Update FEEDBACK

Hi Marika,

thanks to you and the supercell team for staying tuned to us and for being interested in our feedbacks.

I'm one of Germany's top fifty player since more than 11 months with a fully maxed out base, have even spent some time in world's top 200 for some time an i' d like to give you my personal feedback of this last update regarding only changes to the game over 3500 trophies.

After changing the abilities of the heroes with this last update winning with a fully maxed out army has become really easy. If you are not drunk, with gowiwi and the superheroes plus the l5 freeze spell, maybe some rage, it has become impossible to loose an attack against every fully maxed out fortress. If you don't believe it, take a look at the statistics of Germany's top 50 players of the last days since the update. You will soon notice that you will not be able to count up to 10 won defences there since the update. Even my defence, which over the last months has been really succesfull, has nearly any chance against this overpowered superheroes any more.

So my main point is: With this update, balance at high level over 3500 is gone, defence is dead, and winning every attack has become normality.

I don't think this was a good and necessary change at high level play, maybe below.

thanks for reading this

best regards

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by WilliamWallace

I think so, I was very disappointed with this update. 100k DE for an increase of 4 damage and 6 hit points? What are we doing, I'm totally lost on the logic. 40k for lvl 5 then 100k for lvl 6???? I'm in Noooo hurry for the lvl6 minion, partially because I'm still grinding out 100k/100k raids (after 20-40 next buttons). How i miss the days of the "boring" 200k raids. Still lol'ing about that phrase. Give me back the 200k raids, at least it wasn't so brutally boring. The boost was supposed to be a good thing?????? ♥♥♥♥, cut the cost and results by half and call that an improvement? Again, so lost with the logic.

I absolutely love the concept of this game, the art and the premise are phenomenal, however, I am SOOO turned off by the structure & what seems a never ending voracious greed. The updates seem a continuous kick in the face, truly seems you have lost your vision for your app or it has blown up beyond your expectations & you can't handle the success.

I for one am finding it harder and harder to stay active or interested. I've searched from 1000 cups to 2700 & the only 300k raids I've seen are maxed out TH9's or 10's which need a 200k army to get 50%. I wish I could find the good raids I hear rumored from some (most seem to have the same "next button blues" as I). I want so badly for this game to right itself & achieve its potential. So I've promoted my co-leader & have noticed zero improvement or excitement from this upgrade. The new hero abilities are nice, not a lot to get excited about for me. Maybe when I push again, I will enjoy these new abilities more, for now it's fairly lackluster. I truly hope there are better days to come, I hope the $$ and time I've put in to this game provide some better entertainment than this! Scale of 1-10, I rate this update a 4! Had to take away points for the ridiculous boost setting (costs me 50 - 60 gems every 2 hours, no thank you!) give points for the new hero abilities and the increase in gems from obstacles. Everything else is a negative or has zero value to me. I think you need to reevaluate the loot system, greatly reduce the barracks boost or decrease training times. Make it easier for us to play longer & stop making me feel like all your doing is trying to bleed me dry!
I offer my opinion with all good intentions, I love this game and hope to offer productive feedback. I can't help the negative overtones as my disappointment currently shadows my enjoyment. Come on SC, help me play your game, I'm doing everything I can from my side, how about a little more love from your side!

Hope my input resonates & helps add some color to the overall feedback. All good intentions! Clash on!!

---

I think this sums up pretty well how many of us are feeling, and totally agrea.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by WilliamWallace

I think so, I was very disappointed with this update. 100k DE for an increase of 4 damage and 6 hit points? What are we doing, I'm totally lost on the logic. 40k for lvl 5 then 100k for lvl 6???? I'm in Noooo hurry for the lvl6 minion, partially because I'm still grinding out 100k/100k raids (after 20-40 next buttons). How i miss the days of the "boring" 200k raids. Still lol'ing about that phrase. Give me back the 200k raids, at least it wasn't so brutally boring. The boost was supposed to be a good thing?????? ♥♥♥♥, cut the cost and results by half and call that an improvement? Again, so lost with the logic.

