Cool Defensive Loot Idea

Mission: To ensure game morale is not sacrificed by producing updates that provide something to everyone.

Objective: Confront the issue of defensive strategy, defensive loot, and sustainability resources for All players.

End state: By providing players with another building (or TH perhaps) that holds loot obtained from defensive victories that is similar to resource collectors, one would reinforce player satisfaction and reinforce and complete Mission Objective.

To start off,

I would presume to think that most clashers put a lot of time into their defenses.

I would also presume to think that most clashers would enjoy the idea of having a small incentive to maintaining these defenses, especially one's required to "recharge" such as the xbow.

Defensive loot has been talked about quite prolifically throughout the forums. However, i haven't seen one solution explained such as this thread will attempt to do.

I propose that Game makers add a building (or make THs a click-able resource collector) that holds loot acquired through defensive victory. Obtaining one successful victory could add (yet to be determined amount) these said resources into said collector. The more successful defensive victories, the more the loot is multiplied after each successful attack. T

Here is where it gets interesting and fun.
Players that choose NOT to collect these resources can keep having this loot compounded with each successful defense. (possibly up to 10x?) BUT, With the destruction of this building comes the loss of a portion (say half?) of the defensive loot obtained.

So your question may be "Well what will keep higher level players from dropping trophies and trolling lower level players?


Well the solution is simple...and actually reinforces higher level players to maintain normal trophy level progression. This proposed action would actually reinforce the stability of the game.

1. Defensive loot will be increased a certain amount at each TH level.

2. Defensive loot cannot be looted by Town Halls higher than your own.

This encourages lower level players by: Creating an incentive for mature players to go up to the next TH level, pay attention to defensive strategy, find and maintain presence in clans, encourages game attentiveness, and discourages premature growth in TH levels in addition to receiving an additional loot bonus when attacking.

On the flip side for the potential of more loot, higher level players have more of an incentive to stay around their proper trophy ranges, provides something that the game desperately requires for those who are burnt out or want something game changing, and maintains game attentiveness in addition to receiving an additional loot bonus when attacking. (especially for expensive walls)

POSSIBLE SOLUTION?

This may be too high or low but its worth considering...I thinks something like

1000>2000>4000>8000 @ TH1,2,3,4, and 5
2000>4000>8000>16000 @ TH 6
4000>8000>16000>32000>64000 @ TH 7
8000>16000>32000>64000>128000 @ TH 8
16000>32000>64000>128000>236000 @TH 9
32000>64000>128000>236000>472000 @ TH 10

A "successful defense" at this point i think would be not letting your town hall get destroyed. If it is destroyed then your multiplier starts over and you lose half of your defensive loot. You have to collect it before the multiplier starts over.

then what is to stop higher town halls from dropping trophies and putting their town hall outside of their wall to get the loot bonus?

Good point, however, if they want a higher loot bonus (from defensive loot) then they would want to stay around their trophy range, Because attacking a TH below their own (10 vs 8 or 9) would not give them access to other players defensive loot. As you can see from above half of 236,000 would be an extra 115,000 in gold and elixir and at 5 multipliers they would receive an extra 236000 if they destroyed another player at TH 10!


Can you elaborate how this would discourage premature town hall upgrades? I would think that it would actually encourage it.


Players would want to think twice about becoming premmies as any player at their TH level could steal half their defensive loot. Imagine a TH 7 player destroying a TH10 premmie and receiving 115,000 in gold and elixir @ 4 multipliers and at 5 multipliers they would receive 236000 in ADDition to normal base loot!?


Thanks for the questions, they were really good! I think Supercell should at least consider Something like this in regards to defensive loot as this seems to me to be a possible solid update! What do you all think and how about some possible numbers for different defensive TH loot? (as i am not good with statistics)

Great ideas durham.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Parker177

Great ideas durham.

---

Thanks for reading! I really hope this gets some attention.

This is actually a great Idea but itll make me have to protect my th now :(

I like this idea :)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Durham2886

Mission: To ensure game morale is not sacrificed by producing updates that provide something to everyone.

Objective: Confront the issue of defensive strategy, defensive loot, and sustainability resources for All players.

End state: By providing players with another building (or TH perhaps) that holds loot obtained from defensive victories that is similar to resource collectors, one would reinforce player satisfaction and reinforce and complete Mission Objective.

To start off,

I would presume to think that most clashers put a lot of time into their defenses.

I would also presume to think that most clashers would enjoy the idea of having a small incentive to maintaining these defenses, especially one's required to "recharge" such as the xbow.

Defensive loot has been talked about quite prolifically throughout the forums. However, i haven't seen one solution explained such as this thread will attempt to do.

I propose that Game makers add a building (or make THs a click-able resource collector) that holds loot acquired through defensive victory. Obtaining one successful victory could add (yet to be determined amount) these said resources into said collector. The more successful defensive victories, the more the loot is multiplied after each successful attack. T

Here is where it gets interesting and fun.
Players that choose NOT to collect these resources can keep having this loot compounded with each successful defense. (possibly up to 10x?) BUT, With the destruction of this building comes the loss of a portion (say half?) of the defensive loot obtained.

So your question may be "Well what will keep higher level players from dropping trophies and trolling lower level players?


Well the solution is simple...and actually reinforces higher level players to maintain normal trophy level progression. This proposed action would actually reinforce the stability of the game.

1. Defensive loot will be increased a certain amount at each TH level.

2. Defensive loot cannot be looted by Town Halls higher than your own.

This encourages lower level players by: Creating an incentive for mature players to go up to the next TH level, pay attention to defensive strategy, find and maintain presence in clans, encourages game attentiveness, and discourages premature growth in TH levels in addition to receiving an additional loot bonus when attacking.

On the flip side for the potential of more loot, higher level players have more of an incentive to stay around their proper trophy ranges, provides something that the game desperately requires for those who are burnt out or want something game changing, and maintains game attentiveness in addition to receiving an additional loot bonus when attacking. (especially for expensive walls)


What do you all think and how about some possible numbers for different defensive TH loot? (as i am not good with statistics)

---

So you are suggesting getting loot from defending?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by fiskee55

So you are suggesting getting loot from defending?

---

Yes, And you can choose to gather it from your TH (or possibly a separate building) or leave it in and let it multiply with each successful defend!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Durham2886

Yes, And you can choose to gather it from your TH (or possibly a separate building) or leave it in and let it multiply with each successful defend!

---

That would a cool idea!

I am all for this. Anything to make defense actually mean something and to stop so many TH just being out for the free shields. I'd support this easily!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Durham2886

Yes, And you can choose to gather it from your TH (or possibly a separate building) or leave it in and let it multiply with each successful defend!

---

So it increases exponentially or something?
Or why wouldn't I just collect it and spend it.

Like most "make TH mean something" threads, it'd have to be a MASSIVE amount of loot before I could care less about this. Compared to farming a million gold each evening, how is this ever going to compare?