Printable View
Well, not all players are in Town Hall 12. So clans like us are having a hard time competing and looking for seige donators. It makes competing with other clan unfair whenever they have siege machnines. If siege machines are available in TH11, it will be widely accesible for town hall 10 too since reaching town hall 12 takes more time. I hope supercell will take this as a suggestion.
There is an entire subforum for ideas and feature requests
Well, not all players are in Town Hall 12. So clans like us are having a hard time competing and looking for siege donators. It makes competing with other clan unfair whenever they have siege machines. If siege machines are available in TH11, it will be widely accesible for town hall 10 too since reaching town hall 12 takes more time. I hope supercell will take this as a suggestion.
Why? It's already available in cc. Also it would make attacking a lot easier.
Villages can be 3 starred without siege machines. It had not been in the game for 6 years so were not th 10 and 11 villages 3 starred? It is an additional option.Quote:
Originally Posted by TerraIncognita
Not really. You don't get the point. There are a variety of attacks which can only be done using siege like electrone or miner hogs with siege barracks. The reason is for the enjoyment of the players. Yes you can three star a base without siege but why add a part of the game that is less accesible to most of the players?
You really don’t want to be able to donate siege machines constantly. They’re quite expensive and take some time to build.
But that’s not even the most important thing.
Every TH level should have something that encourages people to progress to the next TH level, especially when the higher TH levels are involved where the game becomes a little more difficult. TH11 has the warden and for TH12 it’s the siege workshop. By taking that away from Th12 you encourage some players to stay and permamax at TH11 which is an undesired effect. So personally I don’t think that’s a good idea at this point in the game.
Agree with Kaptain Kat. I see no need to change anything.
While I have heard some say this encourages rushing to 12 to get the SM, this would still be the case but with TH10’s rushing to 11 for them.
I understand the reason why. It's just getting hard to recruit more players because they always look for sieges. I have members who leave too just because of it which makes managing a clan more difficult because players won't join without a high level donator.
There should be things that is less accesible to most of the players because they pay for them like gold pass.Quote:
Originally Posted by TerraIncognita
Why do you try to recruit town hall 10’s. You can recruit players that have lower town halls.Quote:
Originally Posted by TerraIncognita
So recruit TH12 and higher. Stop accepting lower level players and your problem will be solved. People have been asking for your idea for almost 2 years and it's just not going to happen. It discourages players from upgrading their town hall and that goes against the entire goal of supercell. They want players to upgrade to the next town hall. Taking away the only incentive to upgrade to TH12 is not a good idea at allQuote:
Originally Posted by TerraIncognita
While I agree with the others that machines should not go down to 11, here are a couple suggestions.
1. Search request and go clans to see if you find one willing to donate machines. Some only donate junk troops so be careful to read the descriptions. Maybe someone better with forum search can find the need a machine thread that's been around for a while.
2. Rush an 11 to 12 and unlock machines. Make it clear they are for war only. Or rush a mini account to 12.
Becausebit isn't meant to be available to most of the players.Quote:
Originally Posted by TerraIncognita
Every Town Hall gets new things, not available to those beliw them. Siege engines were the main thing for TH12.
If you are trying to wzr with TH11 as the highest i yourclan, then yes, you may have issues. The solution to which is to upgrade at least one account to TH12. There probably aren't all that many warring clans now which have TH10 but no TH12+
Merged from 2 threads
My mini TH7 needs Archer Queen too, but what can we say, let's hope SC hears our request.
You get a new building at every town hall, something new that is special. Sieges happen to be the one for th12 here’s a list of town halls with the new buildings:Quote:
Originally Posted by darpan2704coc
-th1 Cannon + barracks
-th2 archer tower
-th3 mortar
-Th4 air defense
-th5 wizard tower + spell factory
-th6 air sweeper
-th7 hidden Tesla + dark barracks + barbarian king
-th8 bomb tower + dark spell factory
-th9 x-bows + archer queen
-th10 inferno towers + ability to carry sieges in cc
-th11 eagle artillery + grand warden
-th12 work shop + giga Tesla
-th 13 scatter shot + royal champion + giga inferno
So getting siege machines at th11 throws off the only new special building for th12, making no importance.
*EDIT*: added giga Tesla + inferno as Phoenix brought up but sieges are the main upgrade here.
^dont forget the giga tesla. But that doesn't even compare to how important the siege workshop is for incentivizing upgrading to TH12
There are 3 levels of siege work shop in th12. I like the idea of moving level 1 to th11. The building was introduced with th12 that's why it has always been there. I don't think balancing will be required as you can already use machine from cc.
Then people will want it at 10 too. You can use yetis and edrags at 10 in cc, should those be available to th10 and lower clans too? Personally, they never should have been made available to 10s in the first place. But that's water under the bridge. If a clan needs a 12, make one. It's been out for almost 2 years so needing machines is nothing new.Quote:
Originally Posted by Shadow199172