Gameplay Suggestion

Hi! I don't know if this has been suggested already ..but what if we add like an "arena" option to the game?It's a place where two clans (or maybe more) can "sign up" then for a limited number of hours whenever team members from the clans go attack, it would be a random player from the other clans who have signed up.

Just thought of that since, hey it's called "clash of clans" but I don't see any clans really clashing for the top spot. It would be an exciting addition to the game play specially for those in the higher league.

Option 1: The game could be two clans who have agreed to just play against each other. They send invite to a clan fight and if one accepts, the game is on. Accepting a challenge would fall of course on the clans' leaders and their assessment if they are up to the challenge.

Option 2: Game play is divided into rounds. Once a round is filled, random clans who have entered will go against other clans in that round. This option can be for 2 or more clans, depending on how many teams each round can have. Unlike option 1, this will be a random selection on who you will face when you go battle. Challenge round in the arena could be for 10 battles, meaning when a clan is in the arena, they should know that whenever they go battle - they are fighting on behalf of the team and ultimately beating the other clans in the arena.

Possible hurdles -
1. number of people in the clan
2. level pairing
3. duration of a battle between clans
.

Winners can have the right to brag, or you can put a spot for clash winners for the week or season -- and of course gems gems gems!!!I hope you will consider it, let me know what you guys think ... :)

great idea it would make the game much more competitive even among clan friends to prove their power

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Top80

great idea it would make the game much more competitive even among clan friends to prove their power

---

it's really gonna go down the wire on who really is the leader in the clash of clans :)

Would you perhaps be kind enough to use paragraphs? Perhaps some bulletins?

It's rather difficult to read right now.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by HansClashOfClans

Would you perhaps be kind enough to use paragraphs? Perhaps some bulletins?

It's rather difficult to read right now.

---

Hi Hans..I already edited it a few minutes ago..I hope its readable now... let me know if I need to shorten it still. :)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SilverChair

Hi Hans..I already edited it a few minutes ago..I hope its readable now... let me know if I need to shorten it still. :)

---

Thank you! Much better this way.

I have read your post and although I agree with your idea.. I do feel like it need a little more polishing. Also I would like to add the following hurdle:
- Troops versus troops has completely different dynamics...
Although very unlikely, imagine the following the following scenes:
1. Both teams entering just balloons. Dragons and minions could perhaps be solved by giving them the possibility to attack other air troops.
2. Team A has 10 barbs left, team B has 2 barb and 1 healer left. Team A barbs manage to kill the 2 barbs on team B and still have a few barbs left. Team A now has a few barbs, team B only has a healer. Now what? Who wins?
3. What use would hog riders still have?
4. How overpowered would valkyries and dragons suddenly be with their AoE attacks?

In short, the dynamics are not made for troops to attack other troops.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by HansClashOfClans

Thank you! Much better this way.

I have read your post and although I agree with your idea.. I do feel like it need a little more polishing. Also I would like to add the following hurdle:
- Troops versus troops has completely different dynamics...
Although very unlikely, imagine the following the following scenes:
1. Both teams entering just balloons. Dragons and minions could perhaps be solved by giving them the possibility to attack other air troops.
2. Team A has 10 barbs left, team B has 2 barb and 1 healer left. Team A barbs manage to kill the 2 barbs on team B and still have a few barbs left. Team A now has a few barbs, team B only has a healer. Now what? Who wins?
3. What use would hog riders still have?
4. How overpowered would valkyries and dragons suddenly be with their AoE attacks?

In short, the dynamics are not made for troops to attack other troops.

---

Well, I understand your point. However, its not about attacking troop vs troop per se, with the current set up, unless troops are coming from the clan castle (donated troops) -- troops vs troops would be impossible (I think)

Simply put - this set up is basically like simply going on a raid - only thing is you know from what team you are attacking and you are vying to dominate the other clan in terms of raid success.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SilverChair

Well, I understand your point. However, its not about attacking troop vs troop per se, with the current set up, unless troops are coming from the clan castle (donated troops) -- troops vs troops would be impossible (I think)

Simply put - this set up is basically like simply going on a raid - only thing is you know from what team you are attacking and you are vying to dominate the other clan in terms of raid success.

