CoC now imbalanced OFFENCE vs DEFENCE - POLL

I am not going to mention the poor league bonus or NEXT problems in this thread :p



I am a fully maxxed TH10 (except walls), and have played at various league levels. I have found that no type of attack effectively damages my base, and I feel it would take a very strong, high level and lucky attack to succeed. The same is of course of my attacks on other maxxed TH10 bases (or even near maxxed ones).

CoC has shifted in balance between it favouring offence and defence, over the time I have played it. However, I feel that the game is currently very strongly imbalanced in favour of defence. Perhaps the result of numerous troop nerfs (e.g. witch, hogs. minions) combined with defence level boosts.

I feel the time has come to increase attack troop capability at the highest levels. L6 minions for example are a joke, considering their upgrade cost. Perhaps it is time we have L3 Witch, stronger L6 minions, and a few other new high level troops? Perhaps even L7 barbs, archers, gobs, giants and balloons.

Anyway, the poll is asking the simple question. Is the game currently imbalanced, or not.

Where is the poll? It's not imbalanced. Notice that you can also find complaints that offense is too strong.

Th10 defense is built to stop all cheap farming armies. There isn't a base in this game that will stop a decent gowiwi or a skilled loonion.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Woski

Th10 defense is built to stop all cheap farming armies. There isn't a base in this game that will stop a decent gowiwi or a skilled loonion.

---

Personally, I disagree, but let's see how many vote each way :)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Akali

Personally, I disagree, but let's see how many vote each way :)

---

Look at players in the top 200 with fully maxed bases and fully maxed heros and ask them if it's balanced or not. They'll all tell you offense rules.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Anarchos

Look at players in the top 200 with fully maxed bases and fully maxed heros and ask them if it's balanced or not. They'll all tell you offense rules.

---

That from everything I hear and see is true.

But speaking as a Th9 holder that has always enjoyed attacking up the ladder at every level of them game so far, I'd have to say that Th10 defence is totally OP.

Nerf those disco balls a bit and give us a change of attacking, otherwise puny, Th10 bass please SC.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Akali

I am not going to mention the poor league bonus or NEXT problems in this thread :p



I am a fully maxxed TH10 (except walls), and have played at various league levels. I have found that no type of attack effectively damages my base, and I feel it would take a very strong, high level and lucky attack to succeed. The same is of course of my attacks on other maxxed TH10 bases (or even near maxxed ones).

CoC has shifted in balance between it favouring offence and defence, over the time I have played it. However, I feel that the game is currently very strongly imbalanced in favour of defence. Perhaps the result of numerous troop nerfs (e.g. witch, hogs. minions) combined with defence level boosts.

I feel the time has come to increase attack troop capability at the highest levels. L6 minions for example are a joke, considering their upgrade cost. Perhaps it is time we have L3 Witch, stronger L6 minions, and a few other new high level troops? Perhaps even L7 barbs, archers, gobs, giants and balloons.

Anyway, the poll is asking the simple question. Is the game currently imbalanced, or not.

---

I wonder if you come or stay in champion league, you won't be so confident. The majority player's base are maxed with lv 40 hero. I am balloonion player and winning % is about 99%. I also have max defense but my winning % on defense is about 5%.

So my vote is offense is way overpowered

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by kingleo10

I wonder if you come or stay in champion league, you won't be so confident. The majority player's base are maxed with lv 40 hero. I am balloonion player and winning % is about 99%. I also have max defense but my winning % on defense is about 5%.

So my vote is offense is way overpowered

---

I am genuinely interested in your experience. Balloonion is merely a TH9 army, and I too have used it extensively. It certainly fails every time against my base, so I wonder how it can be so successful for you vs other maxxed bases.

When you say "win", do you only mean getting 1 star at least? I am farming, so my definition of "win" is doubtless rather different. Loot is all that matters to me. My TH is outside, so I can be "defeated" by 1 minion, yet to me that is no defeat. I only count a "win" for my attack if I take at least 200k gold (and taking only 200 of 400 available would be a very slim win in my mind).

Losing a single gold store is however a big loss for me, and losing 2 a defeat in my mind.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Woski

Th10 defense is built to stop all cheap farming armies. There isn't a base in this game that will stop a decent gowiwi or a skilled loonion.

---

This ^^^.

So, offense is very over powered. And trophy system is broke. So...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Akali

I am genuinely interested in your experience. Balloonion is merely a TH9 army, and I too have used it extensively. It certainly fails every time against my base, so I wonder how it can be so successful for you vs other maxxed bases.

When you say "win", do you only mean getting 1 star at least? I am farming, so my definition of "win" is doubtless rather different. Loot is all that matters to me. My TH is outside, so I can be "defeated" by 1 minion, yet to me that is no defeat. I only count a "win" for my attack if I take at least 200k gold (and taking only 200 of 400 available would be a very slim win in my mind).

Losing a single gold store is however a big loss for me, and losing 2 a defeat in my mind.

---

Hmm if i understand correctly - that means your poll on whether offense or defense is imbalanced is actually based on farming (resources lost) and not trophies?

Gowiwi with maxed heroes are actually very strong even for a maxed TH10..

Cheers~