Challenge Mode

Printable View

February 23rd, 2014
Hi5er

Challenge Mode

Hi all I know I'm new here, but I have an idea (shocking!), also, apologies if this has been suggested before!

I know we have the league table system going on so you can see who you are ranked with and my idea revolves around that to some degree.

Challenge Mode

The premise is simple, when you click someones name you have the option to "view Profile", "visit" or "view clan" (I think that's the only 3?). My idea is to add a fourth option that reads "Request Challenge".

This would send the user a message that someone wishes to challenge them. At this point the user could accept or reject the invitation (like the reply/revenge buttons in Defence log), perhaps there could be a list of all the people challenging you and you could just select yes whenever you wanted, I would suggest that there would be no pop-up so high ranked players don't get spammed.

The challenge would give each player a chance to attack one after the other.

The only problem I can see is people exploiting this to boost up trophies / resources, so maybe make this a free mode so you don't actually compete for anything except bragging rights? Or maybe you can only challenge the same players once a week?

I think it could be a cool concept - what are your thoughts guys?
February 24th, 2014
Tystervale

good idea, just no rewards like loot or trophies or shields
February 24th, 2014
Btu2001

Good idea great for groups of flashers and people competing in leagues
February 24th, 2014
Hi5er

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tystervale

good idea, just no rewards like loot or trophies or shields

Exactly, as long as it's not exploitable I see no issue.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Btu2001

Good idea great for groups of flashers and people competing in leagues

My thoughts as well! Although I think it should be renamed to "Clash Mode".
February 24th, 2014
HansClashOfClans

What I like most about this idea is that it would give us something to do while... well.. waiting!
February 25th, 2014
Hi5er

Quote:

Originally Posted by HansClashOfClans

What I like most about this idea is that it would give us something to do while... well.. waiting!

My thoughts exactly! I'm getting daunted by the prospect of waiting 2 days for my TH4 to level up... Can't imagine what I'll be like when I get higher up haha...
February 28th, 2014
Hi5er

Tinylilbump
February 28th, 2014
001rens001

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hi5er

My thoughts exactly! I'm getting daunted by the prospect of waiting 2 days for my TH4 to level up... Can't imagine what I'll be like when I get higher up haha...

2 days ? later your mines are going to cost twice as much :) !

better stack up some gems bro .....
April 29th, 2015
Dragnovich
(sorry for my english any way)
I have the same idea ... Ok this is what I think how it sould be done ...
1. Allow Challenges Button (as in the Available to war)
2. Allow Challenges options from anybody, or only from clan members.
3. You can challenge Users in General chat, or your clan members (or other clan members (optional))
4. User1 "Challenge user2" and selects the troops he want to bet (they sould had them already made, as if they will be donated).
5. User2 gets the Challenge and Accept or reject it. If accepted, he choice the troops he had and bet them too, (also they had to be already created)
6. then user1 can accept or reject the bet. if not accepted, challenge is terminated.
7. If accepted by both, Both had UP TO One hour for preparation of troops* (active war village is used, so you can change it to avoid clan mates to peek your town before), how ever the can anytime, click a button "Battle NOW!"
8. Preferibly, Both attacks sould be done at the same time... (or the attacks sold be done in maximum one more hour) (Max, One hour for preparation and one for attack)
9. User with highest % wins
10. Untie criteria ... 1) Destruction percentage 2) lowest attack time 3) resources used 4) if still tied .. TIE Challenge no wins. Troops in bet are LOST
11. Winner get the troops in HIS CAMPS!! how ever they sould have space to accommodate them. If not.. troop is lost.
FAIR BATTLE CRITERIA:
1. Yes it sould NOT MAKE YOU WIN ANYTHING, (resources, xp or tropies)
2. As You can BET troops! only (like donating) this will cost you elixir (pink or dark depending on the troop)
3. How ever it SOULD not cost you also NOTHING so Is just for FUN (or PRACTICE). Or will cost ONLY for the one who START THE CHALLENGE (but I think is unfair also).
4. All troops used in the challenge sould be FREE and with no time creation. And I say FREE troops 0 cost of elixir. 0s Time Creation. Troops not used in battle will be lost also. ( no mercy xD )
5. What can you use?? both users get the highest troops of the lowest player. I mean if User1 has Golems Lv1 and User2 has golems Lv3, both gets Golems Lv1, if User 1 Has wiches and User2 does not have them, none will get access to wiches.
6. You can make only a few challenges per day. and can't challenge the same user in some time.
7. You will be blocked for challenge (accept or request) if you are in War (preparation or battle day)
8. If you are in a challenge you cant participate in war during the challenge.
9. Won troops cant be used in war?
JUST FOR FUN:
No troop bet ... You can also bet a FLAG or something that says like "SHAME ON ME", so if you loose your town will have a flag or something that says User1 is my master or something fun text that the users both agree to place. in their town. for a day or something, so when somebody attacks you can see that...

