donating spells

i mean Over Powered

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by chiefgabe

I think you should be able to donate spells in the clan castle. It would be just like donating troops. What do you think?

---

No. Zappers would now be able to attack with as many as 10 lightning spells. No thanks. I like just being able to donate troops.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Julezwatts

No. Zappers would now be able to attack with as many as 10 lightning spells. No thanks. I like just being able to donate troops.

---

Please read the other replies in this thread - that concern was already addressed and resolved.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by techcare

What do you mean by "OP"?

---

OP means "overpowered" which means that it very strong\stronger than it should be. :)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by techcare

That is how I would manage that feature - you can only hold as many as your factory allows. If your factory has a max of 3 spells, you can only hold a total of 3 spells, regardless of if they are bought by you or donated by a clan member.

I would even like to see another Friend in Need type of achievement put in place track spell donations.

There are some kinks to be worked out, but this could work!

---

Then what is the point of the donation if all it gives you is one from a clan mate. Also I wouldn't want to donate a 30k spell to some clan mate. From the general point of the idea its terrible, people would be ♥♥♥♥♥♥ off that they got attacked with a lvl 2 freeze spell and they are only TH5.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ClashySquill

Then what is the point of the donation if all it gives you is one from a clan mate. Also I wouldn't want to donate a 30k spell to some clan mate. From the general point of the idea its terrible, people would be ♥♥♥♥♥♥ off that they got attacked with a lvl 2 freeze spell and they are only TH5.

---

I understand that at a lower level of playing, you may not see the benefit of this. However, for those of us who play at higher levels, a 30k spell isn't anything. It's the same as a few wizards or a dragon or PEKKA. The cost is the same or less than those units.

Let me ask you though - By using your logic, you shouldn't be able to donate a level 2 dragon to anyone because they might use it when attacking a TH5, right? That makes no sense. People are free to use (or waste) their units or spells how they please.

(Also, if you're attacking a TH5 with a freeze spell, you're either incredibly inexperienced or the TH5 has some insanely high look which isn't possible.)

As far as the "point of the donation," it's to help your clanmates. You couldn't really count it as one troop, like when you donate a troop. That is why I suggested a different achievement for it. Also, it would probably need a separate request button. Also there would be the same 20minute cooldown time (or longer depending on game mechanics and game balance) for requesting spells again.

This is not a terrible idea. It has been suggested many times before and it's wonderful! Obviously, supercell sees this as a possibility as well, as it hasn't been ruled out.

Only one spell to donate are alla right not 10 I would like to donate one spell to every one who want it my english it is bad I hope you intherstand what im saying

Terrible idea. High level players could give maxed rage to noobs who haven't earned it, or use one account to effectively help another use twice as many spells.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by chiefgabe

I think you should be able to donate spells in the clan castle. It would be just like donating troops. What do you think?

---

I think .............. this idea is ................................................. ruled out

Isn't this ruled out? This would be cool, but imagine 6 level 6 lightnings on a DE storage. SC considers all the things that could go wrong or are unfair, which is why Clan Wars may be taking longer than expected.