Do something against hoppers, I have an idea. We could make a thing, that when you join a clan and you leave you can't join a new one until you wait atleast 12h. I hope you will add that to the game. :)
Printable View
Do something against hoppers, I have an idea. We could make a thing, that when you join a clan and you leave you can't join a new one until you wait atleast 12h. I hope you will add that to the game. :)
I like this idea. Hoppers are a big problem. Another idea was to not let people leave a clan until they have donated at least the same number of troops that they have received for said clan. If they are kicked out before they can match donations, then they get locked out of clans for a day or something.
Would be bad for people switching between clans in an alliance. If you dislike with people coming and requesting before leaving stop donating troops to new recruits. Hopping is a problem if you make it into one.
What happens if u dont like a clan? A few days ago, I went through like, 10 clans in 10 minutes because none of them were active.
What's the point of being in a clan if you are not going to donate or receive troops? Why would a new recruit stay if they never get troops?Quote:
Originally Posted by Glaciesvir
Seems like alliances need to be made official and movement between clans in an alliance would be an exception to this rule.
Who said never? Simole donate before requesting raises the bar for hoppers. In the end if you give archers to new recruits you risk losing very little elixir.Quote:
Originally Posted by oFFCeNTauR
So your clan has never had any hoppers? I really do not see how being in a clan that gets hoppers makes hopping my fault.Quote:
Originally Posted by Glaciesvir
It doesn't seem like you would ever get quality players if you don't offer donations to new recruits. We have a good group of 30 or so solid donators, and donation ratios are heavily watched, but we still get hoppers.
Maybe we'll give not donating to new members a shot... I mean, what's the worst that can happen? The only problem I see is my points for donating will slow down.
*sigh* why do people make 500 threads about the same thing. this is hard because many people, when trying to find a good clan, join one and realize they aren't active, or maybe the clan just isn't for them. so they have to wait 12 hours to get a clan?!
if there was a ban on joining clans. it would have to be a rule like " joining 5 clans in 'x' minutes is a 2 hour ban"
can't be 12 hours. way to long
The entire idea behind this is flawed. What about clans who allow visiting other clans? Not every clan puts a ball and chain on their members.
Hopping isn't your fault. Making an issue out of it and complaining about it is. There is no way to prevent hoppers without also penalizing innocent people who change clans regularly that are not malicious.Quote:
Originally Posted by oFFCeNTauR
Quality players also understand what hopping is. If you explain the policy and why it is in place when they join, quality people will understand.Quote:
Originally Posted by oFFCeNTauR
When new people join, explain to them that because of the hopper issue you'd prefer they donate X amount first before requesting high value troops. If they do it anyway, kick them. If you're getting bent out of shape over people leaving after receiving archers, it's you with the problem and not them.
Alternatively, consider the donations a recruiting cost. If you feel that the donations are required in order to obtain quality players, then so be it.
So why do you care? Hoppers prop up your donation numbers.Quote:
Originally Posted by oFFCeNTauR