Siege Machine at TH10

level 6 Clan Castles (Town Hall 10) shouldn't have a siege machine slot... It's so unbalanced. Getting tired of my clan's TH10 villages being wiped by poorly planned attacks that had a siege machine and got 3 stars while they'd barely get 1 star if it wasn't for the machine. Just to clarify, I have nothing against siege machines, I like them, adding stuff like that to make the attacks more complex enhance the experience of the game, but they just shouldn't be available for TH10's Clan Castles.

If you basebuild properly, then it shouldn't be that easy to get 3 stars. However, I do admit that 3 stars are quite common for mirror matchups at basically any townhall that's not 12 or 13.

All th10s have siege access upon upgrading their clan castle, so it’s perfectly balanced.

This will allow just about any th10 player to get a siege making th10 attacks too easy IMO.
I know that you get it in your CC in a clan but that's kinda the perk of being in a clan.

I know every TH10 can receive them, my point is: getting 3 stars is way too easy with them. 3 stars are also common at TH9 but you can't get it without a decent attack (when attacking a full village at least). At TH10 a lot of lousy attacks using siege machines get 3 stars.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by kimbaru

I know every TH10 can receive them, my point is: getting 3 stars is way too easy with them. 3 stars are also common at TH9 but you can't get it without a decent attack (when attacking a full village at least). At TH10 a lot of lousy attacks using siege machines get 3 stars.

---

TH10 is three levels below the max. Getting 3 stars should be easy when you are that far down. It was very easy to get 3 stars at TH8 when TH10 was the max, never mind TH7.

The lowest level now that a competent player will often not triple an equivalent base is TH11, and even there, it will happen more often than not.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ajax

TH10 is three levels below the max. Getting 3 stars should be easy when you are that far down. It was very easy to get 3 stars at TH8 when TH10 was the max, never mind TH7.

The lowest level now that a competent player will often not triple an equivalent base is TH11, and even there, it will happen more often than not.

---

I disagree. How far below the max shouldn't matter when getting attacked by the same TH level. And still, TH10 with siege machine is easier to get 3 stars than TH9.

And when your TH10 crush the other guys who are rushed/poorly designed maps TH10 due to siege ?????? This comes down to one thing and one thing only. BASE LAYOUT

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by kimbaru

I disagree. How far below the max shouldn't matter when getting attacked by the same TH level. And still, TH10 with siege machine is easier to get 3 stars than TH9.

---

Whether you think it should or not, it always has, and always will.

Apart from anything else, it is inherent in the fact that you can get high level CC troops. But even without those, most lower level TH will expect to triple equivalent opponents more often than not.

I can't honestly see SC doing anything to change that either. They don't want the game to get too hard until you start reaching the higher levels.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ajax

Whether you think it should or not, it always has, and always will.

Apart from anything else, it is inherent in the fact that you can get high level CC troops. But even without those, most lower level TH will expect to triple equivalent opponents more often than not.

I can't honestly see SC doing anything to change that either. They don't want the game to get too hard until you start reaching the higher levels.

---

ok now that was a good point. Really wish they'd do something about it but I guess you are right. Thanks for the replies guys.