Permanent Purchasable Super Troops

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by DAWNBUDGE

There’s no pay to win here.

---

It is
People who get permanent super troops have an advantage
Not only that but it ruins the whole point of super troops
That you can use it for one week and then a week of cool down
This idea just ruins super troops and is pay to win

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by DAWNBUDGE

There’s no pay to win here.

---

It is P2W.An F2P player would be able to unlock only 3(or maybe,4)Super troops(lots more are coming) through the accumulated gems.And that is,if he plays for years,spends no gems at all,and sacrifices all clan games rewards and clan war league medals,for this.Accumulating 2500+ gems won't be too easy for an F2P player.Whereas,a P2W player could just buy some gems and unlock all the super troops instantly.I don't think many F2P players are going to like this,if this gets implented(as the P2W players would have the ability to decide which super troops they want to use,after scouting the war base,whereas a F2P player would be stuck with the one he chose.)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Goo27

It is
People who get permanent super troops have an advantage
Not only that but it ruins the whole point of super troops
That you can use it for one week and then a week of cool down
This idea just ruins super troops and is pay to win

---

Not pay to win, please go back and read the entire conversation u won’t understand it unless u do, pay to win don’t exist if u are able to earn things without buying, hence making gems from normal things, plus why would anyone pay a load of money in clash for things? Pay to win more than anything means Money would make u win all the time, that don’t happen because u can buy all the gems u want and it don’t make u a better attacker so I don’t see pay to win even existing in clash of clans, it’s just people who are jealous of others spending money to get things faster than others, this game has been out for many years now so who cares if others use gems to reach the endgame faster, it takes a very long time for new people to upgrade their hero’s anyway, they will most likely be sitting there for awhile and that means anyone above them puts them at a disadvantage so if u want to claim my idea is p2w then u should consider disadvantages have always existed and that p2w only makes people catch up faster, there will always be someone under each other and no amount of money can make u better, permanent troops are just an idea for people like me who don’t use them because of the cooldown.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Nexusios1521

It is P2W.An F2P player would be able to unlock only 3(or maybe,4)Super troops(lots more are coming) through the accumulated gems.And that is,if he plays for years,spends no gems at all,and sacrifices all clan games rewards and clan war league medals,for this.Accumulating 2500+ gems won't be too easy for an F2P player.Whereas,a P2W player could just buy some gems and unlock all the super troops instantly.I don't think many F2P players are going to like this,if this gets implented(as the P2W players would have the ability to decide which super troops they want to use,after scouting the war base,whereas a F2P player would be stuck with the one he chose.)

---

Dude that’s how it is rn with everyone your stuck with that single troop for 7 days, and then u got a cooldown so the disadvantages already exist, and if u don’t need the items from CWL, SP, CG, or the trader then why not delete them for gems, if people need them then don’t delete them but there exists a way for F2P players getting gems really easily so that shouldn’t keep people thinking p2w here p2w there when everyone can literally get it all, I mean no matter what in the game rn u are always gonna have to work and save up for as an example a upgrade when others who have the resources or gems can instantly buy it and upgrade it, anyone can do that if they choose to do so, the only thing gems do in this game is allow u to speed up your overall village upgrade times/levels, other than that gems can’t make u better at a game that has been out for years now, so I don’t believe in p2w in clash of clans since the endgame is based on knowledge and skill, this means the pro players can use any troop strategies and 3 star anyone.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by DAWNBUDGE

Not pay to win, please go back and read the entire conversation u won’t understand it unless u do, pay to win don’t exist if u are able to earn things without buying, hence making gems from normal things, plus why would anyone pay a load of money in clash for things? Pay to win more than anything means Money would make u win all the time, that don’t happen because u can buy all the gems u want and it don’t make u a better attacker so I don’t see pay to win even existing in clash of clans, it’s just people who are jealous of others spending money to get things faster than others, this game has been out for many years now so who cares if others use gems to reach the endgame faster, it takes a very long time for new people to upgrade their hero’s anyway, they will most likely be sitting there for awhile and that means anyone above them puts them at a disadvantage so if u want to claim my idea is p2w then u should consider disadvantages have always existed and that p2w only makes people catch up faster, there will always be someone under each other and no amount of money can make u better, permanent troops are just an idea for people like me who don’t use them because of the cooldown.

---

Lets see if sc will say its p2w because I dont want to argue for another hour

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Goo27

Lets see if sc will say its p2w because I dont want to argue for another hour

---

Exactly.(Don't think the devs are going to post here(for good reason),tho).Don't want to argue,anymore.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Goo27

Lets see if sc will say its p2w because I dont want to argue for another hour

---

Well unlike the other persons idea on the other forum post he said give permanent access to these troops by a 5$ gold pass that’s pay to win, my suggestion is something able to be obtained by all F2P, same as any other upgrade, defense, hero, troop, or building.

Aye re read the edited main idea of this thread I edited it to give a better incentive and a option to the endgame players who have a lot of CWL tokens saved up.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by DAWNBUDGE

Aye re read the edited main idea of this thread I edited it to give a better incentive and a option to the endgame players who have a lot of CWL tokens saved up.

---

I'm sorry but this idea is so wrong
If you remove the option to buy it with gems it would be better
But the whole fundamental idea is wrong
The whole point of super troops is the cool down
I'm sorry but a big no from me

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Goo27

I'm sorry but this idea is so wrong
If you remove the option to buy it with gems it would be better
But the whole fundamental idea is wrong
The whole point of super troops is the cool down
I'm sorry but a big no from me

---

The option to buy with gems is optional Incase supercell thinks gaining 2000/2500 is to hard for most people.