to be donated. When you hit donate, those not allowed troops will not show up. Also, after you hit confirm on allowable troops it will tel you you first, second, third, and allowable troops. Then you hit confim a final time.


The way donation will work on his is that you will see the first second and third choice with the choice number above them.Then all the other troops will be below it.

The next part of this is the donation counter. The way this will work is that you have the tier troop it is (dark barracks could also be divided into tiers, I'm thinking mins and hogs 4, and the rest 5) multiplied by the housing space. For example, a giant is tier 2, so it would be 2 times 5 housing space = 10 points for a giant. An archer would be 1*1=1. I know a wizard is considered a tier 2 troop, but I think it should count as a tier three troop, so it would be 3*4=12. (this part before this was Nmills idea. Thanks Nmills!) Then, you would get 3 extra points for giving first choice, 2 for 2nd and 1 for 3rd. Currently the counter is by housing space, but in that system a wiz is less than a giant. This bonus would not show up on recieved counter, but the point to troops would stay.

Thanks for reading. Please comment and vote in the poll. I will take your comments into account. Keep this thread alive!

---

i like it, but one one post someone said that a pekka gets 10points 5 gobs gives 15points. how? wouldnt pekka get 75 and gobs 5?

I was wanting this update to come along for a very long time, unfortunately, i think clash is working on new troops and spells at the moment, i also heard that th 11 is gonna come out this year, that is huge so i think supercell would focus mainly on that and not this filter thing. Great idea but it will take a long time for this to come out!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by warheads123

I was wanting this update to come along for a very long time, unfortunately, i think clash is working on new troops and spells at the moment, i also heard that th 11 is gonna come out this year, that is huge so i think supercell would focus mainly on that and not this filter thing. Great idea but it will take a long time for this to come out!

---

Yeah... you "heard" more silly players' speculation. Maybe it will, but that could easily hurt the game.


I like this, except for the difference in points. I think we should keep the points the same. Also, you should not be able to request a troop and/or level that your clan doesn't have yet.


Great