Probably because that's where your gold storage is.Quote:
Originally Posted by Kjeldinator
Printable View
Probably because that's where your gold storage is.Quote:
Originally Posted by Kjeldinator
Thanks for showing the weaknesses to my base :) without it i cant really spot there was the X junctionQuote:
Originally Posted by R3taliate
What's your clan name and I'll check it out for youQuote:
Originally Posted by Fr3aK
Clan: adult clash 21+Quote:
Originally Posted by R3taliate
name : slayer 117
Hello this is my cousins base, please rate/tip it :D
http://i62.tinypic.com/iwokf5.jpg
Any hints/tips what to do next?
But there are also storages where it is nowQuote:
Originally Posted by halfbreed
http://i57.tinypic.com/x7tat.jpg
I'm a newish th7, having fun trying out a few interesting base ideas. This one is mostly for farming. The CC isn't centralized, but at least a couple of camps/barracks delay the release. Each mortar covers its neighbor, and the "50-yard line" is meant to be very tough to cross.
So far it's stood up well, but it hasn't really seen a very strong attack yet. What do you guys think?
That's a great base! 9/10Quote:
Originally Posted by Johno
IMO, bases like this usually don't work that well. I could just barch my way to the storages. I would put more buildings inside the walls.Quote:
Originally Posted by Skysaw
The storages are a bit bunchedQuote:
Originally Posted by Shazain
the mortars aren't even
the clan castle isn't centered
theres an x junction
the t junctions are exposed at the bottom
its a hybrid base, but so many buildings are easy to get
6/10
I cannot take screenshot with my app. if anyone would mind taking a shot of mine and posting it here (that's ok, i give you permission... in fact i'm more requesting lol)
that would be cool to have some advice.
Thx!
IGN : Gunkar
Clan : Bonnie & Clyde (a black and white flag (like triangular/circled one)) we have about ~12k trophy if i'm right around 45-50 clanmates
thx everyone and anyone who does it (post screen shot)
What's wrong with a x junction? :)Quote:
Originally Posted by nathannathan1232
Also 'the mortors aren't even _____?'
Yeah, but it's defending one elixir storage. If you move it to where nathan was talking about it's defending a gold and an elixir storage. Or put another way, where it is now also has an AT helping defend. The new spot has no AT to help defend. You basically are spreading your defenses out better.Quote:
Originally Posted by Kjeldinator
If the corner piece is destroyed in an X junction, attacking troops gain access to 3 new compartments. If the corner piece of a T junction is destroyed, attacking troops only gain access to 2 new compartments.Quote:
Originally Posted by Shazain
He means that the mortars are all up towards the top. You want even coverage with your mortars, which means placing them around the base in a more or less equilateral triangle shape.
Also, I'm not a huge fan of the spring trap placements. In general you want them where troops will likely path. When you put them up against walls like that, it's more random as to whether they will be triggered or not. A good strategy is to place them between defenses so giants or hogs will likely trigger them. Alternatively, if you were targeting gobs you would want them between two resource buildings.
IGN: Injustice
Clan: Sneaky Santa
I would like to see feedback and tips for my base, I would like to see cons and pros, thanks.
I took your advice and stopped upgrading my town hall and made a new base. This is town hall level 7 hybrid defense\farming. I noticed the X junction I made but I am unsure what to do as of it.
http://i.imgur.com/zQ3Eu1H.jpg
If four walls are connected (x-junction), then one broken wall will open up all four compartments.Quote:
Originally Posted by Shazain
I just meant that the mortars aren't evenly spread.
This basically sums it up. :)Quote:
Originally Posted by halfbreed
Im not exactly sure what you could do. It's a decent base, but the loot is a bit bunched.Quote:
Originally Posted by Aweshocked
Most of it looks good though.
http://i57.tinypic.com/kdl3zd.png
First time making a base. Any inputs are appreciated. Good or bad. Thank you for your time :)
The top gold storages are bunched.Quote:
Originally Posted by Retin
The splash isn't that even.
the bottom left giant bombs should be placed better.
