Printable View
I was attacked 3 times in the last hour. First two I won but lost some loot, my heroes, my traps and my can castle troops. Third attacked I was 3 starred obviously. In the end I lost over a million of combined loot PLUS over 100k Gold to restore my traps. What did I get in return? ♥♥♥♥ all, a few meaningless trophies.
Thanks Supercell, I guess.
yep, it would be nice. I don't see why they can't put it into the game. Would it really mess with the system that much??
It would also bring more loot into the economy which would help solve the loot problem many are experiencing.
More importantly people would actually get rewarded for successful defences, which makes total sense. At the moment, unless you're trophy pushing, you're being punished for winning. The irony.Quote:
Originally Posted by TomRapp
Couldn't agree more with this concept, potential increase in loot for the high defend it is? just like the league bonus for attacking
You already get trophies for a succesful defense a hand full of meaningless should be more then enough to compensate for the loot that you lost.
Not at all, trophies essentially mean nothing to a farmer....Quote:
Originally Posted by Genie86
even for trophy hunters this is needed. I have won on defense (losing my cc troops, some traps and 100k of each resource) and gained 20 trophies. Won again for 10 trophies (but lost the rest of my traps and another 100k of each resource. Then lost 29 trophies to a 3 star, which also took 200k of each resource. All in all, I gained 1 trophy and lost 400k of each resource (plus the cost to rearm traps) for winning 2 out of 3 attacks.
So yeah, a defensive bonus would be much appreciated
Not interested in this suggestion, sorry. I'd rather they just increased league bonuses in a BIG way from Crystal upwards.
And how does that help out winning a defense like this post is about?Quote:
Originally Posted by Akali
Loot bonuses are for raiding since you deserved it, when your defending, as a player you do nothing. Why would you receive loot for being offline. I would suggest bring up the loot bonus for lower leagues, the top ones already have enough imo.
Oh yeah lets see...Quote:
Originally Posted by Genie86
attack:
if won: you gain resources, get a league bonus and win trophies
if you lose: you most likely gain resources and lose trophies
defending:
if won: you lose resources, lose trap rearming costs and gain trophies
if lost: you lose resources and trophies
Seems pretty unbalanced to me, that means defending with the TH inside is useless unless you are in champion or dont have any resources to raid
So your saying if a person dropped 1 archer on your base and then surrendered you should get a league bonus?
That would be awesome...but that would boost the loot over the edge.
People against this idea either are crazy, never pushed trophies or are low th level
Sarcasm is hard to convey over the forums.Quote:
Originally Posted by Gubert
You know that only happens on your leagues with awful bonus right... 5k gold for winning that defense wont boost the loot over the edge sorry to sayQuote:
Originally Posted by SiLeNtCoYoTe
Im th9 and got into master league... I must be crazyQuote:
Originally Posted by Gubert
Thats in the low th level categoryQuote:
Originally Posted by RKO
If I remember correctly, this is ruled out
Its now listed as something they are considering. I do think it would be tricky to implement without being abused to much.Quote:
Originally Posted by Somerandomguy64
the league bonus could be abused with free elixirs out =)
Yeah sure everybody wants to get free elixir even though they lose the battle at c1 and above...Quote:
Originally Posted by footfetish
no wait they dont
That and like someone mentioned up there, imagine trying to drop cups to go farm lol:confused: Then what? That would change the whole day manic of the game of you either farm fora very long time or face whatever they come up with an if atkr was to lose loot for lost atk then god help us lol,:rolleyes:Quote:
Originally Posted by Beagle21
your suggestion is not healthy for supercell income...so sorry to hear lol
Pretty OBVIOUS really. It means I am not in favour of the suggestion :rolleyes:Quote:
Originally Posted by Terraist
I can't see the logic in being against that, maybe hardcore farmers who never win a defense because their TH is always outside.
Every farmer has their th outside. On a positive note for Supercell, if the loot bonuses are good it could stop farming :rolleyes:Quote:
Originally Posted by madmonk3y
I push in a weird way now, because that is how they've designed the game. I play for 6 hours straight, got from 1500-2000 day one and 2000-2450 today (second day).
Now I won't play for two days.
My town hall is outside. And between long sessions I ride shields. Anything between (casual) is just a dumb choice. That's a little weird.
Btw... Trying to barch to champs this time around. Most fun ever to 50% maxed bases with lots of stuff on the outside. :rolleyes:
Why don't they just make impossible to get resources? That way they will get more money in your point of view right :rolleyes:Quote:
Originally Posted by eriktran84
Also give the Next fee to the skipped base.
Quote:
Originally Posted by SiLeNtCoYoTe
They could just make the loot bonus conditional. When attacking you only get it after 1-staring an opponent, they could do something similar for the defence bonus, only have it kick in if the attacker drops enough troops ( maybe something like 20 housing space worth, and no bonus if ppl only drop a hero )Quote:
Originally Posted by Beagle21
Nice suggestion, give it if you win and get 10% damage maybe.Quote:
Originally Posted by MelliferaMan
Defending you did nothing? So all that time you spent creating an awesome base design and constantly building/leveling up defenses means you did nothing?Quote:
Originally Posted by RKO
Could have fooled me.
That is the only downside, but can be easily resolved to programming the game so that you do not get the bonus unless the attacker used at least 2 spells/troops.Quote:
Originally Posted by SiLeNtCoYoTe
That way no free loot is generated by 'trophy droppers'.
Absolutely great idea. This would add tons of loot to the economy.
Needs to be added.
Maybe a slight increase from Crystal up, but a big one in the gold ranks.Quote:
Originally Posted by Akali
And for the idea itself, it can only be a good thing for the game.
The fact is, so many players; typically those with good loot are either using whatever tactics available to them to stay online to reduce potential losses &/or throw their town hall outside to also prevent losses.
Giving a potential loot reward for a successful defense would encourage more players to defend properly and not feel the need to 'hide' from the queue as much - as they can actually win loot for once.
Keeping players with good loot in the queue longer is going to help everyone.
I hope that's sarcasm...Quote:
Originally Posted by Genie86
It's a great idea and it seems like a no brainier in my opinion, it would be good to reward those who have a good defense and not just give them some trophies but some actually loot.
You and me both lolQuote:
Originally Posted by daz258
Specially since the trophies have ZERO value.Quote:
Originally Posted by Superraven
Yes great idea we need it
Irony: I just read this thread in the morning and got absolutely pasted in the very manner being described this afternoon. I win a defense in which a good bunch of loot was taken, all my traps were set, and my castle troops extinguished (including a lvl4 drag), only to be plundered ten minutes later by a lesser player. Damn ... And I've been devout in maxing defenses on each level before moving on (currently lvl9). Net result? +3 in trophies. Big whoopie deal ...