They give you the tools and options to optimize. You choose to use them poorly in my opinion. It is a forum to discuss changes. Doesn't mean we all agree that all changes are needed.Quote:
Originally Posted by nioc14
Printable View
They give you the tools and options to optimize. You choose to use them poorly in my opinion. It is a forum to discuss changes. Doesn't mean we all agree that all changes are needed.Quote:
Originally Posted by nioc14
They quite definitely thought about it, because they deliberately moved CWL gradually untril it was exactly at the start of the month - and told us that was what they were doing.Quote:
Originally Posted by nioc14
While that was before season challenges came in, I'm sure they knew those were coming well before thye established CWL at the start of the mont.
As ajax said, they spent several months getting the cwl to start at the beginning of the month. And the passes are monthly so when else would they end? You arent the first to dislike it but most of the others were dealing with 250k de dropped in their storage. Not 50k. Watch the offers and gold pass. There are frequently books available very soon after month end. To be honest though, I doubt you are in the target audience. The silver pass bank awards are a drop in the bucket. Maybe a couple or 3 days of raiding. 25 mill gold and elixir plus 250k de requires a whole different level of planning to deal with.Quote:
Originally Posted by nioc14
As someone who buys the gold pass each season, I can agree with this. Not because I necessarily for the reason of having my heroes in CWL. I can live with that part. What bothers me is that if I run into a situation where I can't spend all of the resources I've accrued throughout the previous season, then someone else can attack my village and steal resources that I have literally spent real world money on. And that bugs the heck out of me. If I get 25 mil of elixir at the end of the season but I can't start a troop upgrade for a day and a half, someone else can steal a fat chunk of that. I don't think it should be "delayed" but I think the season bank should be put into the cc treasury like clan war and five star bonus loot. So yeah I can still be attacked, but they'll steal way less of it. It just makes way more sense to me
You haven't spent real world money on the loot, you have spent it on the opportunity to acquire that loot.Quote:
Originally Posted by PennilessBill
Actually, they would steal way more of it if it were moved to the treasury.Quote:
And that bugs the heck out of me. If I get 25 mil of elixir at the end of the season but I can't start a troop upgrade for a day and a half, someone else can steal a fat chunk of that. I don't think it should be "delayed" but I think the season bank should be put into the cc treasury like clan war and five star bonus loot. So yeah I can still be attacked, but they'll steal way less of it. It just makes way more sense to me
There is a cap on how much can be taken from storages, which is at 5.5 million for TH13 (when they can take 550,000 max) - most of what people are taking from you will actually be taken from the collectors you can't empty when your storages are over-full (you can lose 1,050,000 from those).
But there is no cap on what can be taken from the treasury, you can be raided for 3% of whatever is in there.
If you are really bothered by losing a bit, then move up to Legends. You don't lose any there.
You can buy shield to prevent your base from getting attacked.Quote:
Originally Posted by PennilessBill
I am still waiting for someone to tell me why it is not a change that players would support. I can’t force you to agree but you don’t seem to provide a good reason for your disagreement. I am optimising in a way which reflects my high activity and I don’t think what you suggested works for me - to the contrary it looks suboptimal. As far as I’m concerned, the timing of the season bank has been designed poorly - whether on purpose of not, this poor design is not something I have seen elsewhere in the game - unless you have other examples.Quote:
Originally Posted by Piper139
I had forgotten about this. Now that I go back and look, it doesn’t seem to be a pernicious move to diminish the value of the silver bank.Quote:
Originally Posted by Ajax
Would be helpful if some SC staff could confirm either way so I can just get over it...
My disagreement is that the current system benefits those of us who truly optimize. For my mini, the days just after the season bank drop are awesome looting. From people like you. It is of greater long term benefit for me to choose when to use magic items than to use them during farming time. This is a strategy game. Using magical items for maximum benefit is part of that strategy. You are using them tactically, not strategically. Your choice. As far as your high activity, I have a main in legends and a mini new th11 that is quite active. It's quite possible to attack with heroes down. Even queen or warden. Last, my main opposition to your desire is it's change the game to your specific play style. You want to do it your way. Period. You dont want to consider other options. Again, your choice. But I'd really prefer to keep seeing big, fat targets like you when raiding so I dont see why I'd support it.Quote:
Originally Posted by nioc14
Feels great when people don't leave builder free to dump loot or can't manage the season bank and become sweet target for farming in the first week of every season. Can't see why would anyone support an option which reduces the possible loot from their targets.Quote:
Originally Posted by Piper139