Boom!

Okay, my idea. It's to cut down on people getting wiped out by others 40 levels above them.

So, with Town Hall level, there should be a minimum trophy count. This way, if you have a Town Hall of 10, you can't attack someone with a Town Hall of 6. I know this would make it so that people would not be able to be demoted into another league quite as easy as before. I just thought it would get rid of the aggravating annoyance of being wiped out by people who have no business attacking people so low.

Also, I am in no means trying to anger anyone. I am just getting highly irritated.

So if you are a town hall 6 in master's league you literally can't be attacked?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by pokeguy1223

So if you are a town hall 6 in master's league you literally can't be attacked?

---

I don't know. Since it is an idea, that means that it can tweaked and perfected. Is there a Town Hall level 6 in Master?

So i take it that you ONLY attack someone if they are the same TH or higher as you?I find it very hard to believe that you dont attack lower TH's

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by CunningLinguists

So i take it that you ONLY attack someone if they are the same TH or higher as you?I find it very hard to believe that you dont attack lower TH's

---

That is not what I am saying. I am saying that I do not attack someone 30 to 40 levels below me, just because they are easy to attack. Also, this is merely an idea, not my way of complaining. Idea thread, is it not? My apologies.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TacoDave

I don't know. Since it is an idea, that means that it can tweaked and perfected. Is there a Town Hall level 6 in Master?

---

usually if you have to make exceptions, it's a weak idea.

there are DEFINITELY a few TH6s in master.

There was a TH3 in masters. This is how life is, suck it up and move on.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by PhilISuppose

usually if you have to make exceptions, it's a weak idea.

there are DEFINITELY a few TH6s in master.

---

Okay, so an initial idea, right out of the gate, is supposed to be a perfect idea? This makes sense in what universe? So, what's up with new versions of phones and what not?

i wouldn't suggest this. If you were a th 5 that somehow got into champions league or masters, you could just collect from collectors and never be attacked.

Eh. This isnt really needed. Its not like th10s steal much from th6.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Woski

Eh. This isnt really needed. Its not like th10s steal much from th6.

---

Yeah, I suppose losing over 100k from a guy 30 to 40 levels above me isn't all that bad. It could be worse, I could be getting attacked by someone my own level... LoL. Okay, it's only an idea. I am sorry that I had one. Just messing!!! Not in a ♥♥♥♥ty mood or anything.

If you dont want to get attacked by people 40 levels higher than you, stay in your own league comfort zone don't push or you will get attacked by better people.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TacoDave

Okay, so an initial idea, right out of the gate, is supposed to be a perfect idea? This makes sense in what universe? So, what's up with new versions of phones and what not?

---

I've said it before, but if you only want positive feedback email it to your mom.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SirColeman

If you dont want to get attacked by people 40 levels higher than you, stay in your own league comfort zone don't push or you will get attacked by better people.

---

True that, but I usually stay in Silver, but they're all over the place. It was an idea, nothing too bad. Not complaining either, just using it as an example.

so your taking farming out of the game yeah no this thread is bad

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by PhilISuppose

I've said it before, but if you only want positive feedback email it to your mom.

---

Yeah, I suppose, except it's not feedback at all, rather someone trying to poke holes in anything they don't agree with. An idea, is something that can be worked on a tweaked by people. I did not say anything about it being perfect, nor anything about it being a finished idea. Would it have been better if I had put it as a thought? Would that not offend?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by pleasehalpm

so your taking farming out of the game yeah no this thread is bad

---

Apologies. I just thought it was a good idea. I can understand that some people can not handle attacking people their own level, and rather can only attack those weaker than them. Wait, this sounds familiar...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TacoDave

Apologies. I just thought it was a good idea. I can understand that some people can not handle attacking people their own level, and rather can only attack those weaker than them. Wait, this sounds familiar...

---

so people do that yes they do but SC wants people to get good at the game that's why they made farmers also if they do attack you revenge them and take their town hall

100k gold is not a lot lol:p:p:p:p:p:p:p

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by pleasehalpm

so people do that yes they do but SC wants people to get good at the game that's why they made farmers also if they do attack you revenge them and take their town hall

---

Okay. It was an idea, and it does get irritating, but I am in no way complaining. I think that is what part of the problem is. I had an idea, and decided to voice it is all.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by pokeguy1223

So if you are a town hall 6 in master's league you literally can't be attacked?

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by CunningLinguists

So i take it that you ONLY attack someone if they are the same TH or higher as you?I find it very hard to believe that you dont attack lower TH's

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by PhilISuppose

usually if you have to make exceptions, it's a weak idea.

there are DEFINITELY a few TH6s in master.

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Pranav

There was a TH3 in masters. This is how life is, suck it up and move on.

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ClarkTheShnark

i wouldn't suggest this. If you were a th 5 that somehow got into champions league or masters, you could just collect from collectors and never be attacked.

