Close discussion
Printable View
Close discussion
are we allowed to stay?
Before recent update, penalty for upgrading th included:
1. less loot gain from low lvls (-50% loot from th -2 lvls)
2. more loot loss, if attacked by higher ths (it's not a separate penalty, it's the 1st one applied: if you go from th7 to 8, th9 gets -10% penalty vs you, instead of -50, so it works as a more loot loss for you)
3. more loot loss, if attacked by lower ths
Update removed 3rd penalty, but the first two remain as they were. Premature th9 is bad, because, it invites th10s to raid.
Premature th8 invites th9.
Your defense lvl, compared to you, as if you were 1 lvl lower, - does not matter. What matters is your defense vs your probable attacker. Updrading th makes you a valid target for higher lvl attackers. This is what makes premature th bad.
Recruiting forum is next to this one. I personally would not go for any advice to someone, who can't figure out a correct forum to post his clan invitation. Cheers. :)
What about pre-mature th10 thats is going to farm at 1500-1800 thropys, you get less th10 over there. With 3 X-bow and 2 inferno at lvl 1 most people wont attack you right?Quote:
Originally Posted by StanHC
So is this worth going th10 pre-mature?
I would say no. As a permi th10 you can only get 150k out of storages a th8. This means you have to deal with th9 with xbows. This might get you in trouble if your troops are not maxxed.Quote:
Originally Posted by Deuverman
And you might get hammered by nice th9 like me that are nearly maxxed :-) and farm in that range.
A th 10 Loots the exact same as a th8 the only difference is that a th10 can get raided for more resources than a lower th.
I don't think so. There is a loot penalty for the TH10 attacking lower level THs. A TH8 can attack other TH8s for no penalty. A TH10 attacking a TH8 receives 50% less loot.Quote:
Originally Posted by NickKern
Please read about the new loot system before posting such nonsense!Quote:
Originally Posted by NickKern
The loot penalty is still in place so:
TH10 raids TH9 -> 90% of the avalible loot
TH10 raids TH8 -> 50% of the avalible loot
TH10 raids TH7 -> 25% of the avalible loot
Th10 raids TH6 -> 5% of the avalible loot
So going up as permi might get the problem worse
I believe it means exact same amount per attack, just have to raid th9s instead of th7s. :)Quote:
Originally Posted by NickKern
Dont forget the higher cost of the 'next' button. In the long run this can cost you millions compared to the 'next'-costs of a th8.
I found this information on a post by Marika under the headline (Important: changes to the loot system) Now unless I have misunderstood this post and if I have sorry for the false information then I stand with by this.
Ah, ok. You are wrong, then. :)
Quote:
What about existing loot penalties?
Currently, there is a loot penalty system in place that can modify the available loot based on the difference between the attacker and defender Town Hall levels. It was intended to discourage players at higher levels from picking on players at much lower levels by reducing the loot when the defender was at a lower Town Hall level, and increasing the loot when the defender was at a higher Town Hall level. However, this system is not ideal for a number of reasons and has, not unfairly, been criticized as "punishing players for progression."
We feel that the loot adjustments, as described above, are a better way of encouraging fair play and rewarding high level attacks, rather than the existing loot penalty based system. Therefore, we are removing loot cap increases based on an attacker being below a defender's Town Hall level.
Some examples will help here, too. In the old system, the situation looked like this:
(Old system) If a defender at Town Hall level 10 had 200k gold as available loot:
An attacker at Town Hall level 10 would see 200k gold as available loot (no penalty)
An attacker at Town Hall level 9 would see 220k gold as available loot (+10% loot increase)
An attacker at Town Hall level 8 would see 300k gold as available loot (+50% loot increase)
The new system will be much simpler. Town Hall level differences are ignored when the attacker is below the defender's Town Hall level. Instead, higher town hall levels will naturally carry a higher loot cap, regardless of opponent.
(New system) If defender at Town Hall level 10 has 400k gold as available loot:
An attacker at Town Hall level 10 will see 400k gold as available loot
An attacker at Town Hall level 9 will see 400k gold as available loot
An attacker at Town Hall level 8 will see 400k gold as available loot
Keep in mind, though, that loot decreases based on an attacker being above a defender's Town Hall level will remain unchanged in order to continue to better protect lower level players.
You have at least misunderstood the prat about TH loot bonuses and penalties. The bonus for attacking higher THs is gone, the penalty for attack a lower TH is still there and the same as it was before the loot update.Quote:
Originally Posted by NickKern
TRUTH!Quote:
Originally Posted by Pete82
More truth.Quote:
Originally Posted by KoningDulcis
SUPER DUPER FALSE.Quote:
Originally Posted by NickKern
On a side note, did anyone else notice that you got tricked into being involved in a recruitment thread without even knowing it? That's what this really is, a thread to recruit you to his/her clan. Wrong section, but you almost got me :)
Are you trying to circulate false info so that those who fall for it will go premmie and then you have the chance to raid them?