Do you make the grade? NEW Player Rating System idea

Thanks for taking notice.

We are proposing a Player Rating System to help ALL clans to weed out players who in one way or another who do not add value to your clan. People are very aware that there are clan hoppers, freeloaders(those who do not donate but request continuously), clan saboteur (as soon as receiving elder, kicking everyone), and inactive players that typically get kicked at some point and jump from clan to clan providing the same negative influence of deadweight on each unsuspecting clan they join.

i.e.:

Now what you know:

Bob1234
Lvl 92
Trophies 1457
Visit village

If we can get Supercell to add a simple player grading system:

Bob1234
Lvl 92
Trophies 1650
Clan Friendly Grade 67 (out of 100) based on complaints and kicks
Number of Clans Kicked from: 12
Number of Clans Attended: 47

There could be a list of boxes to check when you kick someone that stays permanently on record:

Please Check Reasons for Dismissing Player:

__ Does Not Donate/Freeloader
__ Does Not Donate Requested Troops
__ Inactive
__ Offensive Behavior
__ Clan Saboteur

These records could be kept and viewed before accepting any player as a member.

Thoughts? Other Suggestions along the same lines?

Thanks everyone. Happy Hunting.

Upper Decker
gold-n-goo

Very good idea, it is much needed :)

I hope we can encourage Supercell to get this done.

Great thread Deck! Anyone that makes the grade can apply at gold-n-goo we are mostly a farming clan that does a week long push every six weeks or so. Happy clashing!

Any additional thoughts on reasons why you don't want a player in your clan?

Ok then, so I can rate every player who doesn't join my clan a zero? This could be the new report button. I like the number of clans joined and kicked, but not the rest. Good thinking though :)

You would only be able to rate people who have been in your clan. Thanks for playing devil's advocate though.

Excellent ideas, can we get a "spy" option in the reasons for kicking thing. They join your clan screenshot bases (Usually for revenge attacks (but they could become common when we get clan wars) (So they know where traps and teslas are)) and then leave.

That would be a great check box addition King Dao. Thanks

+1
i like this idea, need to be careful of griefing though