---

You would just be attacking the other persons village?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by HansClashOfClans

You would just be attacking the other persons village?

---

Well, unless they find a way or there's a way it would be troops vs. troops too -- then that's the only way to go.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SilverChair

Well, unless they find a way or there's a way it would be troops vs. troops too -- then that's the only way to go.

---

if it's going to be troops vs troop, then whatever troops a person has in the camp and clan castle will be the ones defending the whole base...purely on defense mode.

I had misread the idea I am in favor of creating an arena where they can collide 2 clan and the choice of the opponent is always random, that I have a TH8 so I can have an TH10 maxed out as a TH6 up in and what create additional trophies for the game clan would be very nice and competitive. if he wins 30 trophies clan clan that loses it loses that much if instead of 50 attacks a clan will win 20 and the other 30 who wins and who loses 5 trophies always 5. then you can always creade handicap ie if a TH10 attacks a TH6 must achieve 3 stars to give point to his clan, but this is to be seen in the meantime I would say to start with the arena changes and updates we always have time to them


if you want to create a new post that contains this idea, it seems to me a thing feasible and not too expensive for you to programmatically

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Top80

I had misread the idea I am in favor of creating an arena where they can collide 2 clan and the choice of the opponent is always random, that I have a TH8 so I can have an TH10 maxed out as a TH6 up in and what create additional trophies for the game clan would be very nice and competitive. if he wins 30 trophies clan clan that loses it loses that much if instead of 50 attacks a clan will win 20 and the other 30 who wins and who loses 5 trophies always 5. then you can always creade handicap ie if a TH10 attacks a TH6 must achieve 3 stars to give point to his clan, but this is to be seen in the meantime I would say to start with the arena changes and updates we always have time to them


if you want to create a new post that contains this idea, it seems to me a thing feasible and not too expensive for you to programmatically

---

you just might have a good idea there on how the whole thing's gonna go down as far as awarding trophies and how to determine the winners of a clash. i hope some of the admins are reading this and give the idea a shot..would be worth it to try for a season and how everything goes. if it falls through..then we go back to the usual programming. :)

- The winners are determined according to the stars captured in the single match type TH8 vs. TH8 if the attacker takes one star at least 1 point to the team attacking it takes 0, 1 point to the defending team, TH10 vs TH6 to take the point must get to win 3 star that is 100% complete
- A player can only participate in one attack and one for defense
- Once all tournament participants who have both attacked defended the winner is determined on the basis of points scored by your clan
- If the result is 50 to 0, 50 trophies will be awarded to the winning clan and subtracted 50 to the loser
- In case of a tie and 0 lost trophies taken
- In the event of a total 30 for team A and team B 20 10 trophies will be assigned to the A team, and so on



I hope some moderator read the post otherwise I create it again I

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Top80

- The winners are determined according to the stars captured in the single match type TH8 vs. TH8 if the attacker takes one star at least 1 point to the team attacking it takes 0, 1 point to the defending team, TH10 vs TH6 to take the point must get to win 3 star that is 100% complete
- A player can only participate in one attack and one for defense
- Once all tournament participants who have both attacked defended the winner is determined on the basis of points scored by your clan
- If the result is 50 to 0, 50 trophies will be awarded to the winning clan and subtracted 50 to the loser
- In case of a tie and 0 lost trophies taken
- In the event of a total 30 for team A and team B 20 10 trophies will be assigned to the A team, and so on



I hope some moderator read the post otherwise I create it again I

---

I do hope someone who has say in the game would take notice this idea... it would be great way to really challenge the clans who are pushing for the top spot. Although raiding random people would be a staple, the ability to go head to head battle against another clan would really push competition further.

so really measure the strength of the clan, but above all the real ability of the players is to stick both and to defend

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Top80

so really measure the strength of the clan, but above all the real ability of the players is to stick both and to defend

---

i definitely agree!!!