Clan mate sparing

I'm sorry is this has already been suggested. I think it would be great if you could spar with your clan mates. Free of cost or for very little resources. You would use the troops you've trained but not loose them afterwards. There would be no exp/resource/trophy gains and no shield after a loss. I believe this would help people modify their bases to be more fortified, or learn better strategies for attacking. All in all making for better clan experiences. Perhaps even if you could test your own base with your own troops/spells etc.. And likewise with no gains or losses.. I hope this get seen, because myself and my clan all think this would be a great idea to implement to improve an already great game.

Hello,

I cannot undertsna what you are asking here,

A battle simulator?

This is a good idea, But it won't be here for a long time :(

Basically you can practice your raiding technique or have you clan mates attack your base to find weaknesses. But with out consequence.

The ideas is good, i think even wilder.
how if we can fight our own clan member once a month to pick a new leader to sit at his throne.
So that the new leader can sometimes give a lesson to bad clan member.

The idea can be widely changed and additions made to improve further. I just thought the basic idea of it was a good one. I have seen nearly the same "testing" in other freemium games.

No chance of it happening in a long long time :(

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by fenn93

No chance of it happening in a long long time :(

---

I like it. Why not?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by soccercrazy1

I like it. Why not?

---

I agree, of course. I'm no code writer but seriously why won't it be around for a while?

Is there a way to get some supercell input here?

I think this is a very good idea for once, although, OP, please make the thread more elaborate and detailed so your idea will be taken seriously.

Okay, I'll try to be more elaborate.

Imagine this, your chatting with your clan mates about how badly you've been getting beaten on defence. Your all throwing different ideas around to better fortify your base. You make the suggested changes but of course you can't put them to the test without possibly paying the consequences of trophy loss, and resource loss. This is one major part of my idea. If you could request someone within your clan to "raid" you (within your Town Hall/Trophy range of course) to find weak points in your defence and how your defence stand up to various troops. After the "raid" you would be able to better adjust your base to be more fortified against enemy troops.

Another scenario! Imagine your having trouble raiding, or finding a good technique. So, rather than taking advice from others or having to watch videos or reading raiding guides you could take the troops that you have trained in your army camps and "raid" a clanmate. You can test your different troops to find their strengths and weaknesses and how some work better together.

That's it for the theory behind my idea, now for the details.

If you were defending a clan mates "raid"
- You would not loose or gain trophies like you would in a multiplayer battle.
- You would not loose resources if your defence lost.
- Your clan castle toops would be returned after the battle was over.
- If you lost you would not be given a shield.
- Bombs and other traps would be automatically reset afterwards.

If you were attacking a clan mate
- You would not gain(or loose) trophies.
- You would not gain resources.
- All troops you used would be returned afterwards likewise with spells.

Basically it's like nothing ever happened, except for the knowledge gained from practice. There could be a minimal resource cost, such as 1000 gold/elixir. It can be an option in the player profile or when you press on them in chat.

Honestly I don't know how I can explain it any better. It's a fake battle, for getting better at the game. For not getting beaten.

Hope that's suffice.

I think a battle simulator would just throw the game, it's really easy to abuse it, say you want to revenge someone, Not sure if you're going to beat it? Ask a clannie to duplicate the base and just practice until you get that perfect army comp

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by FlyingH1gh

I think a battle simulator would just throw the game, it's really easy to abuse it, say you want to revenge someone, Not sure if you're going to beat it? Ask a clannie to duplicate the base and just practice until you get that perfect army comp

---

Thats a lot of effort for one revenge

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Cranfordsteve

Thats a lot of effort for one revenge

---

The principal still stands, adding a sandbox mode into the game removes strategy. If you can repeat attacks until you 3 star a base it takes away skill/strategy. -1

LOL i read through the sticky post, but i didn't see this post until after i just posted mine called, "Defense Tester". I agree with this! It will keep people more active while waiting for their upgrades to finish. But maybe only allow so many tests on fellow clan members per day or something too, so people don't get too burnt out on fake attacking... Idk, but great idea!

It's a good idea...I don't know why so many people r saying it'll never happen. The only change I would make maybe, is that u do lose your troops afterwards simply to avoid over usage. That's just a suggestion, and it may be shot down since it may lead to people not using it at all due to loss of resources

Asking somone to replicate a base simply so you could 3 star is ridiculous. Firstly they would need to have Exactally the same level structures, traps, defences, walls, etc.. And who knows what troops are in their clan castle. And how exactly does it remove strategy? Wouldn't it better your strategies? For attacking and defending bases? This idea has already been implemented into other games, but it's a simple test in which you use your own troops to attack your own base. And hell if supercell wants another dig at peoples wallets, they can add a cool down timer which you can remove with gems. Perhaps if they reduced the time in which you could "revenge" battle someone, it would eliminate the ability to "abuse" my idea as some of you so truly believe it would be. Rather than instantly shooting an idea down, why not get creative and think of ways to possibly get this implemented into the game?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Cranfordsteve

Asking somone to replicate a base simply so you could 3 star is ridiculous. Firstly they would need to have Exactally the same level structures, traps, defences, walls, etc.. And who knows what troops are in their clan castle. And how exactly does it remove strategy? Wouldn't it better your strategies? For attacking and defending bases? This idea has already been implemented into other games, but it's a simple test in which you use your own troops to attack your own base. And hell if supercell wants another dig at peoples wallets, they can add a cool down timer which you can remove with gems. Perhaps if they reduced the time in which you could "revenge" battle someone, it would eliminate the ability to "abuse" my idea as some of you so truly believe it would be. Rather than instantly shooting an idea down, why not get creative and think of ways to possibly get this implemented into the game?

