Warning System

Hi guys,

I have been in situation where I would like to give a member a "warning" but I can't for obvious reason. (There is no way of doing it)

I think if elders and give members warnings by pressing on their name and pressing "Warn". The elder can type a message to the user which doesn't have a short limitation.

Leaders can also do this but they can also warn elders.

The warning appears in the warned users inbox with a subject saying "[Warners name] has given you a warning!" And then the message underneath.

So it is bit like the infractions you get on the forums.


Let me know what you guys think.

No. This sounds both annoying and patronizing.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by shivampaw

Hi guys,

I have been in situation where I would like to give a member a "warning" but I can't for obvious reason. (There is no way of doing it)

I think if elders and give members warnings by pressing on their name and pressing "Warn". The elder can type a message to the user which doesn't have a short limitation.

Leaders can also do this but they can also warn elders.

The warning appears in the warned users inbox with a subject saying "[Warners name] has given you a warning!" And then the message underneath.

So it is bit like the infractions you get on the forums.


Let me know what you guys think.

---

I have actually never heard of this idea but I like it! +1

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by dahimi

No. This sounds both annoying and patronizing.

---

In what way? As in an elder can harass the members?

This will get ABUSED easily.:rolleyes:

This is a good idea. Maybe they can set a 1-6 hour limit until a person can be re-warned.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by BluStar

This will get ABUSED easily.:rolleyes:

---

How?

ten chars

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by fabiancito

This is a good idea. Maybe they can set a 1-6 hour limit until a person can be re-warned.

---

More like 36 hours.


But still i dont get the point, why cant you just tell them in clan chat??:confused:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by fabiancito

This is a good idea. Maybe they can set a 1-6 hour limit until a person can be re-warned.

---

Yes I agree with that.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by shivampaw

In what way? As in an elder can harass the members?

---

Look at the behavior in global. Now realize those same people are in clans.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by BluStar

This will get ABUSED easily.:rolleyes:

---

You seem to like putting things in blue bold.

Anyways, to the OP: I think that the leader should be the only one who as the ability to do this, but with a 30 minute cooldown time.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by dahimi

Look at the behavior in global. Now realize those same people are in clans.

---

I think you just blew his mind.

this would seem annoying and condescending.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by BluStar

More like 36 hours.


But still i dont get the point, why cant you just tell them in clan chat??:confused:

---

Because if I told you something that you didn't like being told in public chat then you might leave but if I told you through a warning then you probably wouldn't.


Maybe the warning message box can be pre populated with things like, No donating goblins, Watch your donations and receiving ratio.

This would be much better. Something like this:

A drop down with a few options like, Donated wrong troops, Bad ratio, Not donating, Been inactive. etc.

Then when you select one a few fields would come depending on what you choose. Eg.

Been Inactive field would be - Last seen.

Then when you press send the game will format it to something like this:


Shivam Paw has given you a warning for being inactive. You were last seen [date] You are required to come online more to stand a chance of reaming in the clan. This warning could also mean you have logged on recently but not spoken, donated or received.


An automated system would make it easier to handle and less abused

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Julezwatts

You seem to like putting things in blue bold.

Anyways, to the OP: I think that the leader should be the only one who as the ability to do this, but with a 30 minute cooldown time.

---

Yes thats not a bad idea, also Co- leaders (if introduced) should get this

Warn them publicaly. If they don't modify their behavior, kick them, simple as that.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by shivampaw

Because if I told you something that you didn't like being told in public chat then you might leave but if I told you through a warning then you probably wouldn't.


Maybe the warning message box can be pre populated with things like, No donating goblins, Watch your donations and receiving ratio.

This would be much better. Something like this:

A drop down with a few options like, Donated wrong troops, Bad ratio, Not donating, Been inactive. etc.

Then when you select one a few fields would come depending on what you choose. Eg.

Been Inactive field would be - Last seen.

Then when you press send the game will format it to something like this:


Shivam Paw has given you a warning for being inactive. You were last seen [date] You are required to come online more to stand a chance of reaming in the clan. This warning could also mean you have logged on recently but not spoken, donated or received.


An automated system would make it easier to handle and less abused

---

That is much better. So it has options like 'Donate what is requested' ect.

Last online date has been ruled out.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by dahimi

Look at the behavior in global. Now realize those same people are in clans.