I absolutely love the concept of this game, the art and the premise are phenomenal, however, I am SOOO turned off by the structure & what seems a never ending voracious greed. The updates seem a continuous kick in the face, truly seems you have lost your vision for your app or it has blown up beyond your expectations & you can't handle the success.

I for one am finding it harder and harder to stay active or interested. I've searched from 1000 cups to 2700 & the only 300k raids I've seen are maxed out TH9's or 10's which need a 200k army to get 50%. I wish I could find the good raids I hear rumored from some (most seem to have the same "next button blues" as I). I want so badly for this game to right itself & achieve its potential. So I've promoted my co-leader & have noticed zero improvement or excitement from this upgrade. The new hero abilities are nice, not a lot to get excited about for me. Maybe when I push again, I will enjoy these new abilities more, for now it's fairly lackluster. I truly hope there are better days to come, I hope the $$ and time I've put in to this game provide some better entertainment than this! Scale of 1-10, I rate this update a 4! Had to take away points for the ridiculous boost setting (costs me 50 - 60 gems every 2 hours, no thank you!) give points for the new hero abilities and the increase in gems from obstacles. Everything else is a negative or has zero value to me. I think you need to reevaluate the loot system, greatly reduce the barracks boost or decrease training times. Make it easier for us to play longer & stop making me feel like all your doing is trying to bleed me dry!
I offer my opinion with all good intentions, I love this game and hope to offer productive feedback. I can't help the negative overtones as my disappointment currently shadows my enjoyment. Come on SC, help me play your game, I'm doing everything I can from my side, how about a little more love from your side!

Hope my input resonates & helps add some color to the overall feedback. All good intentions! Clash on!!

---

agree with all

Barbarian King: the feature is pretty cool a small free rage every fight I use him.
Archer Queen: Don't have one so can't give any input.
One thing that's kind of bad is that it only works on offense, it would've been nice for example if the ability activated when the hero drops below 50% hp on defense. Would balance offense and defense a bit more.

Lvl 6 minions & Freeze Spell: i'm TH8 so can't test them but I find the minion update to be a bit expensive for what you get, if for example you had given minions 87+ HP so they can survive a shot of max archer tower at lvl 6 then the price would have been justified but right now it's kind of ridiculous.

Duration and cost reduction of boosts + Hero boost: love it since I rarely have the time to play more than 2 hours straigth and it feels like a waste to boost for 4 hours then. Also the heal on heroes is so expensive i've never used it but the boost is reseonable priced :)

Clan Co-Leader: Should've been in the game from the start, pretty much any game with clan/guild systems have a much better and advanced system. Being able to make your own rank and adding privileges for each rank like in WoW would've been a very nice feature.

Increased gem amount on obstacle removal: Haven't had a free builder and obstacles at the same time since the update so I have no idea if it has improved a lot.

Gem Box: Currently disabled, kind of sad considering the amount of time spent on this update and saying that everything is planned 2-3 updates ahead and tested for months.

Interface tweaks: all good, sadly can't donate when not in your town.

Rage spell: 10% won't really affect gameplay that much. But I guess it's good since offense is more powerfull than defense in this game, every bit helps.

Hogs & Pekka: Love the hog price increase. Would've been nice if you doubled the training time as well, I see way too many people just resorting to hogs instead of actually learning how to raid properly. Pekka is a small update so I doubt many will even notice.

Valkyrie: I love that you buffed the Valkyrie's health but for me and I assume a lot of other players the Hitpoints of the Valkyr wasn't the issue. The training time is a bigger no go for me. If you'd reduce training time to 8-12 mins they might get some more love in the game.

Other notes: Line on wizard tower is back and is very frustrating for some people (including me), there's a small line on every green bar as well depending on your resolution.

To better assign roles' responsibilities in the Clan, the Elder should still be able to promote players to Elder and not be able to demote them.