:thumbsup:
April 29th, 2015
Chaoslorder

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hi5er

Hi all I know I'm new here, but I have an idea (shocking!), also, apologies if this has been suggested before!

I know we have the league table system going on so you can see who you are ranked with and my idea revolves around that to some degree.

Challenge Mode

The premise is simple, when you click someones name you have the option to "view Profile", "visit" or "view clan" (I think that's the only 3?). My idea is to add a fourth option that reads "Request Challenge".

This would send the user a message that someone wishes to challenge them. At this point the user could accept or reject the invitation (like the reply/revenge buttons in Defence log), perhaps there could be a list of all the people challenging you and you could just select yes whenever you wanted, I would suggest that there would be no pop-up so high ranked players don't get spammed.

The challenge would give each player a chance to attack one after the other.

The only problem I can see is people exploiting this to boost up trophies / resources, so maybe make this a free mode so you don't actually compete for anything except bragging rights? Or maybe you can only challenge the same players once a week?

I think it could be a cool concept - what are your thoughts guys?

I think all of it should be free and you can decide if there is a penalty for the looser
April 29th, 2015
Evo2356

Great Idea

I think this would be great for trying out new types of attacks. Clash On!!!
April 29th, 2015
Chaoslorder

Quote:

Originally Posted by Evo2356

I think this would be great for trying out new types of attacks. Clash On!!!

Unfortunately I have to disagree because it can be used as an attack simulator
April 29th, 2015
Topherccino

Great idea. and it serves as something to occupy time.
April 29th, 2015
Chaoslorder

Quote:

Originally Posted by Topherccino

Great idea. and it serves as something to occupy time.

I think I should give you a random base instead of the same one
April 29th, 2015
Dragnovich

Quote:

Originally Posted by Chaoslorder

Unfortunately I have to disagree because it can be used as an attack simulator

That's why I suggested to NOT be available during CLAN war or while participants are in a war. So you cant SIMULATE a battle that is in your actual clan war.

To be fair and just for fun this sould be only available in NO WAR MODE. :D
April 29th, 2015
Chaoslorder

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dragnovich

That's why I suggested to NOT be available during CLAN war or while participants are in a war. So you cant SIMULATE a battle that is in your actual clan war.

To be fair and just for fun this sould be only available in NO WAR MODE. :D

What about revenge attacks tho
April 29th, 2015
Dragnovich

Quote:

Originally Posted by Chaoslorder

What about revenge attacks tho

Good point .. how ever as I propossed ... the users will get the lowest troops AND BUILDING LEVELS of both users .. so is very difficult that the weakest player has EXACTLY the same buildings and wall levels, as the one on their revenge log. (not imposible but very difficult yes)

This maybe can be fixed with a random village from an other user with the same buildings that you as you suggested.
But why if you get one of those troll villages that are in the game... that will be frustrating. I think
April 29th, 2015
Chaoslorder

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dragnovich

Good point .. how ever as I propossed ... the users will get the lowest troops AND BUILDING LEVELS of both users .. so is very difficult that the weakest player has EXACTLY the same buildings and wall levels, as the one on their revenge log. (not imposible but very difficult yes)

This maybe can be fixed with a random village from an other user with the same buildings that you as you suggested.
But why if you get one of those troll villages that are in the game... that will be frustrating. I think

I think that all of the defences and buildings should be either 1or2 levels above or below just to stop maxed people for their th from duplicating the base as this is the most predictable way of this happening
April 29th, 2015
Dragnovich

Quote:

Originally Posted by Chaoslorder

I think that all of the defences and buildings should be either 1or2 levels above or below just to stop maxed people for their th from duplicating the base as this is the most predictable way of this happening

NoI dont think that will work ... what will do a lv2 cannon vs lv1 golem! or pekka

xD

maybe add some unmovable obstacles to the map so the users had to remap their village some rocks or stones randomly but in the same place for both users