---

Yah I support this idea. Supercell is definitely going to add this feature in the next update along with clan wars and the rest. Its in the stickies.


Major Additions:
* Clan vs Clan
* Dueling/challenge/simulator/sparring battle area
* Clan villages = all clan members contribute, leaders control
* Add more single player levels (permanent ones)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Rhema

Yah I support this idea. Supercell is definitely going to add this feature in the next update along with clan wars and the rest. Its in the stickies.


Major Additions:
* Clan vs Clan
* Dueling/challenge/simulator/sparring battle area
* Clan villages = all clan members contribute, leaders control
* Add more single player levels (permanent ones)

---

Thank you for the support. :)

Its not going to happen, it is exploitable, you see this guy who attacked you, and want to revenge him, but you dotn knwo if you cna ahndle him, easy you ask a member if he wants to chnage his base to the base of your revenge attack, and you test out how to do it against your clan mates, also, I believe it has been ruled out because of this.

the programming would be to complicated.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by kjeldinator

its not going to happen, it is exploitable, you see this guy who attacked you, and want to revenge him, but you dotn knwo if you cna ahndle him, easy you ask a member if he wants to chnage his base to the base of your revenge attack, and you test out how to do it against your clan mates, also, i believe it has been ruled out because of this.

---

the person would need the exact same buildings and walls.

​smaller font needed

Not everything in the stickies is going to happen, there are also thigns that won't be added
secondly, you say replicating is alot of efford, but what if that revenge will give you 59 trophies and 1m+ loot? i think you would do it, its exploitable and SC wont add it, done

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Kjeldinator

Not everything in the stickies is going to happen, there are also thigns that won't be added
secondly, you say replicating is alot of efford, but what if that revenge will give you 59 trophies and 1m+ loot? i think you would do it, its exploitable and SC wont add it, done

---

Do you work for SC? Becuase if not your "done" holds zero ground. Again, I say. They would need the EXACT same layout/building/walls/defense AND at all the same lvl. Would I do it? Hell no, I don't care enough about being at the top of the leaderboard and I believe the people who think that by being at the top of the leaderboard gives them some form of "status" are ridiculous.

They dont need same level, just same levle townhall, and that isnt too hard to find, unless youre in a bad clan, then you automatically also have the same building etc, perhaps different levels, but yon can at leats find strategies on how to defeat it.
Also, SC has ruled out the idea of attackign yourself, how would attacking a clanmate be different, you ask eachother to attack and you find weaknesses in your base, its not going to happen, just thrust me(and use smaller font, are you trying to capslock me to death?)
And you think being at top is rediculous, have you ever even tried going up there, its hard, if you manage to do it, youre amazing, it gives a great feel.

The reasons for this idea, other than programming problems, are mediocre excuses if you ask me. I like the idea. It adds a bit of friendly competition to clans.

Yes, even if not clan mate sparing there should be battle sims. Not only for attack but for defense too.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ForLeLulz

the person would need the exact same buildings and walls.

---

very true. plus it can be that in sims the base is set according to your league level

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by soccercrazy1

I like it. Why not?

---

Supercell don't think this should be implemented, It's not ruled out, Just they think it can be abused easily, You might say, How can it be abused? Well, This game is all about Strategy, And improving Bases and improving Offense strategy, They want it so when you actually get raided you find the weakness spots there, And, Some people (Like me) Would just use it for fun.

In my opinion, I think we should be able (if this ever gets implemented) To slectet what level of troops we want, The troops and spells we want, And to select a Timer or no Timer, Infinite troops, Or selected number dl troops Or as many troops as you can fit in your army camps, And lastly to not have a Cooldown.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Kjeldinator

They dont need same level, just same levle townhall

---

So your telling me that wall lvl, defense structure lvl, all other structures lvl(hp) won't make a difference in a battle? As long as you have the same TH lvl? Upgrading at high lvls as I hope you know doesn't happen overnight. So what about if SC put a timer on how long you have to revenge attack? And it's a one shot deal, once you click it, you have one chance. Win or loose. Also the person you revenge attack doesn't have the opportunity to revenge attack you after your revenge attack against them, thus eliminating the ability to study an opponents base.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Pastapio18

The reasons for this idea, other than programming problems, are mediocre excuses if you ask me. I like the idea. It adds a bit of friendly competition to clans.

---

Thank you for your support, and I couldn't agree more about the mediocre excuses. I'd like to get some SC programmer/mods input on this matter.

Sparring* Two R's not one.Sparing is like can you spare my life?Thanks for sparing my life lol sorry i had to do it

Ofc you cna study their base, just click on them and tap visit

I think this is not a good idea, you can just visit your enemy's clan and find out the best troop comp when it doesn't count for trophies and then leave and when the real battle for trophies happens, you can just wreck their base