In this way, the Elder role will be somehow aligned to the new Co-leader one at its proper level of the command chain. Indeed, now the Elder role has been reduced too much, and it is almost no more appealing as a reward.

Check on the attached table the unbalanced Elder capabilities:

Attachment 27215


ARoman, Engineers Clan (Italy)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ARoman

To better assign roles' responsibilities in the Clan, the Elder should still be able to promote players to Elder and not be able to demote them.

In this way, the Elder role will be somehow aligned to the new Co-leader one at its proper level of the command chain. Indeed, now the Elder role has been reduced too much, and it is almost no more appealing as a reward.

Check on the attached table the unbalanced Elder capabilities:

Attachment 27215


ARoman, Engineers Clan (Italy)

---

Awesome, thanks for the spread sheet

Hi..

I have not gone through all the pages so I'm not sure whether it has been posted.

I noticed that the Clan Chat tab is now available during "Visit" and even "Replays".


The "Donate" button though is grayed and says you have to "Return Home" to be able to donate.


A huge plus really.. Especially when clan members are asking you to review their bases.. You don't have to go back to your base to say you comment(s).

Thank you SC!

PS: Clan Wars please

Barbarian King: Archer Queen: These new abilities will be very fun to use and see how they change the attack strategies. I was impressed to see a very poorly executed att in champ become successful based on heros alone. This was an all out drag freeze att that was dead at 25%, then heros were deployed and he was able to get to 50%. pretty crazy and we will see if this is common or just luck of the layout

Hero Regen Boost This was actually the best part of hero tweaks as it allows us to use them more. Very excited and happy to see this.

Lvl 6 minions & Freeze Spell: Happy to see any upgrade to a troop that i rely on for farming and pushing. It seems the small increase has been helpful. Freeze on the other hand is not for me. I have it lvl 4 and have never used it effectively so it has never been a spell of choice.

Duration and cost reduction of boosts: This was great as now I can boost more often. I liked the 4hr boost as well, and generally the overall reduction from the last 16 months, but the 2hr change was an improvement as well.

Clan Co-Leader: I actually do not like this, but maybe its because its new to me. My clan has a great structure with little reason to change, but will be forced to as my elders have now been stripped power

Increased gem amount on obstacle removal: No complaints, can only be good

Gem Box: anxiously await this feature

Interface tweaks: nice to be able to chat while watching a replay or looking at bases, plus chat its self looks cleaner to me

Rage spell: I only use rage and will still only use rage.

Hogs & Pekka: I think a price increase should have been the first step in hog nerf, its here now and may have gone too far. Im not a hog user but so many nerfs have made them almost useless to farm or push with. I dont use pekkas anymore but will be glad they are stronger when i do.

Valkyrie: This troop needs the most work. Train time must be cut, cost maybe should be cut as well. Its the only troop I dont ever see being used by anyone at any level.

Now the people who uses(tier 1) troops can compete with high ranks which will give good opportunity to everyone to reach the top not only the lazy asses who are depending on their defenses because they have maxed base that's one.

2nd (champs with high trophies) will find easier bases to raid as everyone could get high trophies, and farmers will farm from each others and the gold & the elixir will be exchange with attacks as it become easier raids.

I think this update is huge and will motivate everyone to attack which basically the joy of the game rather than depends on their defenses.

Co-Leaders idea is cool as you don't have to give your account to anyone to have multi kick or any authorization that the leader has while you are away.

thank you super cell never expect this update will be this cool.

In regards to Feedback this has been a very refreshing update the level 6 minions have teetered me off the edge into begininning my level 10 townhall days in advance; i am also loving the hero abilities they add a new layer of strategic gameplay really makes you focus in and want to activate those spells at the most optimal time! & for that i am really enjoying it.

Im going to go ahead and agree that i would love to use valks if they were less time costly like wizards and balloons would definitely be able to create a top tier army with a couple of those bad girls.
ALL in ALL good update &&
Allow troops or refund of elixer when the troop survives the battle . This addition would be awsome