Has This Ever Frustrated You?

So you take the time to put together what you believe is a well thought out post - clearly worded and well described. You post it and sit back for well constructed feedback. But then? Almost nothing! Not only a lack of views but a lack of viewings. Meanwhile other posts that are titled "The coolest super duper idea ever" or worse, posts that r spelld lik thiz the hole way throo (grrr) get tons of views AND even worse replies.

Am I complaining? Yes. Whining a wee bit? Perhaps. But I want feedback. Tell me the idea stinks, tell me I'm an idiot, tell me it has merit but tell me something!

So here is a shameful attempt to get feedback. Please have a look (I did put some time in effort into this). Here is the post in question: http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...an-Tournaments

Thank you for reading and for your feedback.

Frustratingly yours,

Tooth

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Bigtooth78

So you take the time to put together what you believe is a well thought out post - clearly worded and well described. You post it and sit back for well constructed feedback. But then? Almost nothing! Not only a lack of views but a lack of viewings. Meanwhile other posts that are titled "The coolest super duper idea ever" or worse, posts that r spelld lik thiz the hole way throo (grrr) get tons of views AND even worse replies.

Am I complaining? Yes. Whining a wee bit? Perhaps. But I want feedback. Tell me the idea stinks, tell me I'm an idiot, tell me it has merit but tell me something!

So here is a shameful attempt to get feedback. Please have a look (I did put some time in effort into this). Here is the post in question: http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...an-Tournaments

Thank you for reading and for your feedback.

Frustratingly yours,

Tooth

---

And thus the OP realized the awesomeness of the "General" sub-forum, nigh the only forum where ideas get read.

~ Strider

Being on a phone, that post proves to be quite the novel read, but I'll give it a shot when I get home.

You are right it's a good thread that got missed, i've put a couple of ideas down and I would encourage others to do the same.

OP I am sorry sometimes the title can be your best sales tool..anyway don't let it discourage you from putting your time into this community.

I don't know what your subject was, but a lot of people put a poorly worded Title for their post that causes stuff to get skipped over.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Bigtooth78

So you take the time to put together what you believe is a well thought out post - clearly worded and well described. You post it and sit back for well constructed feedback. But then? Almost nothing! Not only a lack of views but a lack of viewings. Meanwhile other posts that are titled "The coolest super duper idea ever" or worse, posts that r spelld lik thiz the hole way throo (grrr) get tons of views AND even worse replies.

Am I complaining? Yes. Whining a wee bit? Perhaps. But I want feedback. Tell me the idea stinks, tell me I'm an idiot, tell me it has merit but tell me something!

So here is a shameful attempt to get feedback. Please have a look (I did put some time in effort into this). Here is the post in question: http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...an-Tournaments

Thank you for reading and for your feedback.

Frustratingly yours,

Tooth

---

YES, YES, AND YES!!
I completly agree with the OP
In the past couple of days I have posted well thought out ideas, I cant wait to get replies
Then my idea gets overwhelmed and pushed down by dumb ruled out ideas like:
-Donating resources!:cool: Or
-Exchange market:cool: Or
-Name change!

It gets so annoying!:mad:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Saltin

YES, YES, AND YES!!
I completly agree with the OP
In the past couple of days I have poster well thought out ideas, I cant wait to get replies
Then my idea gets overwhelmed and pushed down by dumb ruled out ideas like:
-Donating resources!:cool: Or
-Exchange market:cool: Or
-Name change!

It gets so annoying!:mad:

---

So annoying they you post it twice eh?:rolleyes:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TomRapp

So annoying they you post it twice eh?:rolleyes:

---

lol I only meant to post it once, but since I nave trashy internet connection I accudently posted it twice

I deleted the duplicate :)

Yeah this has happened to all of my threads :(

Totally understand your frustration.. It's part of the reason I, or maybe many others stop going to the idea sub-forum.

It's typically filled with idea that's not thought out and has been mentioned many many times previously.

I'm wondering if the mod could restrict the idea sub-forum a bit more? Maybe increase the number of minimum required characters in a post in the idea forum? Good ideas typically takes paragraph to describe all the details, something the 10 chars wouldn't do.

And it's really cool idea, will post a separate reply in the idea forum,,