overall 7.5/10
Any suggestions on the improvement part? Thank you for the reply also!:)
I would switch the top gold with the top-left mortar.Quote:
Originally Posted by Retin
pls review this!Quote:
Originally Posted by PickleFace
Is this chief pat's design?Quote:
Originally Posted by PickleFace
There are a lot of x junctions, and un-proper t junctions
The ADs are exposed
I wouldnt put the DE in between mortars
overall 6.5/10
http://i60.tinypic.com/io3tbr.png
"The rocket" Inputs/weaknesses/major flaws? Inspired by The Tempest :)
If a giant destroys an AT at the top, I don't think they will go onto the middle cannon at the top.Quote:
Originally Posted by Retin
the mortars are bunched
I like the trap placement, although the air traps should be placed better
overall 7.5/10
Heres mine as of yesterday. Really want some feedback since i've lost the past 3-4 raids. :X
http://i209.photobucket.com/albums/b...5616581611.png
Do you want mainly saving your trophies or your resources?Quote:
Originally Posted by Exmix
The clan castle isn't centralized, it is very easy to lure.
and there are mostly X-junction, it is very easy to reach the core. In my opinion you should make a new base or just copy a TH 7 base. If you decide to design a new base, look for some good TH 7 base to inspire you.
I think it's mostly the levels of your defenses and walls.Quote:
Originally Posted by Exmix
the clan castle isn't centralized
there are a lot of x junctions
it looks really random
overall 6.5/10
Hows this? It's my own circleish base.
http://i58.tinypic.com/28cghgn.jpg
Alright. I'll try to get a new layout and figure something out. As of right now my resources are more important than trophies. So if you guys have any suggestions please throw them my way.
Also I like your circular-ish layout Nathan.
Now mine, but id love some feedback (im not th9 but I did design it)
http://i.imgur.com/W75p1QX.jpg
The junctions aren't that goodQuote:
Originally Posted by Kjeldinator
i would switch the ADs and WTs
overall 7/10
Real quick, since in my defence replays, i've never seen my Barbarian King attack, does it really matter where I put him and ifh e's protected and such?
He's not that good on defense. I would just have him sleep.Quote:
Originally Posted by Exmix
Works for me, thanks. In the process of trying to re-organize my base now. I see the problem with my last layout so just trying to fine a better one. I can't seem to find a place for my 3rd Mortar and one more cannon.Quote:
Originally Posted by nathannathan1232
Alright how about this one?
http://i209.photobucket.com/albums/b...ngel/Maybe.jpg
The cannons are all in groups (bunched up)Quote:
Originally Posted by Exmix
i would alternate the storages so the gold are on opposite corners
Definantly move the ADs in where some collectors are
Overall 7/10
Alright will do. Works for me, thanks. :D
Not currently a th 8, but thought id test my building skills and make a base.
This is TH 8 farming, gold and dark.
If its bad, im not the best designer thanks
Attachment 30897
didnt notice i had 1 too many buildings inside of first layer haha
pertend i put one on the outside and sectioned off the corner building
It looks great! The junctions connecting the gold/WT compartments aren't proper, but other than that, 8.5/10.Quote:
Originally Posted by sjfasty
Any thoughts or improvements? Can be farming or trophy base.
Farming
http://i57.tinypic.com/6rrle1.jpg
Trophy
http://i58.tinypic.com/t84vtz.jpg
-never switch the lab with the town hall. Put the clan castle where the town hall is, and move a gold storage in.Quote:
Originally Posted by gibbylovesyou
its a great base. 8.5/10
Thanks for the suggestion! I updated my recent postQuote:
Originally Posted by nathannathan1232
Here is my latest TH7 base.. Almost done upgrading splash atm. Seem to be attacked most from the bottom by hogs based armies... Which i stand no chance against
http://i1343.photobucket.com/albums/...ps3d105d54.png
This is my TH6 base. I'm finishing off my 2nd mortar as you can see, and then going to upgrade my Wizard Towers, then my Barracks and a few other things before going to TH7. Just wondering if there's any improvements to be made. :rolleyes:
http://i909.photobucket.com/albums/a...psnni0l75t.png
Quote:
Originally Posted by DjScRiBbLe
You want to protect your elixir, right?
The Clancastle isn't centralised.
What I also don't like are the junctions and the northern part. If you attack from the north you have only to break through 2 walls to reach the core with the elixir storages (wall breakers doesn't attack "empty" compartments).
If you always get 3-starred drop trophies. With your defence levels it is difficult to farm in gold 2.
Thanks, a few notes.Quote:
Originally Posted by Dark9Lu
I rarely have anything in clan castle so its waisting space in the center. I have tried centered and not with little difference. I based the current layout of another base. I will most likely place TH outside and move cc back into the base somewhere. Funny thing is even though the top looks weaker and the preferred place to attack every attack starts at the bottom where once in 90% of the giants get hit by the spring traps moving from defense to defense. I have only been 3 starred and 2 starred once by hog armies. otherwise I'm not getting 3 starred at all...