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Woski

Eh. This isnt really needed. Its not like th10s steal much from th6.

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SirColeman

If you dont want to get attacked by people 40 levels higher than you, stay in your own league comfort zone don't push or you will get attacked by better people.

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by pleasehalpm

so your taking farming out of the game yeah no this thread is bad

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by pleasehalpm

so people do that yes they do but SC wants people to get good at the game that's why they made farmers also if they do attack you revenge them and take their town hall

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by pleasehalpm

100k gold is not a lot lol:p:p:p:p:p:p:p

---

(This message is for the people above) Why on earth are you guys getting so emotional about someone suggesting a idea, he even said that there would be tweaks and so what if its bad you don't have to rub it in his face that he is doing something wrong you should just say its wrong!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by PhilISuppose

I've said it before, but if you only want positive feedback email it to your mom.

---

Phil that is rude and childish why would you say something he is only suggesting something not stabbing you the balls!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Xanoas

(This message is for the people above) Why on earth are you guys getting so emotional about someone suggesting a idea, he even said that there would be tweaks and so what if its bad you don't have to rub it in his face that he is doing something wrong you should just say its wrong!



Phil that is rude and childish why would you say something he is only suggesting something not stabbing you the balls!

---

Come on!

He's basically told me not to comment if I think his idea is weak (and I do)
If people don't post negatviely about ideas that are; flawed and they don't like, it creates the false impression that the idea has only got support from the community.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by PhilISuppose

Come on!

He's basically told me not to comment if I think his idea is weak (and I do)
If people don't post negatviely about ideas that are; flawed and they don't like, it creates the false impression that the idea has only got support from the community.

---

I didnt say you shouldn't do that, i said that you should not be rude.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by PhilISuppose

Come on!

He's basically told me not to comment if I think his idea is weak (and I do)
If people don't post negatviely about ideas that are; flawed and they don't like, it creates the false impression that the idea has only got support from the community.

---

I never said not to comment, I just said that it was an idea that would need work. If you could point out when I said not to comment that'd be cool. You said it sucked, I said it needed work. Right? Yeah.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TacoDave

I never said not to comment, I just said that it was an idea that would need work. If you could point out when I said not to comment that'd be cool. You said it sucked, I said it needed work. Right? Yeah.

---

OK

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TacoDave

Okay, so an initial idea, right out of the gate, is supposed to be a perfect idea? This makes sense in what universe?

---

All I'd suggested was that for you to make your new rule work you were making exceptions, as people had pointed out flaws. (TH6 being essentially invulnerable at high trophies as higher TH would not be able to attack them)

I'm sorry that I didn't give more detailed feedback, I was more concerned at the time in logging my negativity than the reasons why.

#1
Level is a TERRIBLE indication of how strong someone is as from 0-75% (or more!) of their XP can have come from donations depending on if you want to be in a clan at all or want to be in a clan donating 10,000 troops per week. So basing Level to determine the players you should be matched against is bad.

#2
The game already allows only a fraction of someone's loot to be taken from them in a raid if there is a large difference in townhalls between players. So it's impossible that this is an issue. (The loot penalty is doing it's job)

#3
The game has a ranking system (pointless as it may be except at the highest end) that shows who wins the most battles/defenses. This is trophies and leagues. So the fact that another player has wiped out your base and won some trophies (and you have lost some) is just the result that he is better than you.
He either has a higher townhall, uses better troops, or has better tactics, but he is better than you. He wins/you lose.

What if supercell has you do attacks based on levels AND trophies, each weighted similarly.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by PhilISuppose

OK

All I'd suggested was that for you to make your new rule work you were making exceptions, as people had pointed out flaws. (TH6 being essentially invulnerable at high trophies as higher TH would not be able to attack them)

I'm sorry that I didn't give more detailed feedback, I was more concerned at the time in logging my negativity than the reasons why.

#1
Level is a TERRIBLE indication of how strong someone is as from 0-75% (or more!) of their XP can have come from donations depending on if you want to be in a clan at all or want to be in a clan donating 10,000 troops per week. So basing Level to determine the players you should be matched against is bad.

#2
The game already allows only a fraction of someone's loot to be taken from them in a raid if there is a large difference in townhalls between players. So it's impossible that this is an issue. (The loot penalty is doing it's job)

#3
The game has a ranking system (pointless as it may be except at the highest end) that shows who wins the most battles/defenses. This is trophies and leagues. So the fact that another player has wiped out your base and won some trophies (and you have lost some) is just the result that he is better than you.
He either has a higher townhall, uses better troops, or has better tactics, but he is better than you. He wins/you lose.

---

Okay. That makes sense. Thanks for the clarification.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Brownie38

What if supercell has you do attacks based on levels AND trophies, each weighted similarly.

---

That was kind of what I was going for. I just was using a Town Hall as an example. I didn't think it would work just based on Town Hall. Just trying to get people to see what I was meaning.