Defensive loot - with a twist

I know defensive loot has been suggested. But I do have a twist, and I apologize if it's been posted before.

Anytime a player loses in an attack, he/she would pay out the equivalent of his/her league bonus to the defender.

ie: If I am a Crystal III player, when I lose an attack (no stars), I would pay the defender 21K elixir 21K gold and 50 DE.

If you steal far more than the league bonus, you still keep the remainder minus the payout to the defender. So someone who is farming collectors and doesn't care about 1-starring a base would have to be cognizant of how much they are pulling in.

Part of my thought process is, if you put up a good defense, you still carry the risk of losing resources in an attack - EVEN if they do not 1-star your base. I think the risk should be placed on the attacker to lose resources as well.

Hello,

Has been suggested before, to prevent this from happening, please read the stickies for a list of ruled out and or suggested ideas, If it's not there, please search it up, With the Search Bar or advanced search,


Thanks!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by matthewe

Hello,

Has been suggested before, to prevent this from happening, please read the stickies for a list of ruled out and or suggested ideas, If it's not there, please search it up, With the Search Bar or advanced search,


Thanks!

---

Well, this isn't really helpful at all. I did all of this. That's why my original post indicates that I know stuff like this has been proposed, but I don't see any posts that suggest this particular idea (tying in the an attacker having to pay out for a loss).

It adds strategy to tie in a resource loss on the part of an attacker to a winning defender.

Perhaps you could provide a link for me as to where I can find this EXACT idea? I would greatly appreciate it.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by cdresko

Well, this isn't really helpful at all. I did all of this. That's why my original post indicates that I know stuff like this has been proposed, but I don't see any posts that suggest this particular idea (tying in the an attacker having to pay out for a loss).

It adds strategy to tie in a resource loss on the part of an attacker to a winning defender.

Perhaps you could provide a link for me as to where I can find this EXACT idea? I would greatly appreciate it.

---

It can be frustrating when you post a lot , and all you get is what I posted, But some requests take 20 Minutes to make, and they don't get a response, I am just asking you to read the stickies to prevent more ruled out or suggested ideas getting posted. It also in a way can be abused.



As high players attack other high players from their clan (when they leave) to get a free shield, They nonly 40% them, so they get cups and they will get MORE LOOT. Sc aim is to get money, Only high players spend tons of money which keep the game alive, Their money goes to more AWESOME games SC make, and new features for them to make and money to pay bills.



EDIT: Just click on "Ruled out ideas" from my signature, and you can get a list of ideas, suggested and ruled out, (Two sections)

Link:http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...attacker+loses

Use Guide to searching the forums, Click on it located from my sig below, This will help you search up Threads,


I used "Advanced Searching" And I typed, "Gain loot if attacker loses" Came up with one thread, but just shows.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by matthewe

It can be frustrating when you post a lot , and all you get is what I posted, But some requests take 20 Minutes to make, and they don't get a response, I am just asking you to read the stickies to prevent more ruled out or suggested ideas getting posted. It also in a way can be abused.



As high players attack other high players from their clan (when they leave) to get a free shield, They nonly 40% them, so they get cups and they will get MORE LOOT. Sc aim is to get money, Only high players spend tons of money which keep the game alive, Their money goes to more AWESOME games SC make, and new features for them to make and money to pay bills.



EDIT: Just click on "Ruled out ideas" from my signature, and you can get a list of ideas, suggested and ruled out, (Two sections)

Link:http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...attacker+loses

Use Guide to searching the forums, Click on it located from my sig below, This will help you search up Threads,


I used "Advanced Searching" And I typed, "Gain loot if attacker loses" Came up with one thread, but just shows.

---

Thank you for this reply. I searched, just didn't use the correct terms to find this specifically. I read all the forum stickies, just wasn't aware that this particular aspect was out there.