Printable View
Initially XP is not gained from donating into CC for wars to stop people donating any silly troop to just gain XP. However, since Supercell has introduced a Donation Menu, this can be incorporated into clan war CCs to balance out the need to donate for war purpose only. XP can be obtained when donating troops from the players donation menu only. This can also help those players who need specific troops which compliments the design for their base.
Please comment your thoughts...
Except XP still won't mean anything.
What happens when someone requests super troops in war cc or max troops that no one in the clan can donate?
I'm against this for two reasons. First, it wouldn't stop players from repeatedly donating troops and deleting them in any way whatsoever. Many players have mini accounts they could set up in a war and request goblins with to cheese the system anyways. Secondly, as has been mentioned before in the forums, allowing clan leadership to delete / modify the contents of a war castle is a significant tactical advantage. I wouldn't be in favor of restricting that in any way.Quote:
Originally Posted by Lirving
I see your view on this. However, from experience in previous clans, no one would donate because no one saw any ‘benefit’ from doing so. Some could argue that it could mean the difference between winning and losing, however, you find it’s mostly those in the top of the clan who donates, but this isn’t every time. It is unarguable that not everybody in the clan donates, but it can be rewarded for those who do. I’m personally in a clan where everyone donates to everyone which is valuable. However, this is not the same for every clan. Troops takes time and resources. Thus the benefits we receive as a clan when donating to cw bases should be considered.Quote:
Originally Posted by kylorayker