trophy amount lost when defeated in a raid

I think that the trophy amounts lost when your defeated when you raid should be lowered or go down in stages, like if you are going to lose 30 but you get 49% instead of losing 30 you lose say 10, like the stars you get for destroying over 50%, I thought maybe like if you get under 15% you lose all, under 30% over 15% you lose 2/3 and over 30% to 50% you lose 1/3. It is kind of unfair if you get 51% you get around 5 trophies but if you get 49% you lose 30.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Simdim13

I think that the trophy amounts lost when your defeated when you raid should be lowered or go down in stages, like if you are going to lose 30 but you get 49% instead of losing 30 you lose say 10, like the stars you get for destroying over 50%, I thought maybe like if you get under 15% you lose all, under 30% over 15% you lose 2/3 and over 30% to 50% you lose 1/3. It is kind of unfair if you get 51% you get around 5 trophies but if you get 49% you lose 30.

---

It's already staggered. How it breaks up is in thirds.

For each star, you get 1/3 of the possible trophies.

Town Hall being destroyed = 1 star and 1/3 of the trophies
50% damage to town = 1 star and 1/3 of the trophies
100% damage to town = 1 star and 1/3 of the trophies

If the third that it breaks up into ends in a fraction, it gets rounded down to the nearest whole number.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by techcare

It's already staggered. How it breaks up is in thirds.

For each star, you get 1/3 of the possible trophies.

Town Hall being destroyed = 1 star and 1/3 of the trophies
50% damage to town = 1 star and 1/3 of the trophies
100% damage to town = 1 star and 1/3 of the trophies

---

Yeah that's what he said. He said its staggered when you win, it should also be staggered when you lose.

That's a pretty good idea, gets me furious when you get 49% and lose 29 trophies :mad: And then it takes 6 raids to regain them

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Simdim13

I think that the trophy amounts lost when your defeated when you raid should be lowered or go down in stages, like if you are going to lose 30 but you get 49% instead of losing 30 you lose say 10, like the stars you get for destroying over 50%, I thought maybe like if you get under 15% you lose all, under 30% over 15% you lose 2/3 and over 30% to 50% you lose 1/3. It is kind of unfair if you get 51% you get around 5 trophies but if you get 49% you lose 30.

---

How is it unfair when offense is so overpowered? If you actually lose a raid when the offense is so much stronger than defense you deserve to lose a lot of trophies.

I'm fine with the current system it rewards keeping the attacker in the first 50% of a base because all trophies gained from 1400+ come from the defender so if you loose less if you get close it doesn't reward the defender for a successful defense which often is in the 30-50% zone

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by JtB

How is it unfair when offense is so overpowered? If you actually lose a raid when the offense is so much stronger than defense you deserve to lose a lot of trophies.

---

If you are able to get to say 40% then you should deserve to not lose all the trophies, but if you only get to 5% then you do deserve to lose them all

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Simdim13

If you are able to get to say 40% then you should deserve to not lose all the trophies, but if you only get to 5% then you do deserve to lose them all

---

You are not understanding the concept, offense is way overpowered. A monkey could get 40% on nearly any base if he had maxed troops equal to the town hall level that he was attacking. Offense has all of the cards stacked in their favor as it is, and yet, you want offense to have even more advantages. Again, if you fail to get at least 50% in an attack when offense is so much more overpowered than defense you deserve to lose more trophies than you would have won.

This is a wrong subforrum it should be in ideas and feature

Who cares about trophies anyway? Trophy pushing serves no purpose unless you are putting yourself in a different league to farm or if you can be in the top few players in the world for the seasonal gems.