Printable View
At first, starting a clan is hard, the invites are the hardest part. I, as a clan leader on my second account have so much trouble with this.
You can add an option to "insta-invite", this means that any player that they click will automatically be invited without having to go to their profile. This is huge for starting clans, as they can invite players significantly quicker.
<ruled out idea redacted>
It takes one click on the player and then one click on "invite".Quote:
Originally Posted by Ya7ioo
Indentifying donator is ruled out but darian mentioned that donation is pretty high on their todolist. It will most likely be the way that you can only donate the requested troops. That would eliminate wrong donations.Quote:
ANOTHER QoL improvement is to add a small button to the troops in the 'info' section in the clan castle, when clicked, this button shows who sent the donation.
Right, however there is a small delay to enter the profile, and that wouldn't be bad, however, leaders sometimes invite thousands of people into their clan, meaning that time wasted clicking on an extra button + the delay when you leave and enter the profile amounts to so much time wasted and also, the leaders get tired of pressing an extra button and waiting for a small delay, it seems small but over thousands of invites it takes a toll, simply clicking and scrolling would be way more convenient.
Have to look at it from both sides. If I am invited by a clan which did not even look at my profile, then they don't want me, rather they are looking for any and all warm bodies, casting out a wide net. So, no, let us not make it much easier for clans to mass spam players, inviting any and all players, flooding the players inbox with spam invites. That serves neither the player, nor the clan in my own opinion.Quote:
Originally Posted by Ya7ioo
Thousands of invites and you havent found 50 clashers that fit all together?Quote:
Originally Posted by Ya7ioo
Even if you’re starting a clan, you should want to look at their profile achievements anyway. It tells you a lot about the kind of player that person is. It’s not foolproof but can still give you a good idea.
Which, I believe, supports my conclusion. :saywhat:Quote:
Originally Posted by Ya7ioo
For 1,000 players for which there is no obvious match (if you took time to read their profiles), the total amount of time "wasted" by having to click twice is about 10 seconds per player, 1,000 players, equals 10,000 seconds, or 2.8 hours.
For 1,000 players to see the join request, look at your clan (see if it is a possible match), then delete the spam invite (assume 2 min total time) equals 2,000 wasted minutes, or 33.33 hours!
wotanwaton im not saying that i gave out thousands of invites but some poor leaders give a thousand invites or more, and they still dont get enough players or those players are inactive. and they might get tired of it so much they give up on the clan.
NOTE: for the first QoL its only an option, not forced.
Option set by the inviter (Clan Leader sending invites), or the invitee (those receiving the invites)? Can I, the player, prevent you and other clans from spamming my inbox? Yes, I want to see valid invites where the Leader took the time to assess that we may have mutual interest, and mutual benefit.Quote:
Originally Posted by Ya7ioo
But no, I don't want to be flooded with spam, junk mail, nor junk calls. Can the option allow me to block spammers, yet stay open to legitimate invites?
As I stated prior, it must be looked at in the players eyes, there are way more players than clans!!
Yes, recruitment can, and should be improved. But no, making spam invites easier is not a solution in my opinion.
You can put clan invitations in red if you don't want to receive invitation so I don't share your opinion.Quote:
Originally Posted by rowman
The point is that insta invite by just clicking on players is that the inviter doesnt check the profil and the player would get invited even if he wouldnt fit the play style of that clan.Quote:
Originally Posted by Tony85061704860Valdes
In addition there should be a notification if the invited player rejected the invite to stop constant spam invites from one clan.
Yet I clearly said: "Yes, I want to see valid invites where the Leader took the time to assess that we may have mutual interest, and mutual benefit.".Quote:
Originally Posted by Tony85061704860Valdes
The request in a nutshell is to allow fast spamming to be made easier for the spammer, flooding inboxes with spam invites. So no, a "solution" is not disable all invites. That is identical to saying "If you don't like junk calls, dump your phone; if you don't like junk mail, go off grid where you have no address".
In that I agree. That's why the current recruitment sistem has many flaws, and most, has to be fixedQuote:
Originally Posted by rowman
I actually have not thought of that, but yes. That can be an option too.
You have no thughts on your own thread? What can be an option?Quote:
Originally Posted by Ya7ioo
The sistem can put in the recruitment selections only the player that has connected in the last 24h,48h maybe or 72h but not players that has been inactive for 15 days. That could be an improvement option.
Agreed. I get enough players. I don't want spam players