Solution to Cheap Shielding and Other Common Clans Problems

This idea is born in another thread about cheap shields that I suggest you to read because very interesting.
http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...-to-STOP-IT%21
The idea is the following:

One season lasts 14 days and should be divided in 2 periods: PERIOD A and PERIOD B. In my opinionn the PERIOD A should last 6 days and PERIOD B should last 8 days, but the duration can be discussed and changed at will.
The two periods have different characteristics:

PERIOD A

• Clans can recruit
• Clans can change description and requisites to join
• Leader/Co-leaders can promote members
• Leader/CO-leader can invite players
• Players can join the clans
• Leader/Co-Leader can expell players that are banned only for 1 day
• Members can leave the clan

more or less as it is now

PERIOD B

• Clans can't recruit
• Clans can't change description and requisites to join
• Leader/Co-leaders can't promote members
• Leader/Co-Leaders can't invite players
• Leader/CO-leaders can expell a member but this member will be banned for the rest of the season from the clan
• Player can join the clans ONLY IF the clans have less than 40 players
• Members can't leave the clan

BENEFITS: Top players are obliged to stay in their clans during period b of the season and they can't go out to receive cheap shield and if they do that they can't join again till the end of the season.
Clans are more stable during the end of the season.

This solution can be implemented when SC will implement the CLAN WARS (they said that they will implement it) and can help to make to make it more easy and efficient.


Thanks kissofdeath for the original idea.Feel free to comment and try to IMPROVE this idea!

Ty

As i already mentioned in the other post this is a terrible idea.

Here just one question that remain unanswered from the previous thread;

Let take the first example where I ask if a leader can boot, your answer 'Not in the closed period'. So you could end up with a situation of a non welcome member donating goblins and abusing clan chat for 8 days with the leader powerless to do anything?

The saying 'taking a sledge hammer to crack a nut' spring to mind.

The idea is flawed on so many levels.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by VincentVegas

As i already mentioned in the other post this is a terrible idea.

Here just one question that remain unanswered from the previous thread;

Let take the first example where I ask if a leader can boot, your answer 'Not in the closed period'. So you could end up with a situation of a non welcome member donating goblins and abusing clan chat for 8 days with the leader powerless to do anything?

The saying 'taking a sledge hammer to crack a nut' spring to mind.

The idea is flawed on so many levels.

---

PERIOD B

• Clans can't recruit
• Clans can't change description and requisites to join
• Leader/Co-leaders can't promote members
• Leader/Co-Leaders can't invite players
• Leader/CO-leaders can expell a member but this member will be banned for the rest of the season from the clan
• Player can join the clans ONLY IF the clans have less than 40 players
• Members can't leave the clan

This should be in the ideas subforums.


As far as my opinion goes, i don't see how it benefits current players. What will this system achieve other than restricting the movement of players between clans?

How does this elaborate clan system improves the average player's gameplay experience?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Sandalhat

This should be in the ideas subforums.


As far as my opinion goes, i don't see how it benefits current players. What will this system achieve other than restricting the movement of players between clans?

How does this elaborate clan system improves the average player's gameplay experience?

---

removing the cheap shields at least in the most important days of the season, dissuading people to change clan too often, fighting people that join clans, ask troops and then leave and many other improvements

Supercell just need to make it so while you are in a clan, you can leave all you want to visit but for matchmaking purposes make it so they are still tied to their previous clan.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by thisismine

removing the cheap shields at least in the most important days of the season, dissuading people to change clan too often, fighting people that join clans, ask troops and then leave and many other improvements

---

Personally, this change affects me in a negative way.

I don't care about what happens at the top, i hop from clan to clan to socialize, my clan is basically a hub for visitors, i enjoy forum clan activities such as FE (lots of visiting among the four FE clans), and Sky family has this whole open house session during festive seasons like the last Winter Sky.

So, forgive me if i hate this idea because it basically takes away ALL my in game social aspect enjoyment.

So I cant go visit people.

If I get booted I can only join a clan with 39 members.

And this soloution is meant to solve what issue, it certainly doesnt solve cheap shielding.

Lets put this into context. 0.2% of members are champs. Of that % a smaller number may be using a technique to shield themselves and you want to bring in a solution which affects everyone? And at best the solution works for 60% of the time.

If you need to address this issue why dont u look at the idea of no shield without a 1 star in champs?

Yeah i agree,You're trying to change the whole game based on a very very minute amount of players.Its akin to putting fences around every road in the world because 0.2% of people Jay-walk.Its ludicrous

This is changing the whole game for a tiny minority AND a dumb idea.

It's like spray painting the whole of North America because you want it to match the color shirt you put on today!