Printable View
I think it's a great idea to add a building where you can get spells donated from your clan-mates.
lv 1:
price: 50000
building time: 12 hours
town hall requiered: lv 7
hp 300
1 spell can be donated
lv 2:
price 100000
building time: 1 day
hp 350
th required: lv 9
2 spells
lv 3:
price 300000
bt: 3 days
hp: 400
th requiered:lv 10
2 spells
what do you think:confused:
i would like to hear your opinion
guys please watch it
:confused:can i change something to this?
Nice, idea i would like to have it in the game. And in the clan it will count as 5 donations?
yes thats a nice idea!;)
Eeeh, so a TH6 would have 4 extra spells in total from this, and a TH5 would have 3 spells (trice the amount they have now)? This would ruin the game completely, pushing offense into an even stronger position. It's enough already to get raided by TH10s who have 5 spells (me being a TH9, and I can hold 4 spells). Also, who would like to cook a 45 min spell just to donate it? Or who would want to see a TH5 who all of a sudden pops a rage or freeze when they raid you... Nope. Don't like it. Overpowered to no end.
edit: Also, do NOT bump your threads. It is strictly against the forum rules, and if a mod sees this they might close your thread.
then make the first 5 second 7 en the third 9
and i didnt said look at my thread
Not sure what you mean by that, but nevertheless, even with your proposed changes, this would be far too OP. If SC wanted us to be able to donate spells, I'm pretty sure they would have added the feature already. It's already frustrating enough and difficult enough to try to defend versus 5 spells from a TH10 or getting zapped by anyone with more spells than they already have.Quote:
Originally Posted by fastboy
˙ou're right!
:) We should be able to give higher lvl spells and spells we don't have to other people in your clan:)
I think we should donate spells in our clan castle
I really like this idea, and I was thinking of starting a thread like this myself. Do you mind if I add it to my TH 11 idea thread? Also I want to suggest a name for the building. The Spell Vault, or the Arcane Vault.
+1
That's fineQuote:
Originally Posted by KingDao
You're not the original Poster.....Quote:
Originally Posted by zevster
Ow haha wait then allright, ii ment the nameQuote:
Originally Posted by KingDao
I am it is even great if you post itQuote:
Originally Posted by KingDao
Oh, ok, which do you like, spell vault or arcane vault?Quote:
Originally Posted by zevster
@fastboy, this is OP btw, maybe edit it so that this building is available at TH 8, maaaybe 7 and donate 1 spell, two at TH 9 and 10. Then it's not as OP, and it is more plausible.
ok, thanxQuote:
Originally Posted by fastboy
10 chars...
Arcane vault, great ideas add them!!Quote:
Originally Posted by KingDao
Thank you!
Way to op this would turn off so many lose lvl players as they could be hit by heaps of spells and this would be overkill to bases. Defences can hardly hold up as it is.
And I don't want 4 lighting spells plus a few more smashing my dark elixir storages.
I think this is a great idea and sc should have brought it in ages ago.
This would push offense into a far too strong position. As a TH9, it already can be difficult to defend against the army and 4 spells of a fellow TH9 player, let alone a TH10 with an additional 20 troop space and another spell. 2 more spells? Will be no way to win a defence or not lose all resources. This might look attractive for lower THs (more zippie zappie etc), but it would destroy game balance. Completely.
Dont even think about it.......Its just able to ruin the game,like witches occured in the game 1st time,Everypeeps bases were fludded with skelitons!
yeah..... i don't know. an argument can be made for both the "YES" and "NO". It's a sweet idea, but practically I don't think its really a good thing. Spells cost alot and take a long time to create, and its in a way more valuable, mainly cause you only have one spell factory. Also, its already hard to win against 3-5 spells and a full camp, even if you have a AMAZING layout. I thing it would unbalance game. So my assessment is a NO, sorryQuote:
Originally Posted by fastboy
Think about Hogs with another Heal Spell, Dragons with another rage, & etc. This would be game breaking. Sorry but this shouldn't be added.
No. Unless the spells donated are automatically downgraded to whatever your current spell level is, and fill up spots in your spell factory. Even then, this would be OP, because players on shield could build and donate spells and therefore basically make some players able to chug 4+ spells per match without even boosting spell factory.
If it is the same number of spells at lvl 2 and lvl 3 why even bother upgrading it? It is OP and I don't like the idea. It would give you too many spells. Also, whose clanmates want to spend 30-45 min cooking up a spell just to give it away?
This is not a good idea.
TH 10's can already carry 5 spells, and more would ruin the game I think.