---

Im gonna go way out on a limb here,but i actually agree with this

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by dahimi

Last online date has been ruled out.

---

NO! It doesn't say last online date.
It says last seen. So the elder puts when he was last seen

warning message also say this "This warning could also mean you have logged on recently but not spoken, donated or received."

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jazzathegreat

Im gonna go way out on a limb here,but i actually agree with this

---

Great to hear!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by BluStar

This will get ABUSED easily.:rolleyes:

---

If you get abused by it, then it's obvious that the clan you are in isn't good, or you need to tell the leader to demote some elders.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by shivampaw

NO! It doesn't say last online date.
It says last seen. So the elder puts when he was last seen

warning message also say this "This warning could also mean you have logged on recently but not spoken, donated or received."

---

That's exactly what's trying to be prevented with 'last online date' or 'online indicator'. Players would be harassed because they weren't talking or donating. Would you like it if you logged on, collected resources, and logged off. Then the next time you log on, you have a warning message from your leader saying: You were online earlier but didn't talk, donate, or receive.

I don't know about you, but that would ♥♥♥♥ me off.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Julezwatts

That's exactly what's trying to be prevented with 'last online date' or 'online indicator'. Players would be harassed because they weren't talking or donating. Would you like it if you logged on, collected resources, and logged off. Then the next time you log on, you have a warning message from your leader saying: You were online earlier but didn't talk, donate, or receive.

I don't know about you, but that would ♥♥♥♥ me off.

---

I don't think it would be used like that but I had someone in my clan who had joined for 5 days and I noticed he was online everyday yet 0 donations and 0 received. never seen him talk either. Wanted to warn him to come and talk more but had to kick instead as he was taking up room.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Julezwatts

That's exactly what's trying to be prevented with 'last online date' or 'online indicator'. Players would be harassed because they weren't talking or donating. Would you like it if you logged on, collected resources, and logged off. Then the next time you log on, you have a warning message from your leader saying: You were online earlier but didn't talk, donate, or receive.

I don't know about you, but that would ♥♥♥♥ me off.

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by shivampaw

I don't think it would be used like that but I had someone in my clan who had joined for 5 days and I noticed he was online everyday yet 0 donations and 0 received. never seen him talk either. Wanted to warn him to come and talk more but had to kick instead as he was taking up room.

---

That's exactly how it would be used. And this is the reason I would like to never see the ability to message players either.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by shivampaw

I don't think it would be used like that but I had someone in my clan who had joined for 5 days and I noticed he was online everyday yet 0 donations and 0 received. never seen him talk either. Wanted to warn him to come and talk more but had to kick instead as he was taking up room.

---

How do you know that he was online if he NEVER talked and NEVER requested and NEVER donated?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Julezwatts

How do you know that he was online if he NEVER talked and NEVER requested and NEVER donated?

---

Collected mines

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Herpacleese

That's exactly how it would be used. And this is the reason I would like to never see the ability to message players either.

---

You cannot send a custom message - you will look at the dropdown select a option then add in any "variables"

I just don't see the need for this, I take my clans pretty seriously, and this feels a bit petty and authoritarian

1)
Just put it in the clan chat, or are these secrets?

2)
Why not just have the leader use a clan message?
You can send 2 per day.
"These members are in danger of getting kicked for ___________. Player 1, Player 2."

3)
Man up and kick them out?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by PhilISuppose

I just don't see the need for this, I take my clans pretty seriously, and this feels a bit petty and authoritarian

1)
Just put it in the clan chat, or are these secrets?

2)
Why not just have the leader use a clan message?
You can send 2 per day.
"These members are in danger of getting kicked for ___________. Player 1, Player 2."

3)
Man up and kick them out?

---

2) How would you like to be 'shamed' in an entire clan...

3) It is much better to give a warning before straight kick.

i agree with your idea to a point. Only pre-made warnings though like 'Watch your dobations and receive ratio' but i don't know what u mean by "add in any variables" as that suggests to me a custom message by you. Overall, i don't think this will be implemented just because u flag someone in your clan as not as good a clan member as others and they take it way too personally by being embarassed or butt hurt and they leave your clan. If i were Supercell, i would have to agree with everyone else too as to why you can't just tell them in chat, clan leader message, or kick them. if they are performing poorly i would not want to keep them in my clan, i would kick them and find a better player to join.