Why no xp for upgrading heros?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by P1ckrd

Not fair to who has already upgraded walls and other stuff.

---

the xp would just add what was already upgraded. Not like asking for a refund for builds becoming cheaper.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Anarchos

By this logic you'd get no XP if you gemed your upgrade times on anything because it would be no time.

---

I thought gemmers don't get xp for any time that is gemmed... If you start a level 7 tesla upgrade, and wait 5 minutes and then gem, I was under the impression that you would get xp for just the 5 minutes, and the remainder of the 14 day period didn't give xp because xp was determined by actual upgrade time, not potential upgrade time...

I swear I've seen super low levels on upper tier bases and when looking at the GG and HH profile it was clear they had gemmed. I always figured this explained why...

Maybe it was just misinterpretation of what I was looking at though.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Dragonz04

Actually the builders pound away on the heros altar and it does count as a percentage the last time i checked, so should count as a structure

---

I'm pretty sure that the builder moves between the anvil and the cauldron of coals. This is the case for the BK at least. He is forging his sword and armor, not upgrading the altar.

I still wish the BK would sit there and guzzle dark elixir, and maybe even act a little tipsy like hiccuping and nodding off and stuff, while the poor little builder worked over the hot flames for days on end. I mean, that is why he is powerful, right? Because he was a normal barb that got into the dark elixir, haha. So if he is getting more powerful, it's because he has been into the dark elixir again, right?

For people that say XP means nothing they haven't tried joining a clan with XP (Level) Requirements. It apparently does mean something.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by thisismine

i agree
LAB UPGRADES = no xp because you you don't use your builders
WALLS UPGRADES = no xp 'cause you don't spend time

HERO UPGRADE = no xp BUT you use your builders and you spend a lot of time

so this must be fixed

---

Hmm this is pretty valid logic. But why the need for increasing exp earning potential ? Honestly levels hold no value in our game. Just bragging rights.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by XxA1xX

Hmm this is pretty valid logic. But why the need for increasing exp earning potential ? Honestly levels hold no value in our game. Just bragging rights.

---

true, But lots of clan recruit based on levels so I think that they should add this

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by cottoninthewoods

true, But lots of clan recruit based on levels so I think that they should add this

---

I can see this point and it is valid the clan I'm in does this. But my concern is that the exp given has to be low so as to not gain levels every upgrade. Maybe like 25-100 exp per upgrade max. Got to remember there's 40 levels to BK n AQ.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by gorzo93

1 Are heroes a building?
2 Are you donating the heroes?
3 Are you completing an achievement each time you upgrade your hero?
4 Are you destroying a town hall by upgrading your hero?
5 Is your hero an obstacle and are you removing it?

---

1 At least King is as big as a building? At least when raged.
2 Yes, all my troops are real heroes and I do donate them!
3 It is a huge achievement to get your hero upgraded so shouldn't it count? :)
4 Yes, by upgrading my heroes I get to destroy THs :)
5 Yes, I do remove my hero sometimes by putting him/her to sleep :)

(Sorry, I just had to :D)

-Lor