I will most likely change bases soon anyway...
http://i58.tinypic.com/2e207j8.png
Any pointers? I'm just about to upgrade my wizard tower in this screenshot. Next is walls.
The clan castle isn't centralizedQuote:
Originally Posted by DjScRiBbLe
The town hall won't be sniped often
the king isn't centralized. He might just as well be switched with a collector
It's a bit open, but I think that's how you want it
overall 6.5/10
after you fix these things, maybe a 7.5/10
PS. IMO, with the way you have it set up, I think having both elixirs in the middle is ok.
The junctions are exposed on the sides, but it's hard not to do that at town hall 6Quote:
Originally Posted by OneWhoKnocks
i would switch a gold storage with an elixir storage, so they're alternating, and even
The clan castle isn't centralized, but that's ok at town hall 6-
the spring traps are bunched. I would move a few
Overall it's great! 8.5/10
This looks like the pokeball base.Quote:
Originally Posted by ShawnW
i wouldn't have the giant bombs by the town hall. You basically waste 25K gold every time you get sniped, so you might as well have your storages destroyed.
I wouldn't line up the mines and collectors
overall 8.5/10
Thanks! I just alternated the storages. As far as the CC, I often use troops whilst attacking and find my castle empty most of the time so it felt like a priority to have my air defence in the middle to put off Healer Giant strategies. I'll look for where I can move the traps. :)Quote:
Originally Posted by nathannathan1232
Thanks, Ive been playing around with things over the last week and just got my king last night.Quote:
Originally Posted by nathannathan1232
TBH, TH will most likely go back outside the base as mentioned before 99.9999% of attack come from bottom. Also why keep an empty CC in the middle? Same with a LV1 king? Thanks
Its hard not to want to use a recognized TH7 base but they have all been so used and the weaknesses are exploited. Might try making from scratch again tonight.
What's the alternative for the mines and collectors?Quote:
Originally Posted by nathannathan1232
How about this
http://i1343.photobucket.com/albums/...pshrubpvxn.png
I like the overall shape of your base! Perhaps spread out the traps a lot more, it is too overpowered in that bottom area. Also, I would switch your BK and DE storage with your two gold storages on the outside, for more protection, and more important protection to be honest. Great job with your splash coverage, looking good! 8.5/10Quote:
Originally Posted by DjScRiBbLe
The gold is a bit exposed.Quote:
Originally Posted by DjScRiBbLe
i would try to get rid of the x junctions
7/10
I agree with most of that.Quote:
Originally Posted by Jacksonian
Just mix them in with the barracks, spell factory, ect.Quote:
Originally Posted by ShawnW
Thanks guys, The point was to use the emptier of the storages as meat shield with the high hp... But i moved a few things so how about now? I don't see how i can remove anymore X junctions... Could you elaborate..
http://i1343.photobucket.com/albums/...ps19c9dbc0.png
http://i.imgur.com/nFi90wU.png
I just make bases for fun, I don't really change mine as I'm currently using the Pokeball base. Just wanted to see how my base-making skills are.
Attachment 30989
How's my base looking?
Btw, this is my first time posting on the forums, so I still don't know how to use all of this well.
I feel like this is the best version so far?
http://i1343.photobucket.com/albums/...psbeesk32f.png
The traps are betterQuote:
Originally Posted by DjScRiBbLe
there are still some x junctions
overall its a bit better i think
I would alternate the storages (switch one gold with one elixir)Quote:
Originally Posted by Ryp
the mortars are exposed
the ADs are exposed
some t junctions are exposed
overall 6.5/10
Welcome to the forums!Quote:
Originally Posted by inKredibuL
There are a few x junctions
Overall the walls aren't placed that well
the clan castle isn't centered
overall 6.5/10
There are still x junctionsQuote:
Originally Posted by DjScRiBbLe
i would switch the elixir with the WTs
overall 7.5/10
good call on the elixir and wt, didn't even see that possibility. Doesn't every base have X junctions? I find it hard to eliminate them...
Just keep trying, and I bet you could eliminate the x junctions. :)Quote:
Originally Posted by DjScRiBbLe
Will do... so far one TH sniper since conception..
