Anti hopper idea

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by f0rmle55

At first glance I do agree with this concept as most would with regards to brandishing players that 'hop' around from clan to clan, my only concern is how would you differentiate between those who 'hop' just to fill thier clan castles up from Donating clans, Those that never stay in a clan for more then 5 minutes and those that go around visiting friends clans

---

True i do this myself

After 10 reports he could have a symbol next to his name that represents he is a hopper

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by f0rmle55

At first glance I do agree with this concept as most would with regards to brandishing players that 'hop' around from clan to clan, my only concern is how would you differentiate between those who 'hop' just to fill thier clan castles up from Donating clans, Those that never stay in a clan for more then 5 minutes and those that go around visiting friends clans

---

How you diferentiate is only report people who do the join request then leave. The exception to that is in a donating clan. Were you thinking that people get automatically reported for being a hopper? If so, that is not the case. Reporting someone for being a hopper is a manual thing.

I made a simpler post earlier, my idea was that instead of a tag (which is a great idea!), it should say on their profile etc, how many clans they have been in, how many they took and donated.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Kowalski711

I made a simpler post earlier, my idea was that instead of a tag (which is a great idea!), it should say on their profile etc, how many clans they have been in, how many they took and donated.

---

That's a good idea, but the only problem is what if they went to a donating clan? That can throw their numbers off drastically, making it apear they are a hopper, but really arn't.

this idea is just like getting reported and banned in global for no reason

I don't see this being very productive...but I don't see hopping being very productive either, so I guess im neutral on this idea for now, until further notice. Good thinking though!

this is a great idea. i would make the reports a higher munber.

clan hopping is bad. but abusing the hopper tagging is worse.

I've been in the same clan the entire time I've played clash. So I'm just wondering why people think hopping is such a bad thing? They get a few troops that takes a minute to replace you get A few xp.