So this is your reward for winning defense...

Tonight I won the 2 first and with lost traps/bombs/CC/napping King I lost the third, overall >500 000 Elixir. The idea that it is better to lose than win is wrong. Defending your townhall should never be wrong.

Some ideas:
Winning a defence give you shield, not losing.
The amount of loot enemies get depend on how many stars they take. 0 stars, 0 loot.
Winning a defence should give you some bonus, maybe loot, autofilled traps/bombs/CC/awaken hero?

As it is now winning is losing, I don't like that idea.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by n3r0s

Tonight I won the 2 first and with lost traps/bombs/CC/napping King I lost the third, overall >500 000 Elixir. The idea that it is better to lose than win is wrong. Defending your townhall should never be wrong.

Some ideas:
Winning a defence give you shield, not losing.
The amount of loot enemies get depend on how many stars they take. 0 stars, 0 loot.
Winning a defence should give you some bonus, maybe loot, autofilled traps/bombs/CC/awaken hero?

As it is now winning is losing, I don't like that idea.

---

True, I know this idea is ruled out in sticky.
But the least i could say is that the league bonus should go to defender on a successful defense.
Re-Arming of traps is pretty expensive, esp if you are farming. OR make re-arming cost minimal. Current re-arm costs of 75k-120k is too much to win on defense.
Looks like its better to have a crappy base and lose the first time itself.

In essence, if you win a defense ... you are actually losing !!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Beagle21

did you th snipe you way up in cups? I find some of my most lucrative revenges come from this. I would suggest skipping bases with exposed th in case this is the problem.

Regardless this is pretty tough to log into, my condolences

---

No, no, I partly disagree, players skim their revenge list, and bang something pops up.

I passed by 2600 about a week and half ago, still getting revenge attacks from players in crystal & even gold, I knowI wiped these bases, but a few TH outside noobs like to revenge.

http://i39.tinypic.com/2w69bnm.jpg
http://i44.tinypic.com/hs72o6.jpg
http://i39.tinypic.com/2a7eo3o.jpg

Back on to topic, above are a few screen shots of a few defences, the trophy lost over trophy win ratio is stupid!

The 0-5 trophies won on defence means they could have anything between 30-59 available if they 3 starred, we can't gain that amount of trophies on winning, at any point during a push.

And I totally agree, I can loose a high amount of loot, even if I win a defence, AD then get a repeat attack straight away.

It seems pointless, unless pushing for cups, to not keep your TH outside, would be nice if the attackers loot bonus, is given to he winner.

but trophy loss is the biggest pain in the ♥♥♥♥.

A player attacked me, lost, I gained 26, I revenged I gained another 19 (2*) he lost 45 just from me in an hour and a half, he also attacked me at 2900+ when I had revenged he was sitting at 2802, hour and half, with out gems could you gain that count up in masters, by attacking alone.

I try not to save both elixer and gold at the same time, I take turns , if I'm upgrading a barrack or amp then I pour lots of gold into walls , andif I'm upgrading defences I use my elixer on spells expensive troops . Hope this helps

That's bad luck buddy.

Well they can possibly tweak the 40% of getting shield to 20% or something. Just my $0.02.