Edit. So after review my main x junctions were in the core correct? So I made an alteration. I hope its better the have wt in the larger pocket while keeping ad in a closed pocket making it harder for giants ect.. Also I dislike the uneven amount of cannons which is throwing me off. Should I keep then how I had, ie grouped top and bottom or place 1 by each storage like this?
http://i1343.photobucket.com/albums/...psnjxmjeyd.png
Or This? These are the last 2 version and I'm unsure which to use? I prefer the last because of being even..
http://i1343.photobucket.com/albums/...psmrgrusvn.png
My sole purpose with this base was to save my dark elixir i worked so hard to build up. I am trying to max defenses at th8 and made a big mistake in building up too much de with still weeks of tesla upgrades to go. Any advice on a base with a sole purpose of saving de from those th9 aq bk attacks?
i made the cc and barb king lurable from the bottom in hopes of most attacks starting from there and then used most my traps and bombs down there. Works sometimes....other times not so much
thanks
Those are definantly better! I would use the second one, but make a few minor tweaks...Quote:
Originally Posted by DjScRiBbLe
I'm not quite sure how to explain this, but I will try my best. First, go into edit mode and remove the mortars, WTs and ADs. Next, place two mortars where the ADs were, and the third mortar where the current mortar is (top right). Next, put the WTs where the two mortars used to be, and the ADs will go where the WTs used to be.
it looks great- 8.5/10
Moving the town hall to the corner would definantly helpQuote:
Originally Posted by Deke
Town hall 8 bases with those empty 1-block wide compartments usually don't work well unless it goes all the way around
overall 8/10
Looks very similar to junliangs Pokeball baseQuote:
Originally Posted by nathannathan1232
Thanks for the feedback. I appreciate it. Your right about those walls not working most of the time. I think I should be able to do better with the defensive units I have.Quote:
Originally Posted by nathannathan1232
Yes, it does, although slightly different.Quote:
Originally Posted by R3taliate
Thanks. Please note that i'm still catching my new defenses up to th7 when looking at my defense logs :)
http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...esign-UPDATING
First, great job on your base, very advanced for a lvl 86 was it? Anyhow, you deserve it, and the base looks pretty good.Quote:
Originally Posted by Deke
I would protect the DE storage a bit more by possibly making a more intricate moat on the top side of the base, not having an effect on influencing attacks either, so that can put them in a gutter.
Also, possibly focus more on your storage protection? Start upping your TH once your teslas finish, and once it gets inside 4 days, make sure you got 6 mil gold and 40k de...for the AQ. Will help a lot to instantly start both your xbows and aq....that's what I did.
8/10 on the base. It could use some tweaks, but looks well to work with.
Pretty sure I understand. Thoughts on switching the top right motor with bk to cover the lower region better?Quote:
Originally Posted by nathannathan1232
http://i1343.photobucket.com/albums/...psblzlyhfe.png
lol very true, that DOES look like the pokeball. Spread out your teslas some more though, otherwise, great job! Could you protect the DE storage any better? Put it behind the gold storage possibly? No idea.Quote:
Originally Posted by DjScRiBbLe
That's exactly what I meant. :)Quote:
Originally Posted by DjScRiBbLe
usually people attack from the bottom, so it's best to have better coverage there, although the mortar is long ranged, so I would leave it at the top, so it doesn't get destroyed early on.
overall 9/10
Rodger that. Will try it out after shield runs out. So far just one Th snipe again. Around 90 lv5 or 6 archers and they didn't do more than 8/9% from bottom.
Thanks. I do see similarity's to pokeball after readings juns thread. However I just built from scratch and am super ocd about symmetry so naturally I think it evolved to look like pokeball :) I gueaa depending on how full storage is I can always swap de with gold based off that. Only option for teslas is to place one up top mirror to the one on bottom. Again I have to have symmetry lol. Thanks m8Quote:
Originally Posted by Jacksonian
lol yes, I love symmetrical designs too. Soo prettyyyy;)Quote:
Originally Posted by DjScRiBbLe
Anyhow, good ideas on storage capacities depending on whether you will switch or not. Yes, top mirror it. That would add more coverage as well.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ruki
You should switch the air defense with a middle cannon. And if you want, i wood reccomend that u put ur wizard tower where the mortar is. That would make ur storages really nicely protected. put the mortar either where the other midddle cannon is. all my opinion, hope u have a good time with ur base.
i rate that 8/10
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jacksonian
Thanks for for the kind words Jacksonian. Im really excited to move up to th9 and have the de to start the aq right away. Same with gold for x bows. Need to stop the bleeding soon! :). I think i will try and isolate the de in its own little box safe from wizards and archers. When the aq comes I'll just hand over the de and ask for a charitable donation receipt.
I would appreciate any help designing or being pointed in the direction of a base that is made solely for protecting de at the th8 level. I posted my base earlier but i am sure we can come up with something much better than that. The purpose of this base is for the time while the town is upgrading and i will be sitting on substantial dark, for the archer queen, to have at my disposal when the town hall is done. I know nothing is perfect and th9s with good troops and plans will always have a shot at it. But i want to at least try. Thanks for any input.
Here are a few similar ideas. After I made it I realized it looked similar to junliang's battleship. These aren't perfect. I'm not sure how they will do, but I thought they might help.Quote:
Originally Posted by Deke
http://i58.tinypic.com/2w2l9xk.jpghttp://i57.tinypic.com/v3ix48.jpg
[QUOTE=nathannathan1232;1570347]Here are a few similar ideas. After I made it I realized it looked similar to junliang's battleship. These aren't perfect. I'm not sure how they will do, but I thought they might help.
http://i58.tinypic.com/2w2l9xk.jpghttp://i57.tinypic.com/v3ix48.jpg[/QUOTE
thanks very much. I do like the look of these bases. The bottom one might suit me a little better since i have all three teslas down for the next 26 days and need something to slow people down going after that gold with archers. I think ill give this a shot. Thanks again
[QUOTE=Deke;1570413]Cool. Tell me how it works for you. :)Quote:
Originally Posted by nathannathan1232
I made this base for my mom a while ago. How is it? I keep trying to tell here to move the traps away from the town hall, but she won't listen. :p
http://i59.tinypic.com/2a7ebzm.jpg
Your mom clashes?! Lol. Anyways, I see that you are trying to funnel at the north and south cannons, which is always a good idea. But if someone had giants, WBs, and gobs, they could use the giants for destractions and use the WBs to crack open that mini vault, more giants and then gob it up and hit 2 storages, one of each main resource (4 if they somehow get the north storages; 2 of each main resource).Quote:
Originally Posted by nathannathan1232
Can you ask your mom to adopt me?Quote:
Originally Posted by nathannathan1232
Lol. :pQuote:
Originally Posted by Ryp
1010101010
I find it funny how your mum is better than youQuote:
Originally Posted by nathannathan1232
http://imgur.com/dB1IAPL
First time posting an image... I hope I did that right. Feedback on my base please!
She plays more. I do the forums more.Quote:
Originally Posted by R3taliate
EDIT- it goes to show how good we forumers would be if it weren't for the forums. :P
It doesn't work. Upload it to tinypic.comQuote:
Originally Posted by 3lur
[IMG]<a href="http://tinypic.com?ref=1z34bj9" target="_blank"><img src="http://i57.tinypic.com/1z34bj9.jpg" border="0" alt="Image and video hosting by TinyPic"></a>[/IMG]
Alright... Second try.
http://i57.tinypic.com/1z34bj9.jpg I copied the wrong one last time.
It is working nowQuote:
Originally Posted by 3lur
i can see at least 7 x junctions, thesea re all major problems in your base
There are x junctionsQuote:
Originally Posted by 3lur
the clan castle isn't centered
why are you protecting the town hall a little bit? I would move it.
overall 6.5/10
http://i59.tinypic.com/2d7bvr7.jpg Is this any better? I centered the CC more.
It's a bit better, although there are still x junctionsQuote:
Originally Posted by 3lur
Should I just use a Pokeball or one ring?
How can I make and keep few million in elixir and dark. C cuz I am battling. But seems even at one. Hund. K I'm not progressing the way I had hoped. I use barbs. And giants only. With few wall breakers. And am mostly successful. But. My recources. Seem to continue to dwindle..... I am. BABY FACE.... OF CALICHE CLAN. black and white. If you would like to look. See. And help me with some advice
Check out my newest base and leave a reply to let me know what you think
http://forum.supercell.net/showthread.php/219105-TH9-Trophy-Base-The-Defier-%28Anti-Hog%29
I would use one ring, because it's less common.Quote:
Originally Posted by 3lur
I can't really understand that. Could you use better grammer? What town hall are you?Quote:
Originally Posted by